BTS Releases Confusing, Erroneous Transit Stats

I was all set to write a feel-good story about how the latest report from the Bureau of Transportation Statistics [PDF] shows that transit ridership is up and driving is down. I made up my mind to write that story before I even looked at the report, so sure was I that that was the message.

And that is still the message. But BTS’s numbers are awfully confusing.

Let’s start with this:

The first column of numbers is 2005, the second is 2010, and the third is percentage change. Image: BTS

Wait a minute, let me get this straight. There are 4.8 percent more commercial (inter-city) buses in 2010 than there were in 2005. Considering how BoltBus and MegaBus have revolutionized inter-city bus service, making it the fastest-growing travel mode, 4.8 percent growth in five years seems a little stingy. Other reports have put it at 6 percent growth just from 2009 to 2010.

But even assuming that 4.8 percent is correct: A 4.8 percent growth in passenger miles traveled makes sense, although I might expect the growth in the mode to mean fuller buses, meaning a greater growth in PMT than number of vehicles. But it’s the 97.5 percent change in vehicle-miles traveled that I cannot fathom. That would indicate that a few buses are driving around an awful lot without a lot of people on them.

Turns out BTS simply got the number wrong. According to FHWA, where all this data supposedly comes from, there were 148 billion passenger-miles-traveled on buses in 2005 and 292 billion in 2011 — meaning passenger miles have almost doubled, along with vehicle miles.

For what it’s worth, FHWA reports the 2011 total number of private and commercial buses at 311,790.

Moving on to urban transit:

First column of numbers is 2005, then 2011, then percentage change. Image: BTS

So transit bus coverage has grown by an astonishing 39 percent over six years but there are actually fewer buses driving all those miles? Passenger miles have risen just 6 percent for those 65,000 additional bus miles? And the number of trips has actually gone down?

I’m no great quantitative data analyst, but these numbers make no sense.

It’s possible that transit systems all over the country have re-prioritized coverage over ridership in their bus service, but probably not by this much.

But perhaps this is where we get to the rah-rah part of our story. Light rail has grown by 46.5 percent, thanks to big extensions in Denver, Salt Lake City and Dallas and new systems in San Diego and Phoenix. This big light-rail push has led to a 39 percent growth in passenger-miles-traveled. Meanwhile, commuter rail and heavy rail ridership is up 20 percent.

Now Amtrak:

First column of numbers is 2005, then 2011, then percentage change. Image: BTS.

The Amtrak system shrunk by about 780 miles in 2005, when Hurricane Katrina damaged the New Orleans-to-Orlando segment of the Sunset Limited line, and it’s never been reopened. Since 2011, however, Amtrak has made up some of those miles by extending service in Maine and Virginia.

The Sunset Limited is Amtrak’s lowest-ridership long-distance line, so maybe shortening it wasn’t the worst thing in the world (although a spokesperson for the rail company notes that service there is still suspended, not permanently cut). No matter what, Amtrak sure is doing something right: It now carries 25 percent more paying riders than in 2005. (Ridership in 2012 was about the same as the 2011 number shown here.)

Meanwhile, as we’ve amply reported, people drove 3.7 percent less between 2005 and 2011. Passenger miles dropped far more, by 15.6 percent. Does that mean there are fewer vehicles on the road (0.6 percent fewer, in fact) but more of them are single-occupancy? One thing is clear: the dip in driving means there was no reason to build 200,000 more lane miles during that time.


Seattle’s Decade-Long Shift Away From Solo Car Commuting

New Census data is out on how Americans commute, and the standout success story is Seattle, where the rate of people who drive alone to work dropped 8.8 percent over the last decade. Tom Fucoloro at Seattle Bike Blog lists some of the highlights — walking is up, the share of women biking to work is rising. All the trends in […]

American Transit Ridership Hits 57-Year High

The last year transit ridership was this high in the United States, Dwight Eisenhower signed the Federal Aid Highway Act. Not since 1956, according to the American Public Transportation Association, have Americans logged as many transit trips as they did in 2013: 10.7 billion. It was the eighth year in a row that Americans have made […]

Census: American Bike Commuting Up Nine Percent in 2012

Congratulations, America. We’re biking to work more than ever before. We’ve known for a while that Americans are driving less than they used to, even as the economy grows. And just about every quarter, the American Public Transportation Association delivers more stats about increasing transit ridership. Now the Census brings another measure of Americans’ shifting transportation […]

Seven Transportation Improvements Everyone Can Agree On

The Reason Foundation, a free-market think tank, is not always a transportation reformer’s best friend. Its scholars gave Florida Gov. Rick Scott inaccurate advice he then used to justify killing high-speed rail in his state. They want to prevent the gas tax from funding “peripheral” programs like transit and active transportation. But Reason Foundation experts have teamed up with […]

Affordable Transportation and Affordable Housing Need to Go Hand-in-Hand

Rents continue to rise in cities across the U.S., and Pittsburgh is no exception. Noting the escalating housing costs in walkable neighborhoods, Alex Shewczyk at Bike Pittsburgh looks at how transportation and housing policy can coordinate to make places more affordable. We know from resources like the Center for Neighborhood Technology’s Housing+Transportation Index that transportation costs are a large household expense […]

FRA Chief: America Is Driving Less and Congress Needs to Catch Up

Speaking to reporters earlier today, Federal Railroad Administration chief Joe Szabo said that people are driving less and using transit more — and that those changes are permanent. “America’s travel habits are undergoing rapid change,” he said. It’s a fact, he said (“not opinion — statistically proven”), calling on Congress to show that it understands […]