Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Federal Transit Administration

Report: Bush-Era Transit ‘Cost-Effectiveness’ Rule to Cost Charlotte $67M

2:10 PM EDT on April 5, 2010

When the Obama administration moved in January to undo a 2005 rule that made a federal "cost-effectiveness" rating the most important factor in determining which transit projects received funding, critics and even some transit advocates were skeptical, questioning whether the U.S. DOT would be able to legitimately quantify the community-building benefits of rail and bus networks.

Charlotte_SharonRdWest1.jpgThe new light rail line in Charlotte, North Carolina. (Photo:

But federal officials continued to describe the shift as a significant boost for local transit planners, who will no longer need to design the budgets for new transit lines around the confines of a cost-effectiveness formula that attempted to measure the "incremental cost per hour" for each traveler.

Those who cheered the demise of the cost-effectiveness rule got new ammunition today from Greenwire, which sent a reporter to Charlotte, North Carolina, to track the city's plans for expanding its three-year-old light rail line.

The full story is available only to subscribers, but it puts a $67 million price tag on local  transit planners' mandate to comply with the Bush-era cost-effectiveness standard. As Greenwire's Josh Voorhees explains:

Charlotte officials had originally wanted to build theline -- the first in a planned network spanning the metro area -- withthree-car trains. But the project was scaled back to a two-car systemto comply with a complicated cost-effectiveness formula then at theheart of the U.S. Transportation Department's criteria for federalfunding.

"In order to get the score we needed, they told uswe had to find a way to cut the project's scope," said John Muth, chiefdevelopment officer for the Charlotte Area Transit System. "We didn'treally have other options if we wanted the federal funding."

Now, as the city plans the second phase of its light-rail project, athree-car, 11-mile extension of the existing line from Uptown intonortheast Charlotte, it also must retrofit the existing track to carrythe longer trains. That means not only buying more rail cars, but alsolengthening platforms and boosting power distribution. Estimated pricetag of the retrofits: an additional $67 million.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

NYC Debuts Public E-Bike Charging for Delivery Workers

Finally, they’re taking charge! The city’s first public e-bike charging station opened in Cooper Square on Thursday — the start of an overdue six-month pilot that is part of a “Charge Safe Ride Safe Action Plan” for delivery workers that Mayor Adams announced last year.

March 1, 2024

Friday’s Headlines Have Questions

What's an optimal rebate to get people to buy e-bikes without wasting money on those who were going to buy one anyway?

March 1, 2024

To Recruit Transit Workers, More Than Just Higher Pay Is Needed

Labor shortages continue threatening public transit systems, and a new report adds another layer to the conversation.

February 29, 2024

Talking Headways Podcast: Streets for Skateboards

Aaron Breetwor on skateboards for transportation and designing streets for safer skateboarding.

February 29, 2024

Agencies Need to Use Federal Funding to Buy Land for Transit Oriented Development

Transit agencies do not prioritize transit-adjacent housing development often because they lack funding to acquire land.

February 29, 2024
See all posts