Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In

We've got a barn-burner for you today, but first, let's look back at where we are in our first round matchups:

parking madness 2019_dc pike

We've closed the polls on some earlier matchups, with Houston narrowly defeating Boston, Pittsburgh also squeaking by Portland, and Providence absolutely destroying Austin (we suppose that happens when an entire city is completely reimagined rather than just a developer building a nice building on a former parking crater).

But those earlier battles were just prologue for today's matchup featuring a neighborhood in our nation's capital against a piece of the heartland. Here goes:

DC-Pike

This entry comes from Friend of Streetsblog Maren Hill, who told us about the development of Pike & Rose, a new mixed-use neighborhood on the Rockville Pike in the DC suburb of Montgomery County:

The area was formerly a strip mall but has been redeveloped with pedestrian scale streets, public parks and artwork, and squares with street furniture and events. The area now includes condos and apartments, bars, restaurants, and retail (both chain and local), and offices, The building architecture is all unique so it doesn't look like some creepy model city project, it looks like an attractive walkable neighborhood.  Pike & Rose is on Metro, and has nearby existing and planned bike infrastructure.

Hill added that the neighborhood is "a great example of the suburbs doing transit oriented mixed-use redevelopment not infill development to transform their parking craters." The photos below tell the story:

Pike and Rose before and after
Indianapolis

This one comes to us from reader Austin Gibble, who called his Indianapolis submission a "most improved parking crater" and provided aerial and streetview imagery from 2014 and 2018.

"The additions include a transit center, a 28-story residential tower with a grocery store, apartments attached to the side of what was a single-use parking garage, and other mixed-use developments," Gibble said.

Indianapolis Streetview 2014
Indianapolis Streetview 2018
Indianapolis Aerial 2014
Indianapolis Aerial 2018

So who will move on? Vote below:

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Wednesday’s Headlines Are Graded on a Curve

Maybe one reason the U.S. has so many traffic deaths is that it's so easy to get a driver's license compared to other countries.

November 12, 2025

GOP Pol: ‘No Money for Bikes or Walking’ in Fed Transportation Bill

The outlook for active transportation won't be good if advocates don't stand up.

November 12, 2025

Mobility in Rural America: How India’s Popular Transportation Can Be A Model For US Transit Deserts

Lower ridership after Covid, combined with ongoing transit budget cuts, has caused a significant decrease in frequent and reliable public transit service for small and rural communities. Here's one way to fill the gap.

November 11, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines Are Burning Up

On climate change, the gap is growing between what governments are promising and doing, and neither is enough.

November 11, 2025

We Haven’t Saved Transit Yet: What Comes After Chicago’s Fiscal Cliff

On its own, more funding averts short-term disaster, but does nothing to solve our longer term transit issues. And while the governance reforms could lead to better service, there’s no guarantee of that.

November 10, 2025
See all posts