Parking Madness: Rochester vs. Miami

We’re seeing all sorts of parking craters as the 2014 Parking Madness tournament rolls on: pockmarked craters, endless abysses, deep caverns. Excess parking in cities takes many forms. And so we ask you to help us judge which is the worst, using the only method that can be applied consistently across all parking craters — online polling.

Up today, we have a wintry northeastern burgh and a sunny Florida metropolis: It’s Rochester vs. Miami.

Let’s start off with Rochester:

rochester

Submitter Matthew Denker describes the empty heart of this grotesque parking cluster: “It’s an intersection with surface parking at all 4 corners. There is literally no reason to have a road here when it’s just a sea of parking. Even better (worse) you can see a massive parking garage on the left edge on the same block, and if you move just a hair north, you can see a park that was cut in half by a highway. And of course the area used to be the main square of Rochester and where the town Christmas tree was raised.”

Interestingly, Rochester recently received some funds to fill in portions of the Inner Loop highway, shown at the very top. Unfortunately, it’s not this part of town that will see the improvement, says Denker.

Now, on to Miami:

miami

Submitter Rob Wag tells us these shadowy, cavernous craters are made worse by their location: “Million dollar parking views, overlooking the Miami River and Biscayne Bay.”

Perhaps there’s hope for Miami, however, as some developers are constructing new residential towers with no on-site parking whatsoever.

parking_madness_2014_6

Which city has the worst parking crater?

  • Rochester (91%, 474 Votes)
  • Miami (9%, 47 Votes)

Total Voters: 519

Loading ... Loading ...
  • Vernon6

    The scrub parcel in Miami is not really a parking lot. It was recently purchased by a developer for like $40 million. It’s temporary storing cars that are working on a adjacent project.

  • Justin Peterson

    Not only is Rochester a sad, sad example of the parking problem we have in our cities as a result of urban renewal, it will UNDOUBTEDLY win this entire bracket. That is HORRENDOUS.

  • Jimmy Combs

    This is funny, but a great idea to have this tournament!

  • Jimmy Combs

    It’s going to be a battle with Detroit! Rochesterains are well informed of their parking burden

  • James Simons

    It is sad to see my beloved hometown of Rochester included in this dubious contest. What is surely worse, however, is that many locals (especially suburbanites), complain that there isn’t enough parking or that it should all be free.

  • neroden

    It’s probably not obvious, but the main intercity train station for Rochester is two blocks north of this, cut off from the city by that damned Inner Loop expressway.

    The Inner Loop is a lot worse than the parking in Rochester… and I think the Inner Loop is *causing* a lot of the parking lots.

  • neroden

    Geez…. tough competition… seriously, Detroit and Rochester should have been seeded in separate divisions.

  • MAT

    What’s sad is that it doesn’t look like Miami has a walkway along that river. Even Rochester has riverfront walkways!

  • A Rochester Professional

    What killed downtown Rochester wasn’t parking all by itself. You have a combination of insufficient parking to support more businesses, especially retail, and a public transit system that is absolutely horrible. I can drive to my downtown job and park in my company subsidized parking space in only 15 minutes, but to take the bus would be over an hour, including waiting time for a transfer. And I live practically within sight of a bus stop! And don’t even ask me how bad it is if I have a meeting in the evening, and don’t want to need to have my wife come and get me at my off site appointment that’s right next to a bus stop, or it’ll take me another hour and a half or two hours to get home from a place that is only 20 minutes from where I work!

  • Andy B from Jersey

    Agreed! It’s so clear that that “parking lot” on the right in Miami will soon have a building on it.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

It’s Washington vs. Burlington in the Parking Madness 2016 Tip Off!

|
Welcome to Parking Madness, Streetsblog’s annual Sweet 16 tournament of parking craters. What’s a parking crater? Simply put, it’s a depression in the cityscape, a void where car storage has usurped land that should be devoted to buildings. This is the fourth year Streetsblog readers have submitted more than enough entries to field a 16-crater bracket. Thanks to everyone who […]

Parking Madness Final Four: Chicago vs. Jacksonville

|
We started with 16 parking craters and now we’re down to the Final Four of Parking Madness. After two bruising rounds of competition, four hideous parking expanses in Kansas City, Rochester, Chicago, and Jacksonville are still in it to win it. Each one is an ugly and awe-inspiring waste of potential in its own way. Today’s […]

Parking Madness 2015: Can Your Parking Crater Compete?

|
  March is a special month on Streetsblog. It’s the time when the nation’s worst downtown parking scars face off head-to-head for the shame of winning the “golden crater” — and the local publicity bonanza that comes with it. For the third year running, we’re asking you to help seed the bracket in our Parking […]

Camden’s Waterfront Abyss Wins the 2015 Golden Crater

|
From the Texas Panhandle to the Bay Area, from the shores of the Detroit River to the Gulf Coast of Florida — America’s cities are a pockmarked mess, blighted by asphalt parking expanses you can practically see from space. Streetsblog readers submitted two dozen horrendous parking craters for consideration in this year’s Parking Madness tournament, and the editors picked 16 to vie […]

Parking Madness Final Four: Kansas City vs. Rochester

|
The hunt for the worst parking crater on earth nears its epic conclusion with the second Final Four match of Parking Madness. Today’s matchup features a formidable entry from Kansas City and the upstart parking crater from Rochester, New York, which knocked out Detroit in the previous round. The winner will take on Jacksonville tomorrow for […]