Parking Madness Final Four: Medford vs. Poughkeepsie

poughford

We’re in the semi-final round here at Parking Madness. We started off with 16 transit stations, each mired in a morass of parking, and now you can count the number that remain on one hand.

There are just five cities left in the running: Atlanta will face off tomorrow afternoon against the winner of the St. Louis vs. Denver match (voting is open until 2 p.m. Eastern Time on Wednesday), and Poughkeepsie and Medford do battle today.

Usually, the entries that do best in Parking Madness develop a hometown constituency that delivers a lot of votes, because a deep run can make for a good local news story and generate some momentum for policy reform. That seems to be the case with these two entries — smaller cities that beat out bigger competitors to get this far.

Which one will reach the final and a shot at the Golden Crater?

Medford, Massachusetts — Wellington T Station

Malden Parking Crater

This T station and its parking lots, outside Boston, overcame craters in Hartford and Toronto in earlier rounds of competition. An anonymous reader submitted this entry, supported with this description, which has carried it surprisingly deep in the tournament:

The station is sandwiched between a massive parking lot, a major highway and a train maintenance yard. There is also a parking garage just west of the station. I am not sure how any one from the neighborhoods north get to this station on foot/bike, and it is really too bad that using/being near the Malden and Mystic Rivers is almost impossible here.

Poughkeepsie

poughkeepsie_train_station

If there’s a Cinderella in this tournament, it’s Poughkeepsie. This upstate New York commuter rail terminus beat out unsightly parking craters in Fairfield and Queens in earlier rounds of competition.

Reader Jay Arzu says Poughkeepsie should be a walkable place, but…

Poughkeepsie was unfortunately hit with a large amount of urban renewal in the 1950s’ through 60s’. I attached a paper [PDF] explain exactly what happened. The Poughkeepsie Central Business District was ripped apart and replaced with large surface parking lots. The city is trying to redevelop them but I think that the public shame of Parking Madness will help the county help with the process.

Local officials have been working on a plan to remake this site with more walkable development. Here’s a look at what they have in mind:

Poughkeepsie Station development

So there you have it. Your vote will determine which of these contestants competes in the final.

Which city has the worst parking crater?

  • Poughkeepsie (56%, 121 Votes)
  • Medford (44%, 96 Votes)

Total Voters: 217

parking_madness_2017

  • Jeff

    Could you perhaps share this paper with a history of what happened to the Poughkeepsie CBD?

  • Patrick Jackson

    This is absolutely ridiculous. These are the two least bad parking craters in the entire competition, yet they somehow defeat very viable candidates and make the final four. Atlanta or Denver (hopefully Denver) better win this.

  • ocschwar

    The contest has gotten the attention of Medford residents, and since our new mayor is on a tear with new-urbanist projects, there’s a feeling the publicity will get her to do something about this crater, even though it indeed is not that bad.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

walden_toronto

Parking Madness: Toronto vs. Medford, Massachusetts

|
It's Parking Madness season at Streetsblog, and if you're just joining us, this year's competition is all about how we sabotage transit by surrounding stations with huge fields of parking. First round action continues today as Toronto takes on the Boston suburb of Malden. Vote for the worst to send it through to the round of eight.
hartford_medford

Parking Madness: Medford vs. Hartford

|
There are three spots up for grabs in this year's Parking Madness Final Four, as readers vote to determine which North American transit station is drowning in the most shameful sea of parking. In today's match, Hartford's central transit hub takes on a T station just outside Boston.
little_rock_atlanta

Parking Madness: Little Rock vs. Atlanta

|
Of all the places that have been marred by surface parking, the saddest might be city blocks served by transit, where walking should reign and driving should not be necessary. We're seeing in this year's Parking Madness tournament that there's an abundance of these places around the United States.