Cities Want to Save Lives With Lower Speed Limits, But States Stand in the Way

Image: City of Seattle
Image: City of Seattle

Austin’s City Council voted this week to lower speed limits on residential streets from 30 mph to 25. In doing so, the city joins a growing number of cities moving to save lives by reducing default speed limits. But like those cities, Austin needs help from the state legislature to realize its plans.

Vehicle speeds are a leading factor in traffic injuries and deaths. The odds of a pedestrian surviving the force of a car collision start to plummet as the impact speed exceeds 20 mph. Traveling at 20 mph also gives a motorist much more leeway to react and avoid collisions in the first place.

Austin is taking steps to get drivers to travel at safe speeds as part of its Vision Zero effort, which aims to eliminate traffic deaths by 2025. Currently, more than 60 people are killed in traffic on Austin streets in a typical year. In addition to lowering speed limits, the City Council wants local transportation officials to design streets for safer traffic speeds.

But Austin’s vote was largely symbolic. Like a number of other Texas cities — including Houston, Fort Worth, and San Antonio — Austin needs enabling legislation from the state legislature to permit 25 mph residential speed limits. In the meantime, the city can only establish slower speed limits on a pilot basis. Expensive studies must be conducted before the city can lower speed limits on individual streets.

These obstacles are not limited to Texas. Boston has voted twice to lower default speed limits to 20 mph. But like most cities, Boston needed the state legislature to sign on too.

Leah Shahum of the Vision Zero Network, which advocates for policies to reduce traffic deaths and injuries, says state permission is a key obstacle to traffic safety that cities have to deal with.

“This is the most impactful way states can support local Vision Zero goals — give locals the flexibility they need to manage speed to safe levels,” she said. “This is what it’s all about when it comes to saving lives on our roadways.”

“It is proven that managing speed is, by far, one of the most effective ways to keep people safe on our streets,” Shahum adds. “Any community that is serious about Vision Zero must get serious about managing speeds. This includes setting speed limits at appropriate levels in cities where we know people are walking and biking, as well as driving.”

Some cities have succeeded in getting state permission to lower default speed limits.

Months after Boston voted to lower speed limits, Massachusetts Lawmakers voted in August to let the cities decide what was best for them. The default speed limit in Boston will be lowered to 25 miles per hour next month.

New York City also convinced the state legislature and Governor Andrew Cuomo to allow the city to reduce default speed limits from 30 mph to 25 in 2014. Not only was Mayor Bill de Blasio fresh from an election campaign in which he promised to rapidly reduce traffic deaths, but the legislation had powerful support from Families for Safe Streets — people who had lost loved ones to traffic violence and personally spoke to state legislators about the importance of curbing traffic speeds.

Portland wants to systematically reevaluate speed limits on its streets. The city appears to have the support of the key Oregon official whose approval is necessary to move forward.

In 2013, a multi-year campaign by Washington Bikes led to passage of a state law that gave local governments more control of regulating traffic speeds on their streets. Thanks to that law, this year Seattle was able to lower its default speed limit on neighborhood streets to 20 mph.

These stories should give hope to Austin and other cities looking to save lives with lower speed limits. With smart, persistent advocacy, street safety campaigns can win at the state level when the political opportunity presents itself.

Correction: The article originally reported the Massachusetts Legislature had not voted to allow Boston to lower speed limits. They moved to allow cities and towns to lower speed limits this summer. 

  • Alicia

    Fascinating comment. I never realized that my community of under 50k residents had become a “big city”.

  • Lincoln

    You have obviously never been to New York City.

  • Todd

    I have, all five boroughs. Car use is less in Manhattan, otherwise I’d say the 90% number holds up.

  • Lincoln

    Staten Island doesn’t even reach 90%!
    (But unlike any of the other boroughs, it is somewhat close to that at 84%)

  • Todd

    How do you count that 84%?

    Do you mean 84% of residents of driving age have a car? Or a license?

    Or is it 84% of people live in a household that has a car?

  • Lincoln

    84% of households have a car.

  • Todd

    OK, so repeating the question, where are the votes in denying rights to 84% of voters?

  • Lincoln

    Staten Island is not where the majority of the city lives.

  • fdtutf

    Fun having to spell all this out, isn’t it? 😛

  • Todd

    Of course there are reasons on both sides of the debate. But you only really know when people get to vote. Reduce mortality is a worthy goal but so is capacity and throughput. We have conflicting goals

  • Lincoln

    Maximum capacity and throughput entails reducing automobile throughput and reallocating the capacity to higher capacity means of transportation.

  • Todd

    I meant for private vehicles, which is back to the 84% number.

  • Lincoln

    The 84% number which only refers to Staten Island and does not take into account either the fact that many people in households with cars do not use cars and the fact that many households with cars barely use them.

  • Todd

    Outside of Manhattan and parts of SF, is there anywhere in the US where more than 50% of voters do not rely on a car at least some of the time?

  • Lincoln

    Yes. Brooklyn and the Bronx for sure. Quite possibly Queens. Quite likely some in New Jersey as well.


Seattle Moves to Lower Neighborhood Speed Limits to 20 MPH

Seattle is getting serious about reducing the threat of lethal motor vehicle speeds. The city is moving to lower speed limits on neighborhood streets from 25 mph to 20 mph later this year. On big arterial streets, the city will determine speed limits on a case-by-case basis, but the default will be reduced from 35 mph to […]

The Problem With Speed Cameras That Don’t Catch Most Speeders

Residents of urban neighborhoods across the country are increasingly advocating for lower speed limits and automated traffic enforcement. As the above graphic illustrates, the stakes are high for pedestrians. But in some jurisdictions where speed cameras are in use, motorists can drive much faster than the speed limit without penalty. In New York, for instance, […]

Boston Wants to Lower Its Speed Limit to 20 MPH — But Can’t

Twenty is plenty in Boston, according to its elected officials. The City Council voted unanimously this week to lower the default speed limit on most residential streets to 20 mph — and not for the first time. Speeding is the number one complaint council members hear from residents. And on Boston’s narrow streets, packed with pedestrians, […]