Massive Highway Expansion Threatens to Destroy Tampa Neighborhoods

Grassroots advocates have waged a dogged campaign against Tampa's plan to add $6 billion in highway lanes. Now they're starting to gain key political support. Photo: Sunshine Citizens
Grassroots advocates have picked up key political support in their campaign against Florida DOT’s $6 billion plan to widen 90 miles of highways around Tampa. Photo: Sunshine Citizens

Most people still think of Tampa as a sprawling, car-centric town, but that is starting to change. In 2014, Smart Growth America [PDF] found that Tampa is shifting toward a more walkable development pattern. The city is starting to build out a bicycle network, and its Riverwalk project is bringing people out to stroll downtown.

Tampa’s recent progress could be overwhelmed, however, by Florida DOT’s $6 billion Tampa Bay Express project, a 90-mile road widening scheme that will chew up city neighborhoods to add toll lanes to three interstates. Information about the project’s finances is hazy, and Florida DOT has proven that its traffic projections for toll road projects are worthless. Neverthless, regional decision makers are set to take up the plan this week.

On Wednesday, the Hillsborough Metropolitan Planning Organization will vote on Tampa Bay Express.

Tampa's centrally located Seminole Heights historic neighborhood, a former streetcar community filled with charming bungalows, has begun to see reinvestment after decades of decline, but a $6 billion highway plan could deliver another blog. Photo: Wikpedia
Tampa’s Seminole Heights neighborhood is threatened by FDOT’s $6 billion highway widening plan. Photo: Wikipedia

If the highway widenings are built, Governor Rick Scott’s state DOT will seize properties to ram through the new lanes. Of the residents who’ll be uprooted, 80 percent are black or Latino, according to the Tampa Bay Times.

Sprawling development is sure to follow. “You would see a weakening of the trend toward the revitalization of in-town neighborhoods and instead new housing stock farther and farther from the urban core,” said Thomas Hawkins of the smart growth advocacy group 1000 Friends of Florida.

But there’s a chance the highway plan will be defeated, thanks to a grassroots coalition known as Sunshine Citizens that has pushed back against Florida DOT’s agenda.

“For $6 billion we could have a truly multimodal, comprehensive transportation system,” said Michelle Cookson, a leader of Sunshine Citizens who lives in Seminole Heights, one of the neighborhoods that will be affected by the widening. “We know this is the absolute worst choice for us.”

This is what $6 billion in highway projects looks like. Map: FDOT
Florida DOT’s $6 billion, 90-mile highway widening project will mostly uproot black and Latino residents. Map: FDOT

Sunshine Citizens has picked up key political support. The Tampa City Council has voted against the highway project twice. And early this month, Hillsborough County Commissioner Les Miller, head of the Hillsborough MPO, said Florida DOT hadn’t done enough to make the case for the project.

If Tampa Bay Express is added to the list of the region’s priority projects, construction will begin next year. Even with Miller’s defection, shutting down the project will be “tough sledding,” according to the Tampa Bay Times. Only one other member of the 16-person Hillsborough MPO board has voted against the project in the past.

A coalition of 60 private sector heavyweights is lobbying for the highway expansion. Their ranks include the local chamber of commerce, the owner of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and the owner of Publix, a regional supermarket chain. In a letter to the MPO, the highway boosters said $3.3 billion in state funding could go to Orlando or another part of the state if the project isn’t approved.

Florida DOT has also stoked fears of losing out on state funds. Rather than work with local advocates to decide on a different plan to invest in Tampa’s transportation network, the agency has dismissed criticism.

A plan worth $6 billion would include high-quality transit and give some thought to land use, said Cookson.

With the vote looming tomorrow, it’s still not clear how much the project will cost the public. Florida DOT has not been transparent with its financial plan, leading the Tampa Bay Times to declare that “the outlook for the project is hazy.”

The Times’ Craig Pittman noted that Florida DOT can’t be trusted even when it does release toll road financial projections. The nearby Suncoast Parkway failed to produce the $150 million in annual toll revenue that Florida DOT projected — generating $38 million instead — and is now subsidized with revenue from other toll roads.

Cookson isn’t sure whether there are nine votes on the MPO board to remove the highway expansions from the list of projects slated for funding. But regardless of the outcome tomorrow, she says, her group is going to keep fighting.

“We’re just getting started,” she said.

  • greenlake101

    Of all 50 state highway systems, Florida ranks 31st for performance and cost-effectiveness. Maybe they should spend the money on repairing and improving existing roads instead.

    How long will it take for some state DOTs to get through their heads that road-widening does nothing to ease congestion?

  • omaryak

    A more limited project scope could make sense for toll lanes, like across the bridge. But putting any money toward highway expansion while ignoring light rail would be a waste of public resources.

  • rao

    80% of the displaced are black and Latino? There ought to be a civil rights lawsuit here.

  • Charlie

    How about just tolling the existing lanes? No construction needed.

  • Southeasterner

    I believe this project is in Florida where they don’t believe in civil rights.

  • Jesse

    Exactly.

  • R.A. Stewart

    And where displacing black and Latino residents is a nice little lagniappe on top of all the profiteering.

  • KJ

    Or considering commuter rail, as well.

  • robo94117

    $6B looks pretty tantalizing to road construction companies, politicians, and anyone else who can skim the fat off a massive project. Adding capacity does not relieve congestion, here or anywhere else.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Highway Boondoggles: Tampa Bay Express Lanes

|
In a new report, Highway Boondoggles 2 (the original came out in 2014), U.S. PIRG and the Frontier Group teamed up to profile the most wasteful highway projects that state DOTs are building. Streetsblog will be serializing the case studies in the report. Yesterday, we looked at Connecticut’s $11.5 billion I-95 widening. Today, we focus on a proposed $3.3 billion […]

Houston’s Big Chance to Turn Back the Tide of Car Traffic

|
There’s a lot riding on Texas DOT’s $7 billion plan for downtown Houston freeways. TxDOT has been working for more than a decade on a plan for the three highways that roughly form a circle around the city — I-45, I-10, and U.S. 59. Last April, the agency revealed a draft version of the plan, and another revision […]

Huh? After Bailing Out Toll Road, Florida Wants to Expand It

|
By any reasonable measure, the Suncoast Parkway in the Tampa Bay Area has been a complete failure. When it was first proposed, in 1992, consultants predicted the $507 million, 42-mile toll road from Hillsborough to Hernando County would fill up with cars — thanks to the sprawl everyone was sure would follow it. Consultants originally forecast $150 million in […]