Will Philadelphia’s City Council Screw the Pooch on Parking Reform?

City officials in Philadelphia have been hard at work creating a new zoning code for the city. Among the stronger elements is the removal of parking minimums downