Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Harry Reid

Boxer Pessimistic on Senate Bill as Parliamentary Sabotage Rears Its Head

During the current push for multi-year transportation bill, the Senate has been known more for its spirit of bipartisanship than any visionary policy advances. Now that the bill has hit the Senate floor, however, it's getting a little ugly.

Republican Senators have proposed a number of contentious amendments in order to stall the bill's passage. Senator Barbara Boxer, whose Environment and Public Works Committee got the ball rolling on the bill last December, says these amendments are "ridiculously unrelated." For example, Rand Paul has proposed an amendment that would cut off American aid to Egypt until the 19 American civilians there are allowed to leave. Other amendments try to thwart the president's compromise on insurance coverage for contraception.

In response, majority leader Harry Reid has "filled the tree," proposing enough amendments to fill all available slots before any other senator can do the same. The move triggers another cloture vote, this time on specific amendments themselves, rather than the entire bill. The vote, scheduled for tomorrow, will decide whether the Senate goes forward in combining the EPW, Commerce, Banking, and Finance titles into a single bill.

Boxer, who had been generally upbeat about the Senate bill's prospects for passage, is getting frustrated with the delay tactics, according to The Hill:

"Right now, there is no path forward," Boxer said even as she vowed to continue pushing for a clean vote on the transportation proposal.

"I don't see it," Boxer said. "It's one of those things where people just say 'I don't care. We're not going to (approve) this bill.'"

The delay also means that other noteworthy amendments will have to wait until the current quarrel dies down. Two Democratic Senators and two Republicans have just cosponsored an amendment that would restore dedicated funding to the Recreational Trails program, protecting biking and walking programs that the underlying bill undermines. The Cardin-Cochran amendment, which gives metropolitan areas more control over federal funds, is also picking up cosponsors from both parties.

The fate of these two amendments and more -- T4America has a handy page to track their progress -- hinge on Senate leadership setting aside parliamentary scheming, and soon.

Still confused? Does this help? Me neither. Image: ##http://www.ilonanickels.com/CC_amendmenttree.html##Capitol Corner##

Reid's last cloture vote on the transportation bill succeeded by a healthy 85-11 margin, but it remains to be seen whether that margin will shrink in future votes as a result of this maneuvering. Filling the tree is tactic that Reid has developed quite a reputation for using, and it has sometimes come at a political cost. Reid filled the tree to ensure passage of President Obama's health care bill, and to protect the EPA's authority to regulate greenhouse gases. Reid also filled the tree while attempting to protect the provision that ended the military's "don't ask-don't tell" policy -- and it cost him the support of moderate Republican Susan Collins, a crucial swing vote, in the end.

Update: In her remarks on the Senate floor this morning, Sen. Boxer did say that she now sees a path forward, though it is still obscured by some "bizarre, extraneous amendments."

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Shutdown Showdown: Trump Blames Democrats for Transit Cuts In His Continuing War on Cities, ‘Woke’

It's the second time in as many days that the Trump administration has denied funding over policies it opposes.

October 1, 2025

Marcus Molinaro Is Wrong About Chicago Transit

Local transit advocates have diverse opinions on the best ways to improve transit safety. But there's one thing most of us can agree on. Donald Trump parachuting in soldiers, in an attempt to bully Chicago into submission, is not the answer.

October 1, 2025

Advocates In America’s Deadliest Car Crash City Are Forming a Powerful Coalition

A group of Memphis advocates are uniting to challenge car dependency and unravel its devastating impacts on residents

October 1, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines Will Tax Your Patience

RIP electric vehicle tax credits, the Trump administration's latest assault on transit, and more.

October 1, 2025

BIG ZERO: Trump Stiffs NYC Transit System in ‘Sanctuary City’ Tantrum

The federal government is denying the MTA tens of millions of dollars in public safety funding over of New York's immigration policies.

September 30, 2025

More Transit Means Safer Streets

Promoting transit isn't just a social good. It's also a tool to achieve Vision Zero.

September 30, 2025
See all posts