As Fewer Kids Attend Neighborhood Schools, Transportation Challenges Intensify

Scenes like this are becoming rarer. Photo:  MoBikeFed
Scenes like this are becoming rarer. Photo: MoBikeFed

The more kids get driven to school instead of walking, the more chaotic the drop-offs and pick-ups become. Twice a day, the streets around schools turn into a snarled traffic mess, with a lot of vulnerable children walking around.

There’s a discussion at Greater Greater Washington about how schools can make the process safer and less of a free-for-all, and few seem to have had much success.

GGW’s Matthew Kohler notes that the rise of school choice policies adds a whole new wrinkle, as students shift from neighborhood schools within walking distance to schools farther away:

The problem’s scope has only recently expanded — in other words, it’s not something schools have had that much time to think about.

Since the mid 2000s, enrollment at both charter and traditional schools is up (charters had 44 percent of citywide enrollment in 2014), and with more parents entering the school lottery every year more students are attending schools outside of their neighborhoods. That often means walking or biking isn’t feasible (especially for elementary school kids who may not be old enough to walk, bike, or take public transportation), so more parents are driving.

In other words, said Steve Glazerman, “school choice does naturally lead to longer commutes, all things equal, at least in the short run. The idea is that parents get to trade off distance with other school attributes like academic quality or special programs.”

Steve actually did a recent study on school choice, and his findings helped lead to this graph, which is based on data from everyone who applied to DC’s public school lottery in 2014.

School choice roughly doubles the commute for parents and students, a study by Steve Glazerman found. Graph: GGWash
Image: Steve Glazerman and Dallas Dotter

“School choice,” said Steve, “both charters and open enrollment, more than double the average commute distance for these families, probably pushing a lot across the mode choice threshold from walking to car/bus/train.”

More recommended reading today: Transportation for America warns that transit funding will be at risk in the Trump budget. And Price Tags considers how much ride-hailing companies like Uber and Lyft are increasing traffic in Seattle.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Simple Joy of Walking and Biking to School

|
One of the biggest sacrifices we’ve made in the United States to prioritize the movement of automobiles over active transportation is the health and safety of children. Biking and walking to school has become increasingly rare while childhood obesity is on its way to becoming the norm. But for at least one day a year, […]

What If We Rated Schools by Walkability?

|
We live in an era when school ratings are everywhere. Assigning “grades” to schools based on academic performance is a famously tricky proposition, though. Maybe there are other metrics that are much more straightforward. Dan Reed at Greater Greater Washington recently asked a provocative question: How would it change the educational landscape if we rated […]

Getting Rural Kids Walking and Biking: A Case Study From Northeast Iowa

|
This post is part of a series featuring stories and research that will be presented at the Pro-Walk/Pro-Bike/Pro-Place conference September 8-11 in Pittsburgh. Nationally, more than 14,000 schools have taken part in Safe Routes to School programs. Though dedicated federal funding was stripped out in the current transportation law, SRTS funds have helped improve sidewalks, crosswalks, bike […]