Parking Madness 2018: Houston vs. Jacksonville

houston_jacksonville

Your NCAA bracket may be busted but we’ve got a fresh new Sweet 16 for you here at Parking Madness, Streetsblog’s annual tournament to name and shame the worst parking craters in America.

In the sixth year of this competition, there’s still no shortage of entries terrible enough to make the cut. We narrowed down to this field of 16 parking abominations from a batch of reader submissions that proved once again the supply of parking-scarred American cities is truly bottomless.

There are no second chances in Parking Madness — once a crater competes in the tourney, it can’t come back for another run at the title. But some cities have more than one parking atrocity, and to kick things off, we have two towns that have competed before. Houston and Jacksonville give us a classic match-up between a stadium parking bomb and a nasty urban redevelopment project.

Houston

houston_stadium_crater

Stadium parking craters have a long and storied tradition in this tournament, and Houston’s is one of the biggest. The sports venue and convention center cluster known as NRG Park (formerly Reliant Park) is 305 acres large, and most of that land is consumed by parking.

Like other forms of urban parking blight, sports stadium complexes are often subsidized to a scandalous degree. It’s hard to believe how much public money goes toward creating huge dead zones that generate large volumes of traffic on the rare occasion they’re in use. Houston has a lot of urgent rebuilding needs following Hurricane Harvey, and the powers that be think car storage is one of them: Harris County just approved $105 million to refurbish the Astrodome (where the Astros haven’t played in years), including … a 1,400-space garage.

Jacksonville

jacksonville_crater

This is what remains of the LaVilla neighborhood in Jacksonville, just west of downtown. Much of the area was razed in the 1990s, our anonymous submitter informs us, in a failed redevelopment scheme:

The proverbial phoenix has not risen from the ashes more than 20 years later and contains parking lots, empty fields (used as parking) and suburban style development within the city’s grid.

Some of these parking lots serve stations for the Jacksonville Transportation Authority’s “Skyway Express” — an automated monorail that, in the words of our nominator, moves people “from nowhere to… well, kinda nowhere.”

Vote below to decide which parking crater advances to round two.

parking_madness_2017

  • I went with Jxville because stadiums and convention centers are always so bad, almost without fail sitting in the middle of a dead zone of asphalt. (There are exceptions, and I’d like to see a run-off between GOOD stadiums.

    But the Jxville is so sad and wasteful, I had to give it the nod. Places where people live and play should not be just blobs of buildings plopped into parking lots.

  • gojoblogo

    There does not seem to be a vote button. Am I missing something?

  • whittx

    Jacksonville, since it is close to the center of town, while the Astrodome area is several miles from downtown.

  • rta

    That’s a very old picture of the LaVilla area of Jacksonville. There are numerous infill projects under construction on many of the empty blocks in that picture.

  • George Joseph Lane

    https://goo.gl/maps/trra78mngP42

    Stadiums don’t need any parking.

  • Is a tie possible? LOL!

  • TravGyse

    https://goo.gl/maps/trra78mngP42

    A European soccer stadium is an extreme example next to Houston. I always thought Cleveland did a decent job avoiding large surface parking lots near their two downtown stadiums.

  • Michael

    I was shocked when I traveled to Lambeau in Green Bay WI. I expecting a prolific parking crater. In fact, pretty minimal. Most folks just park on-street neighborhoods and walk a few blocks.

    https://www.google.com/maps/@44.5013881,-88.0686017,1797m/data=!3m1!1e3

  • troll e troll

    assuming you have proper transit… and are not in a major American city

  • KJ

    Houston got my vote because the ginormous parking lots are also blocking streets, i.e, you need to go AROUND them, whereas Jacksonville still has connecting streets.

  • Jason

    I’m leaning that way too—based on the images, the Jacksonville situation is more easily reversible than the Houston situation is.

  • Jason

    That’s definitely surprisingly tame as far as American football stadiums go. What I’m a little bit more surprised by is having something like that smack-dab in the middle of an area that looks, based on the satellite imagery, to otherwise be almost purely residential.

  • Michael

    Yes. It’s mostly modest single family housing, with some standard box commercial on the arterials. It’s distantly walkable (45 minutes-ish) from the stadium to the traditional downtown, which like most of the rust belt is somewhat paved-over but recovering. Seems to have a fair amount of old factories & warehouses that are being repurposed. It’s actually pretty “activated” for a small city.

    https://www.google.com/maps/@44.5172863,-88.0212262,3a,75y,13.98h,78.32t/data=!3m6!1e1!3m4!1sAecuYnolwDiRnzNhSpmO-Q!2e0!7i13312!8i6656

    For a football fan, I think it’s worth the pilgrimage.

  • George Joseph Lane

    Yeah, I’ve always been surprised by the parking craters in the US. I have travelled a lot (but never to the US) and never seen anything with even 1/4 of what that Houston stadium has. Most stadiums I have been to have *no* spectator parking. They have bus bays, drop off points, a few disabled parks, and train stations nearby.

    This is probably the worst example here in New Zealand, it’s just a completely different scale.

    https://goo.gl/maps/XjYdpLJgFBt

  • basenjibrian

    Looks better than 90% of small city urbanism in the rust belt! Am impressed!

  • In this comparison, Denver recently has begun trying to catch up with Green Bay. The currently nameless home of the Denver Broncos has always functioned with a tripod of surface parking, good transit service and walk distance parking controlled to protect residents to a degree. So it sits in a wasteland, just not Texas size.

    Plans are underway for development on the surface lots, though with plenty of multi-use structured parking. The new approach, given general support from adjacent neighborhoods, was made possible by the expansion of Colorado’s rail transit lines into suburban areas where many fans originate..

    A sample of the popularity of the rail access:
    https://youtu.be/Kf4HYSWZc3w

    in the toughest situation, an evening game overlapping with the rush hour.

  • Ian Turner

    Possibly blocked by your ad blocker.

  • W.O.W.! And that downtown has a fantastic building to parking ratio, particularly given the city’s size. Another reason, besides the cooperative ownership, to Go! You Packers Go!

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Parking Madness Final Four: Chicago vs. Jacksonville

|
We started with 16 parking craters and now we’re down to the Final Four of Parking Madness. After two bruising rounds of competition, four hideous parking expanses in Kansas City, Rochester, Chicago, and Jacksonville are still in it to win it. Each one is an ugly and awe-inspiring waste of potential in its own way. Today’s […]

Parking Madness: Atlanta vs Denver

|
In the race to the bottom that is Parking Madness, Streetsblog’s Sweet 16-style tournament of terrible downtown parking craters, 10 cities have faced off so far. But there are more, so many more awful parking wastelands in otherwise proud American cities. In this post, the match up is Atlanta versus Denver. Remember to cast your […]

Parking Madness: Minneapolis vs. Columbia, South Carolina

|
Today we’re getting a look at the last two contestants in Streetsblog’s Parking Madness bracket, the tournament that will “crown” the worst parking crater in the U.S. But don’t worry. Milwaukee, Tulsa, Dallas, Atlanta, Louisville, Cleveland, Houston, and today’s winner still need to do battle to determine the final victor. The final first round match-up […]