Washington State Considering a “Symbolic” Tax on Bicycles

In the last few months, we’ve seen all sorts of proposals from states trying to keep their transportation budgets solvent.

Bikes costing more than $500 in Washington state could be subject to a $25 excise tax under the proposed transportation bill. Image: ##http://bikeportland.org/2013/02/20/symbolic-bike-sales-tax-proposed-in-washington-83119?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=feed&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+BikePortland+%28BikePortland.org%29## Bike Portland##

But here’s a new one — the pointless bike tax. Lawmakers in Washington state have proposed a $10 billion transportation spending package that will raise gas taxes and vehicle registration fees. In addition, the draft transportation bill includes what local media are calling a “symbolic” tax on bicycles.

Evan Manvel, writing for Seattle’s Cascade Bicycle Club, says the tax, which is expected to raise just $1 million over 10 years, is misplaced:

The package’s proposed bike excise tax ($25 on sales of bikes costing more than $500) would harm hard-working small business owners. Most such bikes are sold by small family-owned bike shops and this would impose red tape and costs for them while creating virtually no revenue.

People who bicycle already pay substantial taxes for our transportation system, including the sales taxes, property taxes and federal taxes that together cover two-thirds of all transportation spending in Washington. Bicyclists who own cars also pay the same car tabs as everyone else even if they drive less.

In addition to serving no apparent purpose except “making bicyclists pay,” the tax is out of all proportion to the equivalent car taxes, as Richard Masoner points out at Cyclelicious:

A $25 tax is 4% of the value of an entry level $600 bicycle. Compare that against the 0.3% excise tax on new car and truck purchases. Both are on top of the 6.5% state sales tax and whatever local sales taxes that might apply. That’s a full magnitude of difference.

Meanwhile, Jonathan Maus at Bike Portland writes the idea of a bike tax has been tossed around in Oregon for a long time and it wouldn’t surprise him if it emerges in budget negotiations there as well. In the past, some Oregon bike advocates have supported such proposals, under the notion that it would help allay the perception — no matter how inaccurate — that cyclists don’t pay for roads.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Urban Review STL shows a great example from St. Louis of how a former gas station can be transformed into a truly lovable urban space. The Fast Lane shares U.S. DOT’s plan to make the nation’s national parks more accessible by transit. And Transportation for America writes that the latest standoff in Washington over the budget “sequester” threatens to be very bad news for the transportation programs that are most popular in local communities.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Washington State Lawmaker: Cyclists Cause Pollution By Exhaling

|
We’ve heard some silly arguments against cycling before, but this one from Washington State Representative Ed Orcutt… well, it speaks for itself. Orcutt, who is a supporter of the proposed tax on bicycles in Washington, told a constituent that cyclists should be taxed because they cause pollution with “an increased heart rate and respiration.” Tom […]

Who Would Benefit From Eliminating the Federal Gas Tax?

|
We wrote recently on Streetsblog Capitol Hill about a proposal by Republican members of Congress to eliminate the federal gas tax and turn transportation funding entirely over to the states. This proposal — “devolution,” it’s called — has been a conservative dream for decades. Transportation reformers tend to hate the idea because state DOTs on […]

How the U.S. Tax Code Favors Driving Over Other Modes

|
If you get to work by transit or bike, you’re saving a lot of money on gas, but come tax season, Uncle Sam probably won’t be as generous to you as he’ll be to car commuters. The Tri-State Transportation Campaign took a look recently at the way tax benefits apply to different modes of transportation. Renata […]

Communities Vote to Tax Themselves to Support Transit

|
In addition to some of the high-profile measures that we covered already, Election Day brought many successes on some smaller ballot initiatives. According to the Center For Transportation Excellence, pro-transit campaigns had an 80 percent success rate this year at the ballot box, with more ballot measures coming up for a vote than any previous […]

Krugman: Costs of Driving Deserve Way More Attention

|
Two of the nation’s leading lefty commentators weighed in on transportation incentives last Friday, when both economist Paul Krugman at the New York Times and Matt Yglesias at Slate went on a congestion pricing kick. Krugman kicked things off by remarking that the surest way to reduce the costs imposed on society by drivers is […]

More Election Results: Transit Wins Big

|
Out of 12 transportation-related measures that were voted on Tuesday, seven represented a victory for transit, three were losses to learn from, and two more aren’t really a win one way or another but are worth noting. According to the Center for Transportation Excellence, these numbers bring the year’s total to an impressive 79 percent win […]