The Problem With “Share the Road” Safety Campaigns

After this taxi rushed past him 6 inches, Robert Wright snapped this photo "with a shaky hand." Was he wrong to be upset? Photo: The Invisible Visible Man
After this taxi rushed past him with only six inches to spare, Robert Wright snapped this photo “with a shaky hand.”Photo: The Invisible Visible Man

Appeals for courtesy between drivers and cyclists and pedestrians are pretty standard fare for traffic safety campaigns. In London, it’s “Share the Road.” In Utah, they have “Respect is a Two-Way Street.” Is this the best we can do?

Robert Wright at the Invisible Visible Man was thinking this over after a taxi driver nearly struck him while he was biking in Brooklyn, prompting him to yell at the driver in a burst of adrenaline. There’s a big problem, he writes, with safety messages that divide the world into drivers, cyclists, and pedestrians, then assign equal culpability to each group:

A “leave it on the road” approach to road safety suggests that the real problem is people’s malice towards each other or negative perceptions. It ignores the evidence that negligence, inattention and poor risk assessment are significant causes of car crashes. It puts the focus on vulnerable road users’ reaction to negligent driving. It suggests that all cyclists and pedestrians are somehow collectively responsible for each others’ behaviour. Motorists are helpless vessels full of potential rage that cyclists or pedestrians can make explode or safely depressurize. The approach serves no conceivable purpose other than to comfort people like the taxi driver who put me at risk. “Yes,” is the hidden message. “The real problem is those nasty, lippy cyclists.”

It’s self-evidently bizarre to argue that the solution to drivers’ killing people is to ask everyone to be nice. There is a quality-of-life argument for asking people to be calmer and more tolerant. I try when I haven’t been put in fear of my life to act considerately. But it’s hard to see that “share the road” campaigns are a better route to that destination than making the roads safe. The question is why “share the road” campaigns continue to consume energy that could be better directed elsewhere.

I suspect the answer is that transport authorities face a choice between conveying messages that are broadly popular and bringing about changes that are likely to annoy many. It’s not a surprise – though it’s certainly a disappointment — that the former so consistently wins.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Plan Philly, examining data from a new report from Governing Magazine, finds that like in most cities, Philadelphia’s poor neighborhoods see a disproportionate share of pedestrian fatalities. Bike Portland tries to envision what would happen if all the city’s cyclists decided to drive one day. And the Chicago Bicycle Advocate explains a California law that requires drivers to exercise more care than pedestrians or cyclists.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Boston’s Over-the-Top “Bike Safety” Campaign

|
You’ve probably seen the anti-smoking ads that show a man exhaling through a hole in his windpipe. Not pretty, eh? Well, the Boston Public Health Commission seems to have borrowed a page from that campaign in a new appeal to cyclists regarding helmet use. Check out the ad they’re using to promote protective headwear: a […]

Pedestrian Deaths Make Up a Rising Share of U.S. Traffic Fatalities

|
Pedestrian deaths rose 10 percent in the first half of 2015 compared to the same period the year before, according to preliminary data released by the Governors Highway Safety Association. If that increase held up over all 12 months of 2015, it would be among the worst single-year changes since the GHSA started collecting data in 1975. In a typical year, […]

A Former Traffic Engineer on the Industry’s Perverse Standards

|
For decades, policymakers have touted enforcement and public awareness as the answer to the staggering cost of road fatalities in the U.S. But despite decades of stricter enforcement and well-intentioned public awareness campaigns, a new report from the National Academy of Sciences says the U.S. is falling behind other industrialized nations in traffic safety. According […]