Sorry Bus Stops: San Rafael vs. Vancouver

San Rafael vs. Vancouver

We have a truly jaw-dropping set of bad bus stops for you today as we continue first round action in our Sorriest Bus Stop in America competition.

Today’s Sweet 16 match pits two West Coast contenders, one from the Bay Area and the other from Vancouver, B.C.

NashvilleCincinnatiBeverly HillsPittsburgh, and McKees Rocks have already advanced into the second round. Voting is still open in yesterday’s matchup: Miami vs. New Orleans. Now for today’s competition …

San Rafael, California

San Rafael bus stop

This bus stop, on Hwy 101 at Smith Ranch Road, was submitted by reader Kevin Carstens. He writes:

While the stop itself is nice (with a shelter and lighting), it is in a high capacity corridor (four-plus buses per hour throughout the day with extra during the peak hours; nine buses I think during the 6 p.m. hour). Despite this, it is sandwiched between ramps adjacent to a noisy eight-lane freeway with very poor connections to the surrounding areas. Riders have to tackle narrow sidewalks, dangerous and fast ramps, and lack of sidewalk amenities (curb ramps, lighting, … width…). In particular, look to the south of the stop, where a three-foot sidewalk crosses an off-ramp without any sort of signage or striping, pitting pedestrians against vehicles flying off the freeway. Additionally, while the matching southbound stop is only 250 feet away as the crow flies, it is 1,700 feet as the ped walks. Or 1,300 feet if a ped takes the dirt path shortcut from the southbound stop, across the off-ramp, to Lucas Valley Road.

Here’s an aerial view of this bus stop, which helps provide better perspective.

aerial san rafael

The stop is served by Golden Gate Transit and Marin Transit, it even has a park and ride, as you can see.

These agencies and Caltrans need to get together and figure out a way to make stops like this safer.

Pitt Meadows (near Vancouver), B.C.

vancouver bus stop

This hair-raising bus stop is located at Lougheed Highway and Old Dewdney Trunk Road in Pitt Meadows, on the outskirts of Vancouver. It was submitted by Jason Lee, who explains:

Lougheed Highway is a major arterial linking Vancouver’s exurbs with its inner-ring suburbs. It is also one of the most dangerous in British Columbia — ranking second in the entire province with 33 fatal crashes over the 10-year period between 2004 and 2013. Translink, Vancouver’s well-respected transit agency, has been investing a lot of service in suburban areas, with impressive ridership growth. The routes that serves Lougheed Highway — the 701 and express companion, the 791 — together provide service at least every 15 minutes or better, seven days per week, serving over 8,600 trips on an average weekday. Bus stop 61452 [pictured above], located in the westbound direction of Lougheed Highway and Old Dewdney Trunk Road, is a major safety hazard. At that point, Lougheed Highway consists of four lanes in each direction (one of which is a bus lane), with speeds of 50 mph or higher. The bus stop pole is located atop a jersey barrier, which serves as a buffer between speeding cars and the edge of the roadway. Transit riders are forced to either a) wait on the other side of the jersey barrier, and then climb over it when the bus arrives, or b) wait on the highway side of barrier, directly exposed to traffic. Riders in wheelchairs must wait on the highway side of the barrier. The roadway can also be slick; that part of British Columbia’s Lower Mainland receives nearly 58 inches of precipitation per year, most of it concentrated during the dark winter months. This bus stop is a disaster waiting to happen. In my three decades of riding transit, I have never seen a bus stop designed like this. During my journey on the 701 less than two weeks ago, I saw a group of people climb over the jersey barrier to get on the bus. They appeared to be non-English speakers who were carrying buckets of berries they had harvested, captive riders who could easily have become the latest victims of speeding cars along Lougheed Highway.

The highway in this case is managed by the British Columbia Ministry of Transportation. But the larger issue is clear: Sorry bus stops are not just a U.S. problem, eh?

bus_stop_2018

  • John Maier

    Vancouver!

  • Melanie Curry

    Hard to choose. These are both so awful. The San Rafael one seems to have been built to “speed up bus service” but what good is that if people have to risk so much to get to the stop? And the Vancouver one…holy moly

  • Bruce

    How can Vancouver contend for “America’s Sorriest Bus Stop”?

  • Why not?

  • planrb

    North America

  • Colby Spath

    Ummm…

  • Bruce

    It’s not called “North America’s Sorriest Bus Stop”. It’s called “America’s Sorriest Bus Stop”.

  • Robert Kania

    The San Rafael bus stop is a great idea with poor execution. They recently built a bus stop similar to that one in Illinois, just, ya know, better. https://goo.gl/maps/cvLfVkSJN2C2

  • dustinjamesfoster

    …so what you’re saying is, technically, this contest should also include South American cities, because America includes both South America and North American?

    …Or are you confused that people outside of the United States of America don’t call it America because it’s a specific country within the Americas and not the entirety of America?

  • Mark Lister

    Another bad one (pair) in Vancouver is in Richmond – a suburb just to the south of Vancouver. There are a pair of bus stops on the Knight Street bridge. Knight Street is a short 4-6 lane (2-3 lanes each direction) freeway that terminates on an arterial road once it reaches Vancouver.

    The bus stops are separated from traffic by short bus lanes, but have no seating or cover and require riders to cross off-ramps and walk the entire off-ramps to get to Mitchell Island below (or tromp through the deep grass in the off-ramp medians).
    https://www.google.com/maps/@49.2066951,-123.0774095,19.04z
    https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/450c8e10204976e53aa200361de46ac781f26e7af4f0656abcfe78ebf197920d.png

  • Bruce

    “America” means the United States. “North America” means the US, Canada, and Mexico.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

America’s Sorriest Bus Stop: Boston vs. Nassau County, NY

|
Our search for the sorriest bus stop in America — a virtual tour of the deplorable waiting conditions transit riders have to put up with — continues today with the third match in the round of 16. Last week, bus stops in Broomfield, Colorado, and St. Louis County beat out the competition from Portland, Oregon, and Kingsport, Tennessee. There are still […]