Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Jacksonville

Jacksonville Gets Soaked By Bad Parking Garage Deals

The 1,375-space parking structure across the street from Jacksonville’s county courthouse. Photo: Google Maps

Jacksonville taxpayers have forked over $47 million to keep three downtown parking garages afloat, a subsidy that amounts to about $16,637 per space -- and rising.

The fallout is expected to get worse, according to the Florida Times-Union, because the city is on the hook for financial shortfalls at the garages until 2030. The situation should be a cautionary tale for cities thinking of subsidizing downtown parking structures.

The garages were part of the "Better Jacksonville Plan" approved by voters in 2000, which funded the construction of a county courthouse and the Jacksonville Veterans Memorial Arena with a half-cent sales tax increase.

In 2004, the city inked a deal with a garage operator. The public commitment for one 1,375-space structure by the courthouse plus 1,000-space and 480-space garages by the arena was supposed to be limited to $19 million, with the garages turning a profit by 2019. But that's not how things worked out.

The garages are only producing half the revenue projected in 2004, reports the Times-Union's David Bauerlein, and the city must make up the difference. Jacksonville has to pay off debt incurred by garage construction and cover a contractually guaranteed 6.75 percent rate of return for the private operator. Each year, taxpayers fork over about $3.8 million to pay off the garages, and there's no stipulation allowing the city to renegotiate terms before 2030.

It's too late to salvage this deal, but maybe Jacksonville will avoid making the same mistake in the future. Subsidized parking is a bad bet, even in car-centric Jacksonville, which is now short $47 million it could have spent to improve walking, biking, and transit instead.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Talking Headways Podcast: The Architecture of Urbanity

Vishaan Chakrabarti on goldilocks density, defining urbanity, the ennui of young architects and much, much more.

October 10, 2024

Thursday’s Headlines Are Nonbiased

Human cops disproportionately stop Black drivers, while automated cameras don't show the same bias, according to one recent study.

October 10, 2024

Bike-Friendly Campuses Can Inspire the Rest of Car-Centric America

A first-ever national summit will explore what makes a college or university bike friendly, and how higher ed can help create a better transportation culture in cities, too.

October 10, 2024

L.A. City Council Committees Approve Road Widening Reforms

The city Bureau of Engineering proposal should minimize road widening at future private developments, but there are several widening situations it does not address, including BOE's own road widening projects.

October 10, 2024

A Father Speaks: Here’s Why The Speed Limit Must Be 20 MPH Everywhere

At an event on Wednesday, no one was more eloquent than the spotlight-avoiding father of the boy for whom Sammy's Law is named.

October 9, 2024
See all posts