A Single Florida Bureaucrat Might Kneecap Miami’s Commuter Rail

Tri-Rail in Miami is suddenly facing an existential budget threat. Photo: Phillip Pessar via Wikipedia
Tri-Rail in Miami is suddenly facing an existential budget threat. Photo: Phillip Pessar via Wikipedia

Each weekday, the Miami-Fort Lauderdale commuter rail service, Tri-Rail, carries about 15,000 passengers — students, commuters making connections to Miami’s Metrorail, workers heading to the airport. In 2018, Tri-Rail plans to expand with a new station in downtown Miami, thanks to a clever partnership that takes advantage of rail infrastructure built by the private intercity outfit All Aboard Florida.

But out of the blue Tri-Rail is facing insolvency — all because a single state bureaucrat is threatening to throw the agency’s otherwise stable finances into turmoil.

Tri-Rail, by law, receives $30 million in annual support from the Florida Department of Transportation. But last week the state inspector general who monitors Florida DOT, Bob Clift, recommended a big change in the way Tri-Rail is funded, the Miami Herald reports. Instead of FDOT providing funds upfront on a quarterly basis, Clift wants Tri-Rail to apply for reimbursement from FDOT after six months.

The Herald reports that Clift, who was appointed to an inspector general post back in 1997, was influenced by an unnamed former FDOT District 4 secretary “who became concerned about the transparency of Tri-Rail’s spending.” Clift’s report says Tri-Rail provided a “FY 2013/14 operating budget that noted the planned use of funds by source, but the information lacked comparison to final budgetary amounts and actual expenditures.”

While there may be a legitimate need for better disclosure and transparency at Tri-Rail, Clift’s recommendation to withhold funds is too extreme, says Andrew Frey, a board member for the South Florida Regional Transportation Authority, which runs the service.

“We’d go dark,” Frey told Streetsblog. “We would cease to exist.”

The problem, Frey said, is that the agency doesn’t have $30 million lying around to support its operations for six months. The new funding arrangement could literally force the agency to shut down. If Clift’s recommendation is accepted by FDOT, Tri-Rail would have to suspend service in July.

The news of Clift’s decision just came to light on Friday, at SFRTA’s most recent board meeting, said Frey.

Frey, who was appointed by Governor Rick Scott, disputed the legal basis for changing current practice. “They’re basically going against the plain English of the law, which says notwithstanding any other provision of state law, SFRTA gets $30 million from FDOT,” he said.

The SFRTA board has declined to take the case to a judge, Frey said. Instead the agency will appeal to current FDOT District 4 Secretary Gerry O’Reilly, who also sits on the SFRTA board. O’Reilly told the Herald he would work on a mutually acceptable solution to the situation.


Miami’s Golden Opportunity to Bring Commuter Rail Downtown

Opportunities like this don’t come around very often. Traffic-clogged Miami is tantalizingly close to a commuter rail extension that would link its northern suburbs to the heart of downtown. But the city needs to secure $30 million in the next few months to make it happen. The region has a commuter rail line called Tri-Rail that runs 72 miles north to […]

Florida Guv, a Fair-Weather Friend of Rail, Backs Out of Climate Fight

Florida Gov. Charlie Crist (R), facing a challenge from the right as he stumps for a U.S. Senate seat, is shedding his already shaky environmental credibility as fast as he can. Florida Gov. Charlie Crist (R) (Photo: Sun-Sentinel) Crist’s administration is scrapping efforts to combat climate change and won’t be joining a regional carbon cap-and-trade […]

Conservative Tea Party Movement Targets Florida Rail Plan

The conservative "tea party" movement, last seen complaining about the government-funded local transit system that they took during an anti-government march in Washington D.C, is veering back to form in Florida with an organized protest against the state’s proposal for broad new investments in rail transit. The "Tea Party" is now a registered political party […]

Why Buy More Trains If You Can’t Afford to Run Them?

Down in balmy South Florida, D-Day is approaching for riders of the the popular Tri-Rail transit system. A looming $18 million shortfall has forced the Tri-Rail board to approve a budget that slices daily service and stops all trains by 2011 — although ridership has doubled since 2005. Tri-Rail trains like these could stop running […]

Expectations for High-Speed Rail Coming Down to Earth

Three months after the Obama administration announced the first winners of what it hopes will be the first of many federal grants to build U.S. high-speed rail networks, advocates and planners are settling in for a long battle to surmount the obstacles and unknowns that stand in the way of long-term bullet train development. If […]

Highway Boondoggles: Tampa Bay Express Lanes

In a new report, Highway Boondoggles 2 (the original came out in 2014), U.S. PIRG and the Frontier Group teamed up to profile the most wasteful highway projects that state DOTs are building. Streetsblog will be serializing the case studies in the report. Yesterday, we looked at Connecticut’s $11.5 billion I-95 widening. Today, we focus on a proposed $3.3 billion […]