Study: Parking Minimums Cost Seattle Renters $246 a Month

In Seattle, it’s now legal in certain neighborhoods to build apartment buildings with no parking. By saving on parking costs, owners can offer lower rents, and developers say there are waiting lists for parking-free buildings.

Almost 40 percent of parking spaces in Seattle-area apartment buildings are empty at night. Image: ##http://www.westseattleherald.com/2013/12/12/news/meeting-about-no-parking-apartments-california-ge## West Seattle Herald##
Almost 40 percent of parking spaces in new Seattle-area apartment buildings are empty at night. Image: ##http://www.westseattleherald.com/2013/12/12/news/meeting-about-no-parking-apartments-california-ge##West Seattle Herald##

But in most neighborhoods, Seattle still has laws that require a certain number of parking spaces per housing unit. According to recent research by the Sightline Institute [PDF], those parking minimums are costing Seattle residents dearly. Erica C. Barnett at Network blog PubliCola outlines the findings:

Sightline found that in its survey of 23 recently built apartment buildings, 37 percent of spaces were empty at night, the time of day when you’d expect parking to be in highest demand. In four developments, there were more than twice as many parking spaces as parked cars (meaning more than half the spaces were empty). On average, the buildings in the survey had 20 percent more apartments than cars, meaning that if car-owning renters averaged one car per apartment (a conservative estimate if you take seriously parking advocates’ claim that many small-apartment dwellers have multiple cars), only 80 percent of renters owned cars.

And here’s the problem with all that extra, unused parking: Everybody, including people who don’t own a car, pays for it. “Free” parking adds about 15 percent to the cost of renting an apartment — in Seattle, about $246 a month.

But the actual cost of unneeded parking to Seattle renters is even bigger than that, study author Clark Williams-Derry concludes:

Regardless of the reasons for the parking glut, the fact that developers provide abundant (and often unneeded) on-site parking significantly increases the supply-side costs of building new multifamily rental housing. Economic theory posits that higher supply-side costs reduce the amount of new housing that is built.

Less housing makes competition among renters more intense. That leads to higher prices for all renters in markets with minimum parking requirements, whether they drive or not.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Cyclelicious introduces the Florida candidate for governor who’s making bike safety a key part of his campaign. The City Fix says Brazil is moving to add a “right to transportation” to its constitution. And Together North Jersey outlines the city of Paterson’s plan to use urban design to minimize crime.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Real Estate Trend: Parking-Free Apartment Buildings

|
A wave of new residential construction projects in places like Seattle, Boston, and Miami are showing that, yes, modern American cities can build housing without any car parking on site. Officials in Boston gave their approval last week to what Curbed called the city’s “first big-time parking-less condo,” a 175-unit project named Lovejoy Wharf. The “plan was met with […]

Parking Break: What Cities Gain When They Lose Parking Quotas

|
This is the season climax, the culmination, the big reveal. Previously on Parking? Lots! Cities mandate off-street parking (guided only by junk science and groupthink). They do it in fear of territorial neighbors who want “their” curb spaces left alone. Our communities suffer horribly as a result. Information technology is shaking things up, though, and […]

Portland’s Parking-Free Apartment Boom

|
Portland is undergoing a bit of a building boom. According to local planners, about 40 apartment projects have come online in the last year and a half. Here’s the best part: More than half of those apartment projects have no parking — for cars anyway. Portland developers have been choosing to forgo building car storage […]