Parking Madness 2015 Elite Eight: Detroit vs. Camden

Today it’s on to round two in Parking Madness, our hunt for the worst parking crater in an American town. Our first Elite Eight matchup features two cities struggling to rebuild in the wake of some serious urban disinvestment, and these parking craters certainly aren’t helping. It’s Camden vs. Detroit.

Detroit

Screen Shot 2015-03-09 at 3.04.34 PM

The above image, submitted by reader Luke Klipp, is what carried Detroit over the California suburb of Walnut Creek in the first round. Klipp explains this area is right next to the Renaissance Center, where General Motors is headquartered. Klipp said:
Detroit’s waterfront is really sad when compared to its Canadian neighbor across the river, Windsor, whose waterfront is three miles of uninterrupted parkway. By comparison, Detroit has a couple parks near the Renaissance Center and then lots of parking right up to the waterfront.

Thanks to the talented Shane Hampton of the University of Oklahoma’s Institute for Quality Communities, we have historical photos to compare this area to what used to be.

Check it out:

streetsblog_detroit1951

This photo is from 1951. It looks like the area was already becoming a bit pockmarked. Detroit, being the birthplace of the American auto industry, may have been an early parking crater adapter.

Let’s look at the competition:

Camden
original-7
This photograph, submitted by Joseph Russell, lifted Camden over Mobile, Alabama, in the first round. Russell said of the space:

The neighborhood-killing parking lots on the waterfront in Camden, New Jersey. Years ago, this area housed factories for companies like RCA. Ever since, they’ve been used as parking lots for the equally neighborhood-deadening L3 Building, which is essentially a fortress separating employees from the rest of the city. Residents of the Cooper-Grant neighborhood are trying to rebuild a viable neighborhood here, and the negative effects of these huge parking lots stand directly in the way of that goal.

Let’s see what this area looked like back in 1959:

streetsblog_camden1959

Hmm interesting. Looks like it was a train yard.

Which one of these waterfront embarrassments deserves to make the Final Four? Let us know below:

Which city has the worst parking crater?

  • Camden (55%, 153 Votes)
  • Detroit (45%, 124 Votes)

Total Voters: 276

  • Camden is doing their best to make theirs bigger. They win it on substance and effort.

  • LAifer

    Anyone else notice that four of the buildings in the Detroit shot are parking garages? So, parking garages surrounded by surface parking. Seems like a winning strategy to me.

  • C Monroe

    large 8 to 10 story parking garages at that.

  • There is another large surface parking lot or two, just out of view of the Camden photo, adjacent to Broadway PATCO / Walter Rand Transportation Center, between there and Camden’s City Hall (which is a really beautiful building).

    There’s also a tragically out of place, suburban-style ‘drive-thru’ CVS on the other side of the light rail station, with, naturally, yet another surface parking lot of its own.

    Speaking of Camden, I could really go for a Donkey’s Steak right now…

  • Stewart Clamen

    From mid-19th century you could ferry from Philadelphia across the Delaware River to Camden and take the train to Atlantic City or Cape May

  • You can still take the train from Philadelphia to Atlantic City, and NJTransit finally connected River Line light rail (Trenton to Camden) to the Atlantic City line in Pennsauken, just north of Camden, a year and a half ago.

    A train to Cape May today would certainly be really nice anymore. Also, getting to Asbury Park without having to go all the way up to Rahway or Newark to switch lines first. I can dream…

  • Bobberooni

    Yes, Camden. The offer of NEGATIVE $200,000 for the building really takes the cake. Some chutz-pah!

  • Miguel Sanchez

    which city has the worst parking crater the editors momma

  • mmmmm donkeys

  • JayinPhiladelphia

    Dalessandro’s just ain’t the same as it used to be. Props to Joe’s in Tacony (and soon to open a second location in Fishtown) for changing its name, so I can now recommend it as far and away the best steak in the city. Donkey’s is just in a league of its own, though. It excels beyond the category of cheesesteaks. It is a sandwich that every American needs to eat at least once in their lifetime.

  • Whats really egregious about all those empty parking lots in Camden are the spectacular views of the Philly skyline across the Delaware. Those Detroit parking lots ain’t got much to look at!!! Also the Camden lots have perfect-by-design access to NJ TRANSIT RiverLINE and PATCO rail!

  • JayinPhiladelphia

    Camden was making a run, and had pulled to within two votes a couple hours ago, but it looks like Detroit’s pulling away now. Perhaps a concerted, conspiratorial effort!

