It’s Time for Cities to Rethink Right Turns on Red

Photo:  Bill Schultheiss
Photo: Bill Schultheiss

Legal right turns on red are practically a given at intersections from rural Oklahoma to urban Boston. But it wasn’t always so.

It wasn’t until the 1970s that allowing drivers to turn right during the red signal phase became common across the country, says Bill Schultheiss, a civil engineer at Toole Design Group who specializes in bike facilities.

Precipitated by the OPEC oil embargo, the Energy Policy and Conservation Act of 1975 required states to allow rights on red to receive certain federal funds. Decades later, every state in the U.S. allows rights on red everywhere — other than New York City — except when prohibited by signage.

Letting drivers turn on red can save gas, but there is a trade-off. Though recent studies are lacking, the body of research shows that allowing rights on red compromises safety for people who walk and bike.

Permitting rights on red increases pedestrian crashes by 60 percent and bike crashes by 100 percent, the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety found in the 1980s.

A 1995 NHTSA report [PDF] found that the number of right-on-red fatalities was relatively small — about 84 a year — but that 44 percent of the victims were pedestrians, and another 10 percent were bicyclists. Over the 11-year study period, the report stated that 924 people were killed in right-on-red crashes. More than 500 of those killed were people walking and biking.

Injury figures were much higher. For instance, in right-on-red crashes in Indiana, Maryland, and Missouri between 1989 and 1992, injuries occurred at 100 times the rate of fatalities.

With U.S. pedestrian fatalities rising year after year, Schultheiss says it’s time to rethink right-on-red as the default in densely populated places where lots of people walk.

“Should there be right turn on red in a central business district where there’s a whole lot of pedestrians?” Schultheiss said. “It doesn’t make a lot of sense.”

Schultheiss has been doing some work on H Street in Washington, a walkable corridor where the city has made major investments, including the DC streetcar. But though traffic is so intense that right turns on red are practically impossible, it’s still technically allowed. As a result, pedestrians must constantly watch for motorists attempting to turn, often while blocking a crosswalk.

Since it challenges 40 years of bad design habits, Schultheiss said prohibiting rights on red is “a paperwork nightmare,” so engineers are “reluctant to do it.”

“It’s just another example where we prioritize mobility over safety,” he said.

213 thoughts on It’s Time for Cities to Rethink Right Turns on Red

  1. Independent Escort in Delhi When you are finished with the choice, call us and get master for the astonishing exciting ride siphon. They are instructed, sense and open slanted. Legitimately after the factor age’s starting, they have tended to clients with high statuses and the profiles. In the install, in the midst of the stupendous show, you can expect flying the deflect from our young ladies.
    https://nataliakapoor.in/

  2. It is totally protected as each one of the young women required in these has a place with the incredible family establishment and are proficient on the most ideal approach to acting with people and how to work together with clients who are here to secure certified sentiments of peacefulness.

  3. We were taught to pull over into the bike lane if you are going to turn right on red. Bikers know this and still speed thru a red light. I am a biker but this is a two way street. Bikes were here before cars and then cars got the roads. Annoying but no excuse for bikers not to pay more attention to their riding environment as if their life depends on it, it does. I am so sorry for any accident.

  4. lene Lorenzo, 14, and her sister Amy, 12, were walking to Clinton Middle School in South Los Angeles around 7:50 a.m. on April 4 when they were struck by 31-year-old Stanley Bernard Randle who was driving a double bottom dump truck that was making a right turn in the marked crosswalk.

  5. Marlene Lorenzo, 14, and her sister Amy, 12, were walking to Clinton Middle School in South Los Angeles around 7:50 a.m. on April 4 when they were struck by 31-year-old Stanley Bernard Randle who was driving a double bottom dump truck that was making a right turn in the marked crosswalk.

  6. @Hayley Mills Who is “we” and taught by whom? If the bike lane is dashed then yes you can pull into it if it’s solid then don’t.

  7. I suggest making drivers who either ignore school bus stop arms or who ignore No Turn on Red signs do community service as school crossing guards or pedestrian crossing guards in an area with many elderly and disabled pedestrians. Then they may finally understand how their arrogant and dangerous driving affects others.

  8. Best escorts with festival however she is greatest for attendance the get-together and long trip where you find professional escorts who forever stand with you and with the help of her magnificence and contact you whole your lots of deals and appear as a charming person. That is origin that our college scholar escorts and effective escorts exchange the people attention and when they go someplace or approach in this attractive city they repeatedly prefer to get together Worli escorts service forever care of their thoughts and employ that type of high-quality splendor who now not only create them comfy but also she complete their special works who exclusively carried out by capital of an expert escorts.

  9. We provide online Assignment help Sydney to the students of University of Sydney, University of New South Wales, Sydney Law School, Sydney College of Arts, Sydney Nursing School and UNSW Business School. Our experts are available for more than 100 subjects to help the students in their writing when they search for Sydney Assignment help

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Florida Invites Motorists to Bully Pedestrians

|
Oh, Florida. Already the most dangerous place in the country to be a pedestrian, Sunshine State officials have said they want to make walking safer. But then along comes a story like this. Keri at Network blog Commute Orlando reports the legislature recently passed a law that encourages right-turning motorists to infringe on crosswalks, saying […]