Huh? After Bailing Out Toll Road, Florida Wants to Expand It

Tampa's Suncoast 2 toll road is an assured financial loser. But that hasn't stopped the state from promoting it. Map: Suncoast2online.com
Tampa’s Suncoast 2 toll road is guaranteed to be a financial loser. But that hasn’t stopped the state from plowing ahead. Map: Suncoast2online.com

By any reasonable measure, the Suncoast Parkway in the Tampa Bay Area has been a complete failure.

When it was first proposed, in 1992, consultants predicted the $507 million, 42-mile toll road from Hillsborough to Hernando County would fill up with cars — thanks to the sprawl everyone was sure would follow it. Consultants originally forecast $150 million in annual toll revenue.

Since then, according to an excellent summary from Tampa Times reporter Craig Pittman, that forecast was downgraded — twice. But the highway still didn’t meet the revised projections. In 2014, the road brought in just $22 million in tolls. Today the state of Florida heavily subsidizes the Suncoast Parkway with funds from other toll roads, Pittman reports.

But if you think that’s going to stop the state of Florida from expanding the highway 13 miles further into rural lands — including a national forest — think again.

“Suncoast 2” is “moving ahead,” Pittman reports, despite strong public opposition. Governor Rick Scott himself — who couldn’t tolerate the thought of cost overruns for high-speed rail — has teed up $150 million for the $257 million expansion project. Suncoast 2 is expected to generate just $3.8 in tolls in 2020 and only $14 million in 2049.

The project is set to break ground this year, the Times reports, and open in 2019.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Massive Highway Expansion Threatens to Destroy Tampa Neighborhoods

By Angie Schmitt |
Most people still think of Tampa as a sprawling, car-centric town, but that is starting to change. In 2014, Smart Growth America [PDF] found that Tampa is shifting toward a more walkable development pattern. The city is starting to build out a bicycle network, and its Riverwalk project is bringing people out to stroll downtown. Tampa’s recent progress could be overwhelmed, however, […]

The Great Traffic Projection Swindle

By Angie Schmitt and Payton Chung |
This is the final piece in a three-part series about privately-financed roads. In the first two parts of this series, we looked at the Indiana Toll Road as an example of the growth in privately financed highways, and how financial firms can turn these assets into profits, even if the road itself is a big money loser. […]

Southern California Road Agency Courts Bankruptcy With Highway Addition

By Phineas Baxandall and Jeff Inglis |
Today, U.S. PIRG and the Frontier Group released a new report, “Highway Boondoggles: Wasted Money and America’s Transportation Future.” In it, they examine 11 of the most wasteful, least justifiable road projects underway in America right now. This week we’ve previewed the report with posts about the proposed Effingham Parkway in Savannah, Georgia and the harebrained scheme to […]

4 Ways Road Builders Game the Numbers to Justify Highways

By Angie Schmitt |
The people who make the case for highways often present themselves as unbiased technicians, simply providing evidence to an audience subject to irrational bias. But traffic forecasting is not a neutral, dispassionate exercise. It is subject to all sorts of incentives, beliefs, and assumptions that can skew the results in a particular direction. Intentionally or not, forecasters frequently exaggerate predicted […]

Will Texas DOT Gouge Another Highway Through Dallas?

By Angie Schmitt |
The Trinity Toll Road embodies Texas’s destructive compulsion for expanding highways. The proposed $1.3 billion highway project will likely increase sprawl and weaken central Dallas. It’s part of a $5 billion package of road projects to ostensibly reduce congestion. Because tackling congestion by building always works out well. If you need another reason to feel […]