Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Amtrak

How Federal Rules Make It Harder to Build Trains in America

3:57 PM EDT on April 12, 2016

Former U.S. Secretary Ray LaHood at the Nippon Sharyo plant near Chicago, when the contract was awarded in 2012. Photo: U.S. DOT
Former U.S. Secretary Ray LaHood at the Nippon Sharyo plant near Chicago in 2012, when the company was awarded a contract to build 130 railcars. Photo: U.S. DOT

The Wall Street Journal's Bob Tita broke the news yesterday that the manufacturer of 130 new Amtrak railcars is years behind schedule, and probably won't complete the order before the federal funding for it expires. How did this happen?

The 130 double decker railcars were approved for purchase in the 2008 stimulus package, destined for service in the Midwest and California. But the terms of the $352 million contract awarded to Nippon Sharyo, an American subsidiary of a Japanese rail company, made it impossible to complete on time. The company now says it won't begin construction of the trains until 2018, when the order was supposed to be completed.

The problem can be traced to two regulations: a strict "Buy America" manufacturing requirement and the Federal Railroad Administration's unusual safety rules.

The 2008 stimulus bill included a Buy America provision that compelled the winning bidder to build its trains "entirely in the U.S. with domestically sourced components and materials," Tita reports.

Problem is, America doesn't have much of a domestic passenger railcar industry, in part because the passenger train market is pretty small. To comply with the law, the Japanese company had to set up a subsidiary in the U.S. and build a brand new $100 million plant. That was the easy part.

What turned out to be more difficult was acquiring needed components that were made in the U.S. Nippon Sharyo appealed to Caltrans, which is overseeing the project, for an exemption to source these from Japan, according to Tita.

Compounding the difficulty of sourcing the parts is that Nippon Sharyo has to construct a railcar model that has never been built before. That brings us to the second problem.

Nippon Sharyo ran up against the FRA's infamous crashworthiness standards, which "Nippon Sharyo’s car hasn’t been able to pass," reports Tita. As a result, the company is going to have to spend the next few years reengineering the body.

America's mandate for railcars that can withstand these crash tests is unusual, and it makes trains more expensive to build and operate without actually making them safer. In a classic post at Bike East Bay, Eric McCaughrin likened the FRA to "the soccer-Mom who thinks an SUV provides greater safety, the FRA figures collisions are inevitable and heavier is better."

It's not just Nippon Sharyo that's having trouble filling orders for U.S. traincars. A Spanish company that won the bid to construct 130 railcars for Amtrak in 2005 is well behind schedule after 400 defects were discovered in the first 28 baggage cars it rolled out, Tita reports.

Responding to the Wall Street Journal, an FRA spokesperson indicated the agency isn't willing to relax its rules: “The Federal Railroad Administration is committed to its investment in high-quality and safe passenger rail cars. And we are committed to the jobs the project has and will create.”

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

To Help Save the Planet, Take the ‘Week Without Driving’ Challenge

Sierra Club President Ramón Cruz is urging Americans to give up driving for seven days — and support policies to make it optional for everyone.

September 29, 2023

Friday’s Headlines Are Charged Up

Expect a lot fewer ordinary gas stations and a few more Buc-ee's in your area as the electric vehicle transition continues.

September 29, 2023

Talking Headways Podcast: Beyond Greenways

This week we’re joined by Bob Searns to talk about his new book and grand ideas for walking trails that circle whole regions and more local routes that make up a new mode of green infrastructure in cities.

September 28, 2023

Thursday’s Headlines Are Inside Out

Cars and trucks are getting safer for drivers and passengers, but people outside the vehicles are increasingly in danger.

September 28, 2023

New Federal Committee Will Push for Transportation Equity By Helping DOT Reckon With Its Past

“No one alive today is necessarily responsible for the origins of the [transportation] inequities that we inherited. But everybody who was alive today and in a position of responsibility, is accountable for what we do about it. That's why we're here.” 

September 28, 2023
See all posts