Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
An analysis of greenhouse gas emissions per passenger mile traveled shows the environmental benefits of cycling and walking Source: ##http://www.pietzo.com/storage/downloads/Pietzo_LCAwhitepaper.pdf##MIT##

Slate's Brian Palmer wrote in an article this week that he's thinking of switching his commute "from four wheels to two" but he's concerned about the environmental impact of bicycling: specifically, "about all the energy it takes to manufacture and ship a new bicycle." He wants to know how many miles he would "bike the drive" before he's gone "carbon neutral."

He estimates the average carbon cost of the manufacture of a new bike at about 530 pounds of carbon dioxide equivalents, based on a research paper published last year by MIT scientist Shreya Dave [PDF]. But Palmer never asks about the carbon cost of his car. According to an analysis by The Guardian, manufacturing a new mid-size car produces more than 17 tons of CO2e -- about 75 times what it cost to make that bike. A top-of-the-line Land Rover would pollute twice as much, or 150 times the carbon footprint of the bicycle.

Palmer discounts the argument that bicycle "fuel" also harms the environment, since cyclists burn more calories and need to eat more. "As the Pacific Institute has shown, you'd have to be eating an all-beef diet to offset the environmental benefits of walking or bicycling," Palmer said. "Given a 'typical U.S. diet,' you would have to ride your bike instead of driving for around 400 miles to cover the bike's initial carbon footprint."

The food argument also assumes that if you didn't bicycle, you wouldn't do any exercise at all that would require more caloric intake. Do people who don't exercise really eat less? And either way, is an exercise-free planet really a healthier planet?

Adding up carbon output from fuel, infrastructure, maintenance, manufacture, and operation, Shreya Dave's research doesn't even bother with the food-as-fuel argument and puts the bicycle's fuel carbon footprint at zero per passenger mile, though it does consider a relatively high operational carbon footprint since "a conventional bicycle requires the operator to work harder and breathe more heavily." The data also claims, shockingly, that the carbon output of the manufacture of a bicycle, per passenger mile, is twice that of a Boeing 737, and that the infrastructure required to run the bicycle is 50 percent greater.

Still, Dave says that building, paving, and maintaining roads for cars emits almost four times the greenhouse gases as doing the same for bike lanes -- in those special places where dedicated bicycle facilities even exist. And of course, Palmer writes in Slate, "your bike isn't exactly tearing up the asphalt." Weighing in at less than one percent of the weight of a Prius, a bicycle just isn't responsible for the kind of road maintenance that cars are.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Thursday’s Headlines Are Hotter Than July

The Trump administration looked at decades of science and decided that climate change is fine, actually.

July 31, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines Welcome Our Robot Overlords

The robotaxi field is growing, but with buyouts and now possibly layoffs at the U.S. DOT, will anyone be left to regulate them?

July 30, 2025

Shifting Gears to Urban Bike Delivery

Bikes can revolutionize delivery in urban areas. A new report outlines how policymakers can spur them in their communities.

July 30, 2025

Trump’s ‘Beautiful’ Bill Kills Lovely QueensWay Park (Plus Many Efforts to Erase ‘Racist’ Highways)

Here's another reason for Mayor Adams to have buyer's remorse over his bromance with President Trump.

July 29, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines Reel in the Years

Republicans continue to roll back the Biden administration's legacy, most recently ending the DOT's Neighborhood Access and Equity program.

July 29, 2025

What Will It Take To Give Victims and Advocates a Voice at US DOT?

A new bill would put a dedicated "roadway safety advocate" in the halls of US DOT — and you can support it right now.

July 29, 2025
See all posts