The U.S. Transportation Financing Crisis: A Snapshot From the States

Washington transportation policymaking can often resemble an unwieldy soup of anywhere between 50 and 535 local perspectives, as lawmakers from different states and districts vie for a fixed (or even shrinking) amount of federal funding.

gas_tax.jpgCongress isn’t eager to raise fuel taxes to pay for transportation — but what about the states? (Photo: Pop and Politics)

The needs of northeastern states can bear little resemblance to those of their southern or midwestern counterparts, and the mandate for localities to "match" federal transportation funds at an 80-20 ratio (or 50-50, for some transit programs) can prove daunting for cash-strapped areas — particularly as the dwindling value of the gas tax saps transportation budgets.

So as Congress and the Obama administration declining to debate a gas tax increase to pay for the next federal transport bill, how are the states coping?

Some are taking the plunge that Washington won’t, debating new user fees on fuel and driving. Others are simply spending less on maintaining existing infrastructure that is bordering on disrepair. To get a taste of the local developments, let’s take a quick tour of the transportation-financing crisis as it’s unfolding outside of D.C.:

In Kansas, state lawmakers are debating alternative proposals to raise gas taxes and car registration fees to help close a transportation budget that has seen [PDF] $229 million in funding cuts over the past year.

In Virginia, planned transportation cuts over the next six years total $4.6 billion. The planned extension of Washington D.C.’s Metro to Dulles airport will push local tolls 25 cents higher this week, with a planned doubling by 2012. The state gas tax: 40th-highest in the nation, according to the Tax Foundation.

In Georgia, a new report from the state transportation director endorses new revenue-raising methods equivalent to a 1 percent sales tax and warns that the current gas tax — which only meets half of existing infrastructure maintenance needs — may fall short of federal matching requirements as soon as 2012.

In Michigan, an $84 million transportation budget gap for the current fiscal year is expected to cause the loss of $475 million in federal funding. Looking only at maintenance needs, the state fears the share of roads in good repair to fall from 92 percent to 66 percent over the next four years.

In New Jersey, debt service and interest payments on nearly $11 billion in bonding is set to swallow the state’s entire transportation trust fund for 2011, prompting much hand-wringing as new Gov. Chris Christie (R) prepares to take office. Christie campaigned on a promise not to raise the state’s gas tax, which ranks as the nation’s 47th-highest.

In South Dakota, a bipartisan panel of legislators is moving forward with a proposed 10-cent increase in the state gas tax, imposed in two phases, to help raise $240 million for transportation. Other revenue-raising tactics on the table include higher vehicle license fees and new-car excise taxes. The measure could face an uphill battle, however, with a two-thirds majority needed for passage.

In Iowa, a state budget gap estimated at $500 million or more has persuaded Gov. Chet Culver (D) to propose that state troopers be financed by the transportation trust fund — which would leave less money for maintenance of roads and bridges. Bipartisan support for a gas tax increase that materialized last year reportedly has evaporated in the face of a Culver veto threat.


Transport and the Tea Party: How Conservatives Talk About the Gas Tax

The passage of health care legislation this week, while elating Democrats, has proven an equally potent motivator for conservatives advocates of states’ rights. Appearing on Sean Hannity’s Fox News show last night, Sen. Jim DeMint (R-SC) was asked about the viability of the legal challenge to the health bill filed by 14 mostly conservative attorneys […]

Streetsblog Capitol Hill Q&A: Four Questions For Rob Puentes

America’s transportation and infrastructure policies affect literally everyone who moves from place to place in the country, but often they are under-discussed and over-simplified by the mainstream media. To help broaden the debate, Streetsblog Capitol Hill is kicking off a new Q&A series called "The Four Questions." Robert Puentes, senior fellow at the Brookings Institution’s […]

The Big Question: What is the Purpose of Federal Transportation Spending?

With the White House’s agenda crowded by high-profile debates that remain unresolved after lengthy talks with Congress — think health care, financial regulation, even unemployment benefits — only a handful of lawmakers are publicly engaging with the dominant issues surrounding the next long-term federal transportation bill. (Photo: UVA) Within that group of lawmakers, however, there […]

A Bike-Ped State of the Union: 9.6% of Trips, 1.2% of Federal Funding

With the nation still digesting the State of the Union address, the Alliance for Biking & Walking picked an auspicious day to release their biennial Benchmarking report on America’s bike-ped behavior. The group’s bottom-line conclusion: federal transportation funding continues to disproportionately shortchange travelers powered by their own two feet. (Chart: Alliance for Biking & Walking) […]