Stim Cash Gone Bad: Feds Fund Houston’s Highway to Nowhere

holzer.jpgRobin Holzer. Photo: New York Times.

Reuters just wrapped up a two-day "Infrastructure Summit" and published a great collection of stories about the state of transportation policy in the U.S. I especially like this piece, featuring Robin Holzer of the Houston-based Citizens’ Transportation Coalition, who does a great job illustrating some of the major deficiencies that the federal stimulus bill failed to address:

Under the current system that U.S. President Barack Obama
has maintained, at least for now, the U.S. government will pay as much
as 80 percent of the multibillion dollar cost of a proposed 180-mile
ring road around Houston — its fourth such loop — even though it
serves a thinly populated rural area.

In contrast, an expansion of the city’s light-rail system is only
eligible for getting 50 percent of the cost paid by the federal
government, she said.

Yet more than 147,000 people live within a half-mile of the ten stations on the light rail system, Holzer said.

To demonstrate the low demand for the new ring road, Holzer
displayed a picture of its empty lanes that she said she took at 5 p.m.
one weekday — a typical rush hour in urban areas.

"It’s a boondoggle highway in the middle of nowhere," she said. "We need to invest our money where the people are."

  • The excuse is probably that the new road will lay the groundwork for residential and commercial development. This new exurban development is unlikely to take off given the shriveling of existing exurban areas elsewhere in the country. So this is Houston’s last, most futile investment in sprawl. All it proves is that the forces behind sprawl haven’t yet spent their last dime of political capital. But given how New York is squandering the most functional public transit infratructure in the country, who are we to criticize Houston?

  • Veritas

    I grew up in Houston and almost everyone I know there thinks that Grand Parkway is a complete waste of money. But it always seemed like suburban real estate developers were very powerful politically, so they probably pushed this through.

    The current light rail line (there’s only one) has vastly exceeded its ridership projections, even though it doesn’t go on a very great route (it doesn’t do a good job connecting residential and business neighborhoods). Thankfully, the current mayor of Houston, Bill White, has a great urban vision for Houston and is dramatically expanding the light rail system to include five new lines that will be very popular.

  • Jeany

    At the same time, rape victims in Texas have to pay for their own rape kits, making the state again such a paragon of conservative perfection. Protection of citizens who can compensate the state only!


FRA Chief: America Is Driving Less and Congress Needs to Catch Up

Speaking to reporters earlier today, Federal Railroad Administration chief Joe Szabo said that people are driving less and using transit more — and that those changes are permanent. “America’s travel habits are undergoing rapid change,” he said. It’s a fact, he said (“not opinion — statistically proven”), calling on Congress to show that it understands […]

White House Unveils Transit Safety Bill to Cautious Praise on the Hill

Lawmakers on the House transportation committee today greeted details of the Obama administration’s transit safety plan with approval, but some sounded skeptical notes about the costs of state compliance with new federal rules even as transit agencies cope with billions of dollars in maintenance and repair backlogs. Washington D.C.’s transit safety oversight agency has less […]

Calling on Fans of Transit: Get in the Game

Rob Perks is the transportation advocacy director at the Natural Resources Defense Council. As someone who commutes to work on the Metro, I’m a big fan of public transportation. Earlier this week, as I was persusing the sports section of the Washington Post, I read a great story about a super fan. His name is Joel […]

The Build for America Plan: Invest in Transportation, Create Jobs

Janette Sadik-Khan, Congresswoman Carolyn Maloney and Lee Sander. Photo: Paul White. The Build for America campaign officially launched yesterday afternoon at Grand Central Terminal, one of six events held in cities across the nation. DOT Commissioner Janette Sadik-Khan — joined by MTA chief Lee Sander, U.S. reps Jerrold Nadler and Carolyn Maloney, and a bevy […]