Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Federal Stimulus

Stimulus Lesson: When Time is of the Essence, Invest in Transit

5:20 PM EDT on June 30, 2009

To be effective, fiscal stimulus must be timely.

The idea behind the policy is that in recession, households and businesses have an excess demand for savings -- everyone decides that they want to save at the same time, with nasty effects -- and so by borrowing those savings and spending them, the federal government can reduce the impact of the recession.

If the intervention isn't timed well, however, fiscal stimulus can backfire. If it takes too long to mobilize the policy, then the government will be borrowing and spending as recovery takes place, while households and businesses also want to be borrowing and spending.

The result is higher interest rates and bad investments and an overheating economy that's more likely to crash into another serious recession.

So it's not surprising that the government sought to spend as much as possible in as short a time as possible, and it's also not surprising that the relative rush led to investment in some projects that weren't necessarily ideal.

For instance, and as Elana Schor points out, it seems that $6.6 billion of the flexible transportation money sent to states under the stimulus has been allocated toward construction of new road capacity.

This is unfortunate.
Ideally, stimulus projects would offer an immediate economic boost and the promise of long-term economic benefits, but new roads largely fail the latter test. New capacity induces increases in driving, which is counterproductive to environmental and economic goals.

Since new road capacity is also extremely expensive -- tax revenues from most roads fail to cover even half of the total lifecycle cost of the road -- this spending is also counterproductive on fiscal grounds. Productive projects will make it easier to pay down debts accrued due to stimulus. New roads make it more difficult.

As much of the spending from stimulus is yet to come (and since the next few years will involve a lot of federal investment in transportation infrastructure), it's important to try and learn from this misstep. Smart Growth America correctly notes that vague federal guidelines for spending are often problematic. States will often have different priorities than federal governments, and may spend their share of federal grants in counterproductive ways if allowed.

Oversight and accountability must also be tightened. If watchdog groups can't see where the money is being allocated as government groups make their decisions, then pressure to avoid foolish investments can't be applied.

But it's also crucial to understand where opportunities have been missed. Elana notes that new road spending sometimes resulted from an excessive focus on immediate job creation, but this spending has frequently come alongside damaging cuts to transit service. Several billion dollars was initially set aside in the stimulus for transit operational funding but failed to make the final cut. Had some or all of the $6 billion used on new roads gone toward protecting or expanding transit service, tens of thousands of jobs would have been immediately saved.

At the same time, other long-range goals would have been met. In addition to facilitating long-term environmental and land-use changes, sustained or improved transit service would help shield households from rising oil prices, which might otherwise undercut consumer spending and stall recovery.

These are important lessons to internalize. Congress will soon consider how to close the gap in the highway trust fund, and whether new appropriations should be combined with any institutional reforms. Pressure to pass new funding quickly and cleanly will be strong, but should be resisted. With a few tweaks, federal funding can be spent much more wisely.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Thursday’s Headlines Are Inside Out

Cars and trucks are getting safer for drivers and passengers, but people outside the vehicles are increasingly in danger.

September 28, 2023

New Federal Committee Will Push for Transportation Equity By Helping DOT Reckon With Its Past

“No one alive today is necessarily responsible for the origins of the [transportation] inequities that we inherited. But everybody who was alive today and in a position of responsibility, is accountable for what we do about it. That's why we're here.” 

September 28, 2023

Report: America’s Historic Bike Boom is Flatlining

"This growth won't continue forever without being facilitated by more infrastructure investment, [and particularly] safety infrastructure."

September 28, 2023

Wednesday’s Headlines Ask How Much a Life Is Worth

There isn't much of a financial penalty for drivers who kill pedestrians — even if those drivers are cops.

September 27, 2023

‘I’m Not Grieving Alone’: New Play Explores a Father’s Journey After Losing Two Children to Traffic Violence

Colin Campbell and his wife Gail Lerner lost both their children in a car crash with impaired driver. A new play explores how to talk about similar tragedies.

September 27, 2023
See all posts