HUD and U.S. DOT Embrace Housing + Transportation Metric for Affordability

philly_housing
Looking only at housing costs (top map), much more far-flung parts of the Philadelphia region look affordable (the yellow areas) than if you look at housing and transportation costs together (bottom map). Maps: CNT

A few years ago, the Center for Neighborhood Technology gave a wonderful gift to urbanists and planners: the Housing + Transportation Index. This simple calculation clarified and popularized a key concept: that transportation costs must be taken into account in any measurement of “affordability.”

Without that, potential homebuyers and renters make the mistake of “saving” money by buying a home far outside the city, only to see those savings vanish when they end up driving multiple cars hundreds of miles per week, racking up fuel and maintenance expenses. The H+T index is a simple tool for making better decisions — for families, for planners, and for the federal government.

Today, U.S. DOT and HUD announced that they’re launching a new version of H+T. They’re calling it the Location Affordability Index, and CNT helped develop it. LAI differs from H+T in some key ways (here’s an infographic detailing those differences) but at its root, it gets at the same important question: Where is the best place to live without breaking the bank?

CNT answers that question by showing the huge variations between two maps: one that shows places where the median household pays 30 percent or more of their income on housing, and one that shows places where those households pay 45 percent or more of their income on housing and transportation combined.

The maps show how intimately linked transportation and housing are when determining cost of living, as HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan told reporters today. “For any housing community to succeed, its residents need to be able to get to work, its young people need to be able to get to school, and its families need to be able to access critical resources and services they need,” Donovan said.

philly_ht
Areas farther from the city center no longer appear affordable when transportation costs are factored in.

Donovan noted that for most families, transportation is their second-highest monthly expense, after housing, but said transportation costs aren’t always so easily tabulated. You don’t get one transportation bill in the mail, the way you get your mortgage or rent bill. Transportation costs are paid in dribs and drabs — a tank of gas here, a bus fare there, a parking ticket, a taxi ride, an oil change. The LAI index helps quantify how those costs add up, and see if the transportation requirements of a particular geographic area render it unaffordable.

“It can sometimes be tricky to weigh the pros and cons of all of these options,” said Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx. “Does it make more sense to live in a community where you have to drive to work every day? Or might it be a better bargain to live where you can walk, bike or ride public transportation? That’s where the Location Affordability Portal comes in.”

“This tool can show a Dallas family living in Sunnyvale that they spend an average of 22 percent of their household budget on transportation, which they could also compare to 14 percent in nearby Oaklawn,” Foxx said. “And in Des Moines, a family living downtown spends 7 percent less on transportation costs than one living in Altoona.”

Of course, the availability of transportation options and the ability to see average household expenditures doesn’t necessarily tell a family with certainty what they’ll spend. But it opens up that conversation and invites people to calculate those sometimes hidden costs.

“I would argue that had we had a tool like this going into the housing crisis and the bubble that we experienced, I certainly wouldn’t argue that it would have solved that problem, but I think it could have helped ameliorate some of the worst effects that we saw,” Donovan said. “Too often we saw individual families buying homes they thought they could afford without factoring in the transportation costs.”

The agencies are calling the new portal a tool for families, housing counselors and community planners to make better decisions — but they want to see it “road-tested” before they put their full confidence behind it. U.S. DOT and HUD aren’t yet using the LAI themselves to determine how to direct grant money, where to build public housing, or whether to underwrite a mortgage. It’s good enough for local policymakers to use, they indicated, but not the federal government.

Still, if this tool could have helped avoid some foreclosures during the depth of the housing crisis — or could help prevent a repeat — that sounds like an argument for a federal interest in using this metric.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

High Transportation Costs Make a Lot of HUD Housing Unaffordable

|
Rental assistance from HUD isn’t enough to make the cost of living affordable when the subsidies go toward housing in car-dependent areas, according to a new study by researchers from the University of Texas and the University of Utah. The study evaluated transportation costs for more than 18,000 households that receive HUD rental subsidies, estimating that nearly half of recipients have to spend more […]

Talking Headways Podcast: It Costs More to Drive Til You Qualify

|
The topic this week is housing affordability and transit, with guests Shima Hamidi, Reid Ewing, and John Renne. They discuss their recent paper in the journal Housing Policy Debate, “How Affordable is HUD Affordable Housing?” As it turns out, a lot of HUD rental assistance is spent in areas with high transportation costs. We talk about the impetus […]

Sen. Menendez Introduces Bill to Plan For Livable Communities

|
New Jersey Sen. Bob Menendez has taken up where former Senator Chris Dodd left off. Last week, Menendez offered a fresh version of Dodd’s Livable Communities Act. The bill would formally authorize the HUD Office of Sustainable Housing and Communities and its Regional Planning and Community Challenge grant programs, restoring funding for those programs to […]

Feds Begin Redefining ‘Affordable Housing’ to Include Transport Costs

|
Comparing the transportation savings in dense versus dispersed neighborhoods for a dozen U.S. metro areas. (Chart: CNT) The process of expanding the federal government’s definition of "affordable housing," a stated goal of the Obama administration’s sustainable communities effort, began in earnest yesterday with the introduction of a new index that integrates transportation prices into the […]

Are There Any Affordable Cities Left in America?

|
Are Washington, San Francisco, and New York the most affordable American cities? A new report from the New York-based Citizen’s Budget Commission [PDF], which made the rounds at the Washington Post and CityLab, argues that if you consider the combined costs of housing and transportation, the answer is yes. But a closer look at the data casts […]

HUD Chief Preaches Livable Communities at Conference on Cities

|
HUD Secretary Shaun Donovan. Photo: Wikimedia. At least among cabinet secretaries, US DOT chief Ray LaHood has become something of a livable streets rock star. His forceful and public support for cyclists and pedestrians and his dedication to safe driving have earned him the praise of many. By comparison, Housing and Urban Development Secretary Shaun […]