Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
"Accidents"

Even When a Driver Intentionally Causes Mayhem, Media Call It an “Accident”

A witness described seeing the driver of this Prius back up intentional over the other car, but CBS LA improperly persisted in referring to this as an "accident." Image: CBS LA
A witness described seeing the driver of this Prius intentionally back up over the other car, but CBS LA persisted in referring to it as an "accident." Image: CBS LA
A witness described seeing the driver of this Prius back up intentional over the other car, but CBS LA improperly persisted in referring to this as an "accident." Image: CBS LA

The New York Police Department stopped using the term "accident" to refer to car collisions because it conveys the "connotation that there is no fault or liability." In the press, however, "accident" remains standard practice, even when a driver rams another person on purpose.

The Safe Roads Alliance, an organization that promotes safe driving, tracked down five examples just from the last few weeks where media outlets referred to intentional collisions as "accidents" (the reports also tend to say the crashes were perpetrated by vehicles, not the human beings who drive them). Here are the pieces they sent along, with the headline that ran with each story.

Seattle Times: "Road Rage Incident Leaves 1 Dead on I-5"

According to the Seattle Times, the driver of a Chevy SUV pulled in front of the driver of Dodge Neon on I-5, apparently enraged at his slow speed. The SUV driver proceeded to "brake check," causing the collision. A 23-year-old passenger in the Neon was killed, and three others were injured. Both drivers are being charged with vehicular homicide, and yet the Seattle Times goes on to say: "The State Patrol is seeking information regarding the accident."

WHIO: "I-70 Crash: Wrong-Way Driver Had a Criminal Past"

A 35-year driver was killed after going the wrong way on an Ohio freeway and colliding with a semi-truck. A witness to the crash reported the driver, Chris A. Coleman, appeared bent on suicide, speeding through a U-turn in the highway median and then driving into the path of the semi. Nevertheless, WHIO twice refers to the collision as an "accident" in its report.

CBC News North: "Whitehorse Police Seek Driver Involved in 'Road Rage' Collision"

The original report from the Canadian Broadcasting Company referred to a hit-and-run road-rage collision as an "accident." The crash apparently followed a verbal altercation and short chase, and was the result of brake-checking. After a commenter objected to the use of the word "accident," the language has since been changed on this one, so good on the CBC.

CBS Los Angeles: "Did Road Rage Lead to Prius Piggybacking Another Car?"

This article, about the collision shown above, includes testimony from a witness saying the Prius driver intentionally backed over the other car. That person is referred to as "a witness to the accident."

Aspen Daily News: "Murder Suspect May Have Tried to Kill Himself in Car Accident"

Pin this one on the headline writer. Arturo Navarrete-Portillo was badly injured in a wreck in mid-February. Reports about the incident unsealed this week revealed that Navarrete-Portillo had essentially admitted that he intentionally tried to harm himself in the crash, according to the Aspen Daily News. Still, the news outlet call it an "accident."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Streetsblog Joins Campaign for Public Financing of Non-Profit Media

New York provides tax credits to for-profit newsrooms. Now, non-profit digital outlets, public broadcasters and public access channels are seeking equal treatment. Doing so would strengthen our democracy.

December 26, 2025

Opinion: Why Urbanists Should Support Plant-Forward Policies 

Your plate is political, just like your choice to pedal instead of drive. And often, transportation and food politics have powerful intersections.

December 26, 2025

Thursday’s Headlines: Merry Christmas Edition

We're off today, and we wish you a very Merry Christmas!

December 25, 2025

Don’t Believe the Hype: NJ Turnpike Widening Still Happening

Gov. Murphy's late revision will just move the problem around, advocates say.

December 24, 2025

Opinion: Can AI Help Stop Car Crashes Before They Happen?

Proactive safety planning can save more lives than waiting until after crashes kill. But what's the proper role of technology in identifying future hot spots?

December 24, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines Have a Clean Background

Uber isn't doing everything it can to keep violent felons out of the driver's seat, according to the New York Times.

December 24, 2025
See all posts