Advocates: Mobilizing Transit Riders a Challenge, Even in Transit-Rich Cities

With fewer Americans driving and transit ridership breaking records, you might think transit has plenty of muscle behind it. But while the numbers speak for themselves, the riders often don’t.

A pro-transit rally in Honolulu last year. Photo: ## Place in Urban Space##

That’s why local efforts to establish grassroots transit advocacy organizations are so important, said a panel of experts convened by the Center for Transportation Excellence this Wednesday. The presenters described successes and failures in engaging different segments of the transit universe, including riders, labor unions and students.

Greg LeRoy, head of economic development watchdog Good Jobs First, said that in many cities — even transit-rich ones — there’s not always a long history of rider groups organizing themselves, and of those, some have little capacity to advocate.

“Certainly large systems like SEPTA [in Philadelphia] have so many riders there is raw community-organizing capacity, but that doesn’t mean there is any sustained organizing,” said LeRoy.

Enter Americans for Transit, a partnership that combines the organizing power of the labor movement with the number-crunching expertise of economic development wonks. LeRoy said Americans for Transit aims to create a “four-legged stool” of transit riders, labor, manufacturers, and pro-transit employers who can craft and target an advocacy message that’s currently lacking in many cities.

Giving a sudden jolt to the movement is ATU president Larry Hanley, who LeRoy says is sending strong signals to his local presidents to take on a more vocal role.

Not that broad-based transit advocacy is unheard of. When the House looked like it was about to hang transit out to dry a few months ago, a coalition of organizations rose up to defend it. But while Congress’s plan to pull the plug on transit galvanized people around the country to help avert a high-profile national crisis, Americans for Transit aims to strengthen and sustain transit advocacy over the long term, starting at the local level.

One common obstacle to engaging people is that many of the public’s most frequent complaints about transit — timeliness, reliability — boil down to a shortage of operations and maintenance funds. But the riding public often doesn’t know why these problems exist, or who can actually do something about it. So Americans for Transit and similar groups would create and educate a nationwide network of advocates who could put pressure on any level of government — city, region, state, or federal — no matter how low down or high up the funding tree.

Of course, sometimes that tree will lead all the way back to Congress. And while there are plenty of advocacy groups — including the National Association of Public Transportation Advocates, the webinar’s co-host — who do talk fairly regularly to the politicos holding the purse strings, the consensus among the speakers was that members of Congress would rather hear it straight from their constituents. Constituents, meanwhile, just want their bus to show up on time.

“Funding is what we need, but it’s not a crowd-pleaser,” explained Jen Henry from the Natural Resources Defense Council, currently partnering with the Active Transportation Alliance to create a groundswell of public support for transit in greater Chicago. “Sometimes people think transit agencies are wasting the money, and they don’t want to pay any more in taxes.”

In cases like that, it does come in handy to have a wildly ineffectual Congress for people to rally against. “We don’t like crises, but they do help build support,” Henry said.

The hope is that once a national advocacy network is in place, it won’t take another crisis to rally the troops.

  • William Hamilton

    We keep banging away at it down here.  It is hard.  Most people on transit don’t go anywhere they don’t have to so meetings and large gatherings are a challenge.  People are constantly asking me to fix it and I tell them nobody is going to listen to the same person over and over again.  We’re making progress, but it is slow.

    It takes a lot of time to focus the message for every different group you interact with.  Nobody really cares about transit.  They just want a ride to where they need to go.  Many of the riders have such pressing needs they have little time or energy to spare for activism.

    However we don’t have to fix it all, we just have to have more people on the bus next month, a better stop here or there.

  • We are on twitter! Please folllow us @A4transit:twitter website, facebook, and all other good things coming soon. 


No More Mr. Nice Guy: Transit Advocates Get Organized

What do you do if your bus service is cut by a third? If you’re Metropolitan Congregations United in St. Louis, you hold a ballot initiative – and win. What if your transit system neglects less affluent areas compared to the wealthy part of town? If you’re the L.A. Bus Riders’ Union, you bring a […]

Gun Lobby’s New Target: The Bus

Letting people carry firearms on transit vehicles is a new priority for the gun lobby in several states where legislation to expand concealed carry rules to buses and trains is gaining momentum. Proponents of these bills imagine armed transit riders protecting themselves from would-be assailants. Some states, like Texas, already allow guns on transit. But not everyone thinks crowded buses are a […]

The “Choice” vs. “Captive” Transit Rider Dichotomy Is All Wrong

The conventional wisdom about transit often divides riders into two neat categories: “choice” riders — higher-income people with cars — and “captive” riders — lower-income people who must use transit because they don’t own cars. But this framework can undermine good transit, according to a new report from TransitCenter [PDF]. In the attempt to cater only to “choice” riders or “captive” […]