Side-Street Bikeways Only Pay Off If You Have Protected Bike Lanes Too

A bike-friendly local street in southeast Copenhagen. Photos: Michael Andersen.
A bike-friendly local street in southeast Copenhagen. Photos: Michael Andersen.

Can we, as a planet, please retire the idea that cities face a choice between putting all-ages bikeways on low-traffic side streets and putting all-ages bikeways on busy arterials?

The data show exactly the opposite — and also suggest that putting bikeways only on side streets might actually be the worst course of action.

On Monday, Canada’s national Globe and Mail newspaper offered the latest installment of this understandable but misguided narrative. It’s part of a series about projects “that aren’t often talked about because they actually work.”

The idea is that the bike boulevards of Vancouver are uncontroversial, and therefore good:

[Protected bike lanes’] most ardent critic, CKNW radio shock jock Bruce Allen, has spent numerous segments railing against the “big ugly cement barriers that turned our streets into eyesores.”

And yet, he is a fan of the more understated network of traffic-calmed residential streets that allow cyclists to traverse the city in relative safety and peace. …

Urban-planning and transportation experts have long feted Vancouver’s extensive system of bike-friendly side streets as a cheap and uncontroversial way for bike-resistant North American cities to create the infrastructure that gets people out of their cars and onto two wheels.

It’s true that Vancouver’s bike boulevards are relatively cheap and uncontroversial. It’s also true that they’re good.

A tiny park reduces auto traffic on Vancouver’s Adanac bike boulevard.

What isn’t true is that bike boulevards (also known in various cities as “neighborhood greenways,” “neighborhood bikeways” and even “neighborways”) function as a good alternative to protected bike lanes.

When the Adanac bikeway enters downtown Vancouver, it becomes the Dunsmuir protected bike lane. Installed in 2010.

In fact, Vancouver’s recent experience tells the opposite story. In the 1990s and 2000s, the city built a network of bike boulevards and biking gradually edged upwards, reaching four percent bike commuting by 2011.

Then the city shifted toward building protected bike lanes to go with them … and bike commuting more than doubled in four years, rapidly turning Vancouver into the bikingest large city on the continent.

The truth is that protected bike lanes and bike boulevards are complements. As the Dutch have been proving for decades, they work far better in combination.

How much better? Let’s spin the globe to Auckland, New Zealand, where a 2014 academic study put some numbers on this question. Using available estimates of the ridership changes that result from various types of bikeways, a team of researchers simulated four scenarios for the future of Aukland: one with a network of mostly conventional striped bike lanes; one that put protected bike lanes on arterial streets; one that retrofitted all local streets into “self-explaining roads” (essentially, bike boulevards where bikes and cars can safely share the lane) and one that combined protected bike lanes with bike boulevards.

Source on data in charts: Macmillan et al, Environmental Health Perspectives, April 2014.

They concluded that a network entirely of bike boulevards would increase biking — but only to about five percent of trips, about the same as conventional bike lanes.

A network of protected bike lanes would do better, moving biking to something like 20 percent of trips.

But the real payoff, they found, was a network that combined comfortable biking on side streets with comfortable biking on main streets. That combo multiplied the impact of both treatments, leading to a whopping 40 percent of trips by bike.

And when 40 percent of trips in your city happen by bike, you start saving a huge amount of money from reduced fatality rates, hospitalizations, fuel costs and air pollution. (Here’s the full list.) Those cost savings more than offset the cost of the infrastructure:

Which means that if you look at the true economics of bikeways, the best option for saving money is to build an all-ages biking network on both small and large streets:

There are a lot of assumptions embedded in these figures, and different researchers would doubtlessly tally things differently. But the fact is that we already know what cities with 40 percent biking look like — and they have protected bike lanes on big streets and traffic calming on side streets.

Do bike boulevards “work,” as the Globe and Mail puts it?


They work to multiply the power of your protected bike lanes.

pfb_logoMichael Andersen blogs for The Green Lane Project, a PeopleForBikes program that helps U.S. cities build better bike lanes to create low-stress streets. You can follow it on LinkedIn, Twitter and Facebook or sign up for its weekly news digest about protected bike lanes.


America Could Have Been Building Protected Bike Lanes for the Last 40 Years

Salt Lake City is on track to implement the nation’s first “protected intersection” — a Dutch-inspired design to minimize conflicts between cyclists and drivers at crossings. For American cities, this treatment feels like the cutting edge, but a look back at the history of bike planning in the United States reveals that even here, this idea is far from new. In fact, […]

AASHTO Adds Designs to Bikeway Guide, But Not Protected Bike Lanes

Last week, AASHTO, the national association of state DOTs, published the first update to its bicycle facility design guide in 13 years (available online for $144). Since many transportation engineers take their cues from AASHTO, there was an urgent need to update the 1999 guide, which failed to include many effective design treatments and promoted […]

The Street Ballet of a Bike Lane Behind a Transit Stop

Michael Andersen blogs for The Green Lane Project, a PeopleForBikes program that helps U.S. cities build better bike lanes to create low-stress streets. Why don’t more cities escape the curse of bus-bike leap-frogging by putting bike lanes between transit platforms and sidewalks? Though “floating bus stops” and similar designs are being used in many cities, […]

Does the Gender Disparity in Engineering Harm Cycling in the U.S.?

A study published in this month’s American Journal of Public Health finds that highly influential transportation engineers relied on shoddy research to defend policies that discourage the development of protected bike lanes in the U.S. In their paper, the researchers point out that male-dominated engineering panels have repeatedly torpedoed street designs that have greater appeal […]