    I’ll admit to some ‘hometown’ (well, another city across the river in another state, but still…) bias, but what you note should definitely swing things in Camden’s ‘favor.’

    Detroit’s crater could at best be a riverfront park with views of a decent-sized Canadian city.

    Camden’s sprawling crater, on the other hand, is centered right upon a 24-hour rapid transit system (PATCO), directly across the river from one of America’s great cities, with breathtaking skyline views, and should be much more than a dozen blocks of surface parking, to say the least…

  • Oh I agree. And more people might be hearing about Donkeys soon. Did you hear that Anthony Bourdain’s show CNN show Parts Unknown was filming there a few months ago?

  • running_bond

    Both of these were train yards and industrial areas, so the parking lots came about almost naturally as those uses disappeared. But Detroit still gets the nod for its awfulness.

  • running_bond

    Hey, lay off the Canuck-bashing. It’s actually quite a nice view across to Windsor.

    (Disqus messes up the preview, but cut and paste this – “https://goo.gl/maps/DMibT”)

  • EDG

    The worst part about Detroit’s is that it abuts a great amenity, their sparkling new riverwalk

  • Frank in Annandale

    The rail yard in Camden was the terminus for the Pennsylvania-Reading Seashore line. The ferry, which I rode as a child, ran from the foot of Market St. in Philadelphia to Camden where one took the train to the “shore.” Just imagine what could happen to this area if ferry service, or water taxi, were developed.

  • The DRPA sold the ferry to Cooper’s Ferry earlier this year, and I think they’ve got some water-taxy-like ideas in mind. Apparently the ferry is pretty well-used in summer with the concerts, which is great.

  • Camdennnnnnnnn! Going all the way, baby!

  • JayinPhiladelphia

    At least until it runs into Fort Worth, who look invincible…

  • C Monroe

    Wow, Detroit, the city with the most parking craters I have ever seen, is beaten two years in a roll with their two largest craters by smaller craters. Good thing Fort Worth will win this thing.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Parking Madness 2015: Detroit vs. Walnut Creek

By Angie Schmitt |
The Parking Madness competition has never been fiercer. In yesterday’s match-up, Parkersburg, West Virginia, edged Boston by a slim 12 votes, and before that, Amarillo beat out Nashville by just six votes. Your ballot counts. We have two doozies to feast your eyes on today. The Detroit waterfront is taking on the Bay Area suburb of Walnut Creek, California. Detroit […]

Parking Madness 2015 Elite Eight: Newport News vs. Syracuse

By Angie Schmitt |
Yesterday, Camden knocked off Detroit in Parking Madness, giving the Garden State the first spot in our Final Four. Today’s match pairs up dreadful parking expanses in Newport News and Syracuse, and it’s up to you to tell us which is the worst. Syracuse That right there is the picture that put Syracuse over the top in its first-round matchup […]

Parking Madness Final Four: Camden vs. Fort Worth

By Angie Schmitt |
We started this Parking Madness tournament with 16 soulless parking craters from California to New Jersey, and you’ve narrowed it down to the Final Four: Camden, Fort Worth, Syracuse, and the very aptly-named Parkersburg, West Virginia. Today and tomorrow your votes will determine who gets a shot at the title and Streetsblog’s coveted Golden Crater. Camden Joseph Russell […]

Camden’s Waterfront Abyss Wins the 2015 Golden Crater

By Angie Schmitt |
From the Texas Panhandle to the Bay Area, from the shores of the Detroit River to the Gulf Coast of Florida — America’s cities are a pockmarked mess, blighted by asphalt parking expanses you can practically see from space. Streetsblog readers submitted two dozen horrendous parking craters for consideration in this year’s Parking Madness tournament, and the editors picked 16 to vie […]

Parking Madness 2015 Elite Eight: Tampa vs. Fort Worth

By Angie Schmitt |
It’s almost a shame that these two titans are meeting in the second round of the Parking Madness tournament, because both Tampa and Fort Worth look like they have champion potential. Yesterday, Syracuse knocked off Newport News, Virginia, to join Camden in the Final Four. Now it’s up to you to decide who gets the third slot. […]

Parking Madness 2015: Asheville vs. Syracuse

By Angie Schmitt |
Only two spots remain in the Elite Eight of Streetsblog’s Parking Madness bracket. Yesterday, the parking fields by GM headquarters along the Detroit waterfront prevailed over the parking crater around the BART station in Bay Area suburb Walnut Creek. Today, Asheville, North Carolina, faces Rust Belt stalwart Syracuse. Asheville This entry comes to us from the fine folks at Kostelec Planning, […]