Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Federal Stimulus

Republicans Deem Transpo Stimulus — 6% of Total Spending — a ‘Failure’

4:23 PM EDT on July 10, 2009

Republicans on the House transportation panel held a press conference today to deem the economic stimulus law a failure, citing low infrastructure spending in the nation's highest-unemployment states.

Unemployment_DOT_Stimulus_Spending.JPGRep. John Mica (FL), the committee's senior GOPer, and six colleagues displayed a chart (depicted at right) that used estimates of stimulus money spent so far by state DOTs -- as opposed to the amount obligated.

Tallying obligated money might have gotten in the way of the GOPers' argument, since states are beating the White House deadline for obligating transport funds.

But the press conference also hit on a theme that auditors at the Government Accountability Office (GAO) noted this week: Stimulus cash has not been steered to the nation's most economically devastated areas, largely because of an emphasis on getting money out the door quickly.

Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood responded quickly to the GAO report, asking governors late yesterday to redirect money to infrastructure in struggling areas.

This political firestorm over the stimulus' success obscures two crucial decisions that helped seal its fate as a job creator.

First, as Mica and his committee chairman, Jim Oberstar (D-MN), often pointed out during the stimulus, more cash for infrastructure would have generated more jobs.

The duo's proposed $85 billion transportation stimulus was ultimately cut to $48 billion to make room for extra tax cuts. That $48 billion represents just 6 percent of the total stimulus measure, as the AP points out in a fact check of today's event.

Judging the effectiveness of the entire law based on such a tiny slice of the pie -- no matter how economically potent transportation spending is -- seems misguided at best.

Second, investing more in transit would have given greater benefits to the urban areas that are the nation's economic workhorses. Transit also creates about 19 percent more jobs than road projects on a dollar-for-dollar basis, according to research by the Surface Transportation Policy Project.

Still, Mica's statement this morning made a compelling point, one that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) referenced yesterday:

Some leading Democrats are talking about the possibility of another huge stimulus, despite
the current package’s failure to put money on the streets quickly and
create jobs. 

In addition, the Administration wants to doom a major
transportation bill -- the only real jobs bill this Congress could
consider -- to an 18-month delay.

If House Democrats decide to focus on a new transportation bill as a de facto second stimulus, there could be some drama in the offing over the next few weeks.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

The Real Reason Assaults Against Transit Workers Are On The Rise

Hint: it's not just because service has been slashed.

December 7, 2023

Thursday’s Headlines’ Future Looks Bright

Amtrak Joe's administration is making big strides on rail, although it's lagging behind on EV chargers.

December 7, 2023

Feds Award $3B for CA High-Speed Rail, and $3B for Vegas-to-LA HSR

"This show of support from the Biden-Harris Administration is a vote of confidence in today’s vision and comes at a critical turning point, providing the project new momentum."

December 6, 2023

Car Noise Pollution is Worse in Redlined Neighborhoods — And Not Just for Humans

Transportation noise pollution can wreak havoc on wildlife populations, too — and that can have a devastating effect on their human neighbors.

December 6, 2023

Oakland Calif. Mayor Makes New Promise About Safety

Mayor Thao Tweets "It's time to reach a critical juncture where tragedies don’t catalyze improvements." But when and how will we know if the city has really reached that point and is serious about safety for all road users?

December 5, 2023
See all posts