Rochester Wins 2014 Parking Madness Title and Claims the Golden Crater


An asphalt scar in Rochester, New York, has triumphed over 15 of the world’s worst parking craters to become the Parking Madness 2014 champion.

It was a surprising run. Who would have guessed a couple of weeks ago that this scrappy upstart would prevail over some of the sprawliest, most highway-marred urban spaces in North America? But a devout group of locals, recognizing the advocacy potential, helped push Rochester past Miami, and then Detroit, and then Kansas City, and finally Jacksonville, all the way to the Golden Crater. Quite the Cinderella story.

When we closed voting at 2 p.m. Eastern time today, Rochester was several lengths ahead of Jacksonville, leading 611 to 165. The Rochester parking crater joins last year’s winner, downtown Tulsa, in the annals of Parking Madness infamy.

Here’s the crater that swept to victory:


Kansas City may have had a bigger crater. Detroit’s may have been emptier. But the Rochester crater packed an extra wallop because we also got to see what was lost:


Matthew Denker, the Rochester expat who submitted this entry, said the winning site stood out to him for a couple of reasons.

“It used to be a real neighborhood,” he said. “It used to be a downtown. There was a beautiful park there that got cut in half by a highway.”

He said Rochester has its share of parking scars, but here, “there’s nothing to even drive to anymore. There’s a four point intersection with nothing on the corners.”

Mike Governale, who writes at Rochester Subway and leads the local advocacy group Reconnect Rochester, rallied the local troops to vote for their hometown crater.

“I get a lot of people asking me, ‘Why are you promoting this?'” he said, noting that it doesn’t present a very positive image of the city. “But I see this as a tool. I think we can use this going forward, get more people involved. We can go to our policy makers and say, ‘Is this the image you want out there?’ Because if it’s not, we need to plan a little bit better.”

Governale pins the blame for this eyesore not so much on city officials, but on the lack of coordinated regional action to promote a healthy city. Most people opt for driving because it’s relatively easy compared to the local transit system, and parking is cheap, he said.

Two mayoral administrations ago, he said, a detailed plan was produced to develop a downtown circulator bus system, but it has been sitting on a shelf collecting dust.

“I love Rochester,” Governale said. “I think Rochester can be better and I think a more diverse public transit system could really help unlock Rochester’s potential.”

22 thoughts on Rochester Wins 2014 Parking Madness Title and Claims the Golden Crater

  1. Congratulations to Rochester. Well deserved. I hope I can get up to Rochester for the award ceremony. LOL!

  2. If you do go up, just make sure you take the train or bus. I’ve heard it’s impossible to find parking!

  3. This remains an excellent photo, and I regret not taking it and adjusting it as an overlay to the current aerial photo. It’s something I intend to do in the near future.

  4. Thank you. I’d like to advocate for alternative modes of transportation to Rochester (I frequently take the train from NYC), but it’s hard to argue with how easy it is to drive and park there.

    Hopefully we can change that a little (or make it just as easy to park for notably less cars).

  5. To all the Rochester supporters, thank you. To all the other cities, your parking craters are also terribad, and I really hope that they can all be filled in quickly. Cities exist for people, not as Automobile Daycares. It’s time for a change, everyone. Let’s make it together.

  6. Yikes. So sad for Rochester. Unfortunately it’s not a story unique to Rochester either. Most of my extended family grew up in the Rochester area, but they all got out and moved to cities with better accessibility and transit once they had the opportunity, even though a couple of them were working for Kodak at the time. Having no urban life and no transportation options will make you reconsider even the best job ever.

  7. Congrats/regrets to Rochester, indeed. For next year’s contest, here is a suggestion: let the actual NCAA schools in the tournament compete for campus parking crater awards. I’d guess most would be as competitive as their host cities, alas. There is still a relentless demand for cheap or free, abundant, convenient parking at most schools. Bigger universities are small cities unto themselves, too.

