Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Car Dependence

How Gas-Dependent Is Your State?

How big a bite gas prices take out of your wallet varies by state. Photo: ##http://www.nrdc.org/energy/states/## Natural Resources Defense Council##

It's no secret that higher gas prices are hitting American pocketbooks hard. To a remarkable extent, however, exactly how much pain Americans are experiencing is a function of where they live.

A report released today by the Natural Resources Defense Council details how geography impacts our vulnerability to gas price fluctuation.

Fuel pump pressure is most pronounced in Mississippi, where in 2010 residents spent an average $2,225 fueling up, or more than 7 percent of their income. Meanwhile, Connecticut dwellers were far better situated. Residents of this tiny Northeast state spent less than 3 percent of their income fueling up last year, or about $1,586.

The analysis found that motorists in the American Southeast fared worst, overall. South Carolina, Kentucky and Georgia registered the second, third and fourth highest-paying positions, followed by rural Idaho. Study authors attributed this to a regional orientation toward sprawl and less fuel efficient vehicles, among other factors.

Meanwhile, consumers in the Northeast suffered the least as gas prices soared. New York, Massachusetts and Rhode Island followed Connecticut as the lowest spending states, with bike-friendly Colorado occupying the fifth position.

And in the first months of 2011, regional disparities have gotten even worse, the report found. April gas prices alone meant that Mississippi residents were spending a whopping 11 percent of their income on gas.

"Many Americans are locked in to paying high prices for gas," said study author Deron Lovaas in his blog. "They have limited or no access to public transit. They drive old, gas-guzzling cars they can’t afford to replace. They are forced into lengthy commutes by growth management policies that encourage building homes far from jobs. Their employers do not allow telecommuting or public transit benefits, but instead offer free parking."

The study highlights how ordinary people suffer when state policies reinforce car dependence. NRDC examined which states were making the biggest strides to free their residents from fuel pump slavery. Strategies for improving oil dependence included incentivizing electric vehicles as well as improving transportation system efficiency by enacting growth management strategies and instituting anti-idling regulations.

Seventeen states have some policy that restricts idling time. Sixteen states have smart growth or growth management policies in place, the report noted. Three states -- Washington, New York and Oregon -- have established policies aimed at reducing overall vehicle miles traveled.

California, Oregon and Massachusetts got credit for doing the most to reduce citizens' vulnerability to fuel price fluctuation. Nebraska, North Dakota and Alaska, on the other hand, were found to be doing the least to help residents cope.

"The states have a lot of work to do," said Lovaas. "Those at the top, the best thing you can say about them is they're valedictorians of a remedial class."

There is a big role for the federal government to play as well, Lovaas said. Among the NRDC's recommendations is making a fix-it-first policy part of the transportation bill reauthorization and establishing a 60 mpg fuel efficiency standard for new cars by 2025.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Friday Video: Take a Transit-Oriented Virtual Vacation in South Florida

From biking in the keys to commuter rail up the coast, this video showcases some of the best transit the Sunshine State has to offer.

May 10, 2024

Friday’s Headlines Face a Grim Future

Climate scientists are preparing for the worst, and something is going to have to change quickly for the world to avoid catastrophe.

May 10, 2024

More than 30 Organizations Ask Calif. Governor to Lift Transit Funding Freeze

The letter comes a day before Governor Newsom is scheduled to announce his May Budget Revision.

May 10, 2024

Talking Headways Podcast: Highway Fighting in Texas

Jeff Wood talks to Megan Kimble about an amazing footnote to the creation of the Interstate Highway system.

May 9, 2024

The Dawn of the ‘Non-Driver’ Movement: A Conversation with Anna Zivarts

"At the end of the day, there are going to be folks who still can't drive and can't afford to drive — and there are still going to be a lot of us."

May 9, 2024
See all posts