Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Barbara Boxer

Senate’s Changes to TIFIA Could Mean More Toll Roads, Less Transit

When the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee unanimously passed a two-year transportation reauthorization bill last month, it quickly became clear that bipartisan support was coming at a price. First, we learned that the Transportation Enhancements bike/ped programs would lose their dedicated funding. Now, we learn that Transportation Infrastructure Finance and Innovation Act (TIFIA) loans will no longer hold applicants to as high an environmental standard -- or any standard, really.

Will the "T" in TIFIA stand for "Toll road?" Photo: ##http://riversidechamber.files.wordpress.com/2011/03/tifia1.jpg## Greater Riverside Chamber

TIFIA is a popular program, receiving $14 billion in loan requests despite only being able to loan about $1 billion in total this year. And under current law, the extent to which the project "helps maintain or protect the environment" makes up 20 percent of a project's evaluation. In the EPW bill, the program is expanded by a factor of nine, but most evaluation criteria -- including environmental protection -- are omitted.

As Matt Sledge wrote in the Huffington Post:

Phineas Baxandall, a senior analyst at U.S. PIRG, said he thinks [EPW Chair Senator Barbara] Boxer may have cut a bad deal. He argues that doing away with TIFIA's selection criteria means the U.S. Department of Transportation will be forced to give money to any transportation project that meets bare-bones financial eligibility requirements [...] Toll roads, backed by private investors looking to make a buck off of "public-private partnerships," will be first in line, he argued, since they have plans that are "just ready to go off the shelf." [...]

Los Angeles hopes it will get some of that TIFIA money. Not so fast, Baxandall said. "Places like Atlanta and L.A. are hoping that the new bounty of TIFIA will allow them to finance public transit expansions, but they are likely to find the money already claimed by private toll road projects in places like Florida and Texas."

An LA Metro spokesperson told HuffPo he's still "pretty confident" they'll get TIFIA funds.

It's hard not to see this as a step backwards, despite the funding increase. It wasn't long ago that transit advocates were celebrating an end to the Bush-era's "cost-effectiveness-above-all-else" rule in the Federal Transit Authority's New Starts program. Now, Baxandall says, "at a time when the nation's transportation system is starved for funds and there is a consensus that dollars need to be spent more wisely, it is outrageous that the one program that would be massively increased would no longer try to deliver the best bang for each buck."

The good(-ish) news is that there's still time to make changes to the bill. The Senate Banking Committee still has to work on a transit portion, the Senate Finance Committee still has to figure out how to come up with another $12 billion, the whole Senate still has to debate it all, and the House still has to do... anything.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Tuesday’s Headlines Talk About ‘Fight Club’

One environmentalist told the New York Times that the Trump administration's assault on climate change measures resembles the 1999 movie starring Brad Pitt.

March 4, 2025

Could the Comeback of the Pedestrian Mall Start on Bourbon St.?

A recent terror attack has reignited an old conversation about pedestrianizing an iconic street — and whether other U.S. communities should do it, too.

March 3, 2025

Monday’s Headlines Were Caught on Tape

Eight states prohibit the use of speed cameras, and more could join them. The cameras work, but maybe banning them would encourage cities to focus on street design rather than enforcement.

March 3, 2025

Sean Duffy Makes Propaganda Film In Failed Attempt To Show Congestion Pricing Doesn’t Work

The Secretary is doubling down on the Trump administration's mistaken view that the toll is ineffective and a "cash grab" from "hard-working New Yorkers." Is it too much to ask that he clean off the camera lens?

February 28, 2025
See all posts