Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
2009 Transportation Bill

30 House Dems Back Transportation Tax on Wall Street Oil Speculators

More than a month after he first proposed the idea, Rep. Pete DeFazio (OR) -- along with 29 fellow Democrats -- has introduced legislation that would levy a small tax on oil futures trades in order to close the yawning gap in the federal transportation budget.

gas_price_1.jpgOil traders on the New York Mercantile Exchange. (Photo: HowStuffWorks)

DeFazio's bill would set the tax at 0.2 percent for every oil futures contract and 0.5 percent for every option on a futures contract, which he has projected would raise nearly $200 billion for transportation over the next six years.

The prospect of reining in the Wild West world of oil speculators, whom lawmakers and heads of state of all stripes have blamed for creating furious spikes in gas prices, is an irresistible one for many members of Congress.

But DeFazio's bill sets broad exemptions from the tax for businesses that rely on "commercial" oil futures trades to guard against economic downturns or oil price fluctuations

Wall Street firms acting on behalf of those "commercial" traders, which range from oil companies such as Exxon to major trucking companies, would also be exempted from DeFazio's proposed tax -- so long as the firms never held the oil futures for their own profit-making purposes.

It's unclear how much those exceptions would drive down the value of the oil-futures tax. DeFazio's bill does answer skeptics who believe taxing securities transactions could drive business offshore by requiring foreign holders of U.S. oil contracts to deduct and withhold the tax themselves.

The bill's distinction between "commercial" and "non-commercial" oil traders could prove problematic, however, given how murky the distinction is for some financial analysts. Oil companies and banks often work both sides of the equation, making trades connected to legitimate business as well as trades purely to profit from price swings, making enforcement of the rules potentially difficult.

Further complicating the issue, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission could soon pull the rug out from DeFazio's transportation-funding plan by setting its own limits on Wall Street's speculative trading. Still, his proposal is worth watching in the coming days of fiscal uncertainty for infrastructure.

The full list of DeFazio's House Democratic co-sponsors is available after the jump.

Co-sponsors: Brian Baird (WA), Tim Bishop (NY), Leonard Boswell (IA), Michael Capuano (MA), Russ Carnahan (MO), Jerry Costello (IL), Elijah Cummings (MD), Norm Dicks (WA), Bob FIlner (CA), Phil Hare (IL), Maurice Hinchey (NY), Mazie Hirono (HI), Marcy Kaptur (OH), Dale Kildee (MI), John Larson (CT), Dan Lipinski (IL), George Miller (CA), Alan Mollohan (WV), Grace Napolitano (CA), Eleanor Holmes Norton (DC), Jim Oberstar (MN), John Olver (MA), Bill Pascrell (NJ), Tom Perriello (VA), Nick Rahall (WV), Louise Slaughter (NY), Pete Stark (CA), Mike Thompson (CA), David Wu (OR).

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

How To End Your City’s Fight Over Scooter Parking Once and For All

Micromobility riders need a good place to end their ride just like everyone else — and cities can accomplish several goals at once by giving them one.

May 14, 2025

Blue State AGs Sue Trump Over ‘Strong-Arm’ Tactic of Tying DOT Funds to Immigration Crackdown

The U.S. Department of Transportation is illegally threatening to withhold billions in transportation funding to states that don't "cooperate" with the administration's immigration crackdown, a new suit argues.

May 14, 2025

Let Wednesday’s Headlines Clear Our Throat

Congestion pricing is doing what its supporters promised it would do.

May 14, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines Are Blocked In

Cities and regional governments could do a better job of spending federal transportation money than states, argues the Brookings Institute.

May 13, 2025

Check out Seattle’s New Subway!*

*...but only for stormwater runoff, not people. And considering that cars, trucks, roads and parking lots for cars are responsible for half of stormwater volumes — and contribute most to toxic runoff — why are households that don't even drive paying to keep other's waste from polluting sensitive waterways?

May 13, 2025
See all posts