What Toronto Learned By Giving Its Streetcar Its Own Lane

Using low-cost materials like this concrete divider, Toronto set up new streetcar stops on the far side of intersections on King Street, enabling safer boarding and cutting down on time stopped at red lights. Photo: Human Transit
Using low-cost materials like this concrete divider, Toronto set up new streetcar stops on the far side of intersections on King Street, enabling safer boarding and cutting down on time stopped at red lights. Photo: Human Transit

In crowded urban areas, cars aren’t the most efficient way to move people. That’s the lesson from Toronto’s one year King Street “pilot,” which prohibited through car traffic on the high-ridership streetcar corridor.

New data from the one-year pilot experiment shows the King Street corridor is moving more people than it did before the city cleared cars out to the way. That’s because removing car traffic from King Street improved streetcar service so much, ridership has grown 16 percent.

A total of about 84,000 people are using the King Street Streetcar along the east-west corridor daily, the city reports. But only 72,000 people were using the roadway before the street was redesigned to prioritize the streetcar.

The data comes from new report from the city’s transportation staff recommending the corridor design be made permanent. The city estimates it will cost just $1.5 million to make the improvements permanent, providing a dedicated lane for existing high-capacity surface transit one of the best transit investments available to cities.

Not only is the streetcar moving more people, thanks to its dedicated lane, riders are happier with service as well. The King Street Pilot resulted in about 30,000 minutes saved by riders daily, the city reports. It was especially effective reducing major delays. The slowest average journeys — at the evening rush hour — decreased by five minutes.

A graph showing travel times on the King Street Streetcar before and after it was given a dedicated travel lane. Graph: City of Toronto
A graph showing travel times on the King Street Streetcar before and after it was given a dedicated travel lane. Graph: City of Toronto

“Prior to the pilot, overall customer satisfaction with King streetcar service was low on key measures such as travel time, comfort, and wait time,” city staff writes. “Through the pilot period, customer satisfaction on all these measures have significantly improved.”

Cycling rates have also increased. There are about 380 more daily cyclists on the corridor at the afternoon peak, according to the city, “likely because reduced motor vehicle volumes made it more comfortable to cycle.”

Drivers haven’t been duly inconvenienced, the data show. Car travel times on parallel corridors is roughly the same as before the pilot began in January, 2017.

The pilot did show that retail sales were down very slightly, about 0.8 percent, most notably from restaurants. But the city says that reflects a trend that was underway before the pilot. There were a number of very outspoken business owners that opposed the pilot. But, overall, at least according to the city’s data, the experiment does not appear to have been the retail apocalypse some predicted and was very positive for tens of thousands of daily streetcar riders.

  • Max Wyss

    The problem is that it is too cheap and uses no consultants…

    But it shows that there are many low-hanging fruit to make transit more efficient. Just give transit the priorities it deserves.

  • iSkyscraper

    Toronto has a great streetcar network that is worth billions and has had billions invested in it, and those streetcars are a big reason why Parking Madness Infill these year features some strong Hogtown contenders.

    But the city has been very, very slow to acknowledge that it is now the 21st century and we aren’t all on our way to work at the munitions plant like it’s 1940. Four years of Rob F’ing Ford didn’t help either in poisoning the low-information populace against surface transport.

    But things are slooooowly changing. The new streetcars are huge and from their size alone necessitated eliminating some of the too-tightly spaced stops (more need to be cut). Payment is now entirely POP (although the onboard machines are impractical to use when crowded, more curbside machines are needed). Signal prioritization is now in place and many turns removed but more needs to be done to make the ROW for streetcars only. There is just no logic in a situation like this for allowing a few cars to slow critical transit infrastructure.

    The pilot has worked well, keep going T.O. Now if only the TTC could get more non-farebox funding (highest monthly pass cost in North America)…. maybe a little NYC style congestion pricing?

  • ZweiSystem

    By giving a streetcar its own lane makes the streetcar light rail. This is a lesson the Europeans learned in the 1930’s and 90 years later, North America is beginning to learn as well.

  • Becky

    A family vacation to the most exciting places in the entire world with your family and a beautiful house you desire to purchase. Is your current job truly capable of fulfilling your ambitions? In case your answer is no then it’s time for you to change. We bring to you a web-based job that is certainly as easy as being on any search engine like google or doing copy paste job. It does not require any technical knowledge and it does not require anything to sell. It is not similar to any fakes that promises to make you “rich over night” and then turned out to be pyramid schemes or stuff where you need to sell to your friends and family. It is easy to start and you will get the instruction guide within few weeks. You can make almost $13,000-$4,000 on a monthly basis. You could spend much more time with my friends and family and can go out for wonderful holidays. This job gives you opportunity to be own own boss and can work from anywhere in the world. Do not wait for too long, Go and check it out this phenomenal online job opportunity.>>>>>>>>>>>> https://goo.io/Ux3JQo

  • Michael

    North American streetcar companies understood it well too, but the government didn’t allowed them to restrict traffic in their right of ways. It was one of many government interventions that took down private streetcar.

  • tomwest

    “The pilot did show that retail sales were down very slightly, about 0.8 percent, most notably from restaurant”
    Not quite true – the data showed that the growth was 0.8 percentages points less than the previous year.
    Retail sales growed, just slower than the previous year.

  • Rhea

    I actually earn almost $6,000-$8,000 every 30 days using the internet. It is absolutely more than enough to very easily replace my earlier jobs earnings, particularly seeing that I simply just do the work around 20 hour or so every week from a home office.I lost my job after operating for the same corporation for several years, I required very trusted source of income. I was not researching for programs that promises to make you rich in just few days as you can see all over the internet. Those all of them are kind of ponzi multi-level marketing programs in which you need to first make prospective buyers after which sell something to friends or family members or any individual to make sure they will be in your team. The most exciting part of working over the internet is that I am always home with the children and also enjoy time with family on different beaches of the world. Honestly,it is actually easier than you would think, all you need to do is fill out a very simple form to get front line access to the Home Profit System. The guidelines are extremely easy, you need not have to be a computer whiz, but you must be aware how to use the internet. It is as easy as being on Facebook. Here’s the easiest method to start > https://urwebs.it/78SIBV

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Will Toronto Get Cars Out of the Way of the King Street Streetcar?

By Angie Schmitt |
Despite running through some of Toronto’s most densely populated areas, King Street is designed like a suburban road. Cars have dominion while the city’s streetcar has no dedicated right-of-way despite high ridership — so it sits in heavy traffic. But it looks that’s about to change. Toronto recently announced plans to overhaul King Street by 2017 with a pilot project to shift space from […]