Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
asdf
"Excess wait time" -- or how long riders have to wait beyond the scheduled time between buses -- captures the inconvenience of unreliable transit better than on-time performance metrics that many agencies prefer to use. Graphic: NYC Bus Data API
false

When you're riding the bus or the train, an unexpected delay is the last thing you need. If transit agencies want to know how well they're doing and how they can improve service, they have to track how reliable their service is for riders.

But not all reliability metrics are created equal, writes TransitCenter. Some agencies track their performance in a way that's much less rider-friendly than others:

At the moment, the [New York] MTA and many other agencies tend to use indicators of success that reflect the concerns of the people who actually run subway or other systems. These include on-time performance and the average distance a train car travels between mechanical problems.

But those measurements might not actually indicate whether the agency is delivering good service to riders. For example, regarding subway delay, the MTA relies heavily on a performance metric known as “wait assessment,” defined as the percentage of train arrivals that cause passengers to wait at least 25 percent longer than expected.

Wait assessment has two major problems. First, it is not obvious what it means to have a “good” wait assessment score. If the A train has a wait assessment score of 85 percent, what does that mean for riders? Second, wait assessment is indifferent to how late a train is or how many riders are affected by its lateness. On a line with service every four minutes, a gap of six minutes between trains in the Bronx at 6 A.M. is equally as “bad” as a gap of 15 minutes between trains passing through Grand Central at rush hour.

TransitCenter says Boston's MBTA has adopted a metric more in line with international best practice, one that captures what matters to riders:

There is already a performance metric that does a much better job than wait assessment. It’s called excess wait time, or EWT for short.

EWT measures how much extra time passengers wait for a train or bus compared with the ideal scenario of every vehicle running at scheduled frequencies. This gives it major advantages over wait assessment.

For starters, EWT records delay in minutes rather than as a percentage, which captures the problem of delay for riders much more accurately and intuitively. As a result, long gaps in service that cause big rider delays are weighted more heavily than small delays. Additionally, EWT weights delay by the number of people affected, so a service problem during rush hour counts as a bigger negative than an equivalent service delay on Sunday morning.

Not only has Boston moved toward a more rider-centric metric, it's working on publishing the data in an open format. TransitCenter has supported the development of a data tool to assess the reliability of New York City's bus routes based on the EWT standard. The more agencies that collect this data, release it an open format, and use it to improve service, the better.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Greater Greater Washington reports the extension of the D.C. Streetcar may have dedicated lanes -- addressing a key shortcoming of the existing project. Bike Portland notes that drive-alone rates are falling in greater Portland, even in suburban areas. And The Political Environment considers whether Great Lakes states outside of Wisconsin will use their authority to stop a plan divert Lake Michigan water to a sprawling Milwaukee suburb.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

The ‘One Big Beautiful Bill’ Is About Our Transportation Future, Too

Transportation didn't get a lot of mention in the public discussion of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. But it's everywhere.

July 8, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines of Many Colors

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy called rainbow crosswalks "a distraction" and called on cities to eliminate them.

July 8, 2025

Form-Based Codes Mean More Sustainable Cities

New research shows that prioritizing building "form" over their use leads to more sustainable cities.

July 8, 2025

Monday’s Headlines Are Big and Beautiful

The ginormous GOP tax and spending bill President Trump signed on July 4 will make the air dirtier, a lot of it from tailpipe emissions.

July 7, 2025

The Single Most Important Element In Creating Good Cities

A lot of U.S. cities are getting their "right of way" all wrong — and urbanists can help by getting to know this poorly-understood concept.

July 7, 2025

Reclaiming Streets from ICE with Music, Dance, Altars, Mutual Aid, Community, and Resistance

The Mariachi Plaza event was one of four held across LA. Tuesday night. The June 19 abduction of street vendor Emma de Paz from the Hollywood Home Depot was a touchstone of the Eastside gathering.

July 4, 2025
See all posts