  8. Back in 1983, I drove from Long Island to Rochester and left my car with a friend doing his Ph.D. at U of R (mathematics) as theirs was dead. They dropped me off in Buffalo to visit family and had the use of my car for a few days. I rode my bicycle back to Rochester (NY 33 to 33A to 204 into 19th Ward) to their house. It was actually pretty undramatic. Wonder if it still would be so undramatic. Back then, bicycling was no big deal.

  9. Here is another for Detroit next year. These Atwater parking lots are on the water and GM world headquarters is just to the left of the map, Blue Cross/Blue Shield(HQ) is just to the north. Also the infamous I-375 ends at the top of the pic. Notice there are 3 7+story parking ramps with one at the one end of the large parking craters(who does it serve blocks from anything?) If you go to street level, you will notice they only charge $3 a day for parking 3 blocks from GMs world headquarters! A destination for many of auto part supplier sales executives. Bonus though at the far right, a new development of mix use townhouses and retail is about to start.,-83.0347122,578m/data=!3m1!1e3!4m2!3m1!1s0x883b2cd1bc539913:0x37383e7e19c46e3b

  10. Probably not the best example globally speaking, but for a town with a population of 75,500 (2011) in little old New Zealand this is a big change. Got to love big-box retail and the asphalt-awesomeness that goes with it…

  11. When I was in Grad School at Florida State, one of my running complaints was that the school kept building parking garages without charging a premium for parking spaces for drivers. Even Brockport recognized that parking was a commodity with a value, instead of a god given right for students.

  12. One needs to have perspective. One should also take into account Highland Park. I say this not to minimize this particular parking mishap, but because people who are unfamiliar with Rochester may be misled to believe that it is not a fantastic little city with perhaps the world’s best park. OK, I love Lilac Sunday so I’m biased. Nonetheless, we have fine old residential neighborhoods with some great associations. But for the endless gray skies all winter long, and I do mean long, Rochester could be the best place in America. But if we had great weather, then people would flock here and destroy what we have.

    I recall when Rochester had a subway. I rode the subway. Get real! The only people who benefit from the subway are the people who get rich building it

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


Parking Madness: Send Us Pics of Parking Lots Where Your City Should Be

Does your city have what it takes to compete in Streetsblog’s fourth annual Parking Madness tournament? Who will join Tulsa, Rochester, and Camden, NJ, as winners of the coveted “Golden Crater”? We’re looking for 16 parking scars blighting American downtowns. One will advance through our bracket to achieve lasting infamy — and hopefully some hometown coverage that […]

Parking Madness Final Four: Kansas City vs. Rochester

The hunt for the worst parking crater on earth nears its epic conclusion with the second Final Four match of Parking Madness. Today’s matchup features a formidable entry from Kansas City and the upstart parking crater from Rochester, New York, which knocked out Detroit in the previous round. The winner will take on Jacksonville tomorrow for […]

Parking Madness Final Four: Chicago vs. Jacksonville

We started with 16 parking craters and now we’re down to the Final Four of Parking Madness. After two bruising rounds of competition, four hideous parking expanses in Kansas City, Rochester, Chicago, and Jacksonville are still in it to win it. Each one is an ugly and awe-inspiring waste of potential in its own way. Today’s […]

Parking Madness 2015: Can Your Parking Crater Compete?

  March is a special month on Streetsblog. It’s the time when the nation’s worst downtown parking scars face off head-to-head for the shame of winning the “golden crater” — and the local publicity bonanza that comes with it. For the third year running, we’re asking you to help seed the bracket in our Parking […]

Parking Madness: Rochester vs. Miami

We’re seeing all sorts of parking craters as the 2014 Parking Madness tournament rolls on: pockmarked craters, endless abysses, deep caverns. Excess parking in cities takes many forms. And so we ask you to help us judge which is the worst, using the only method that can be applied consistently across all parking craters — online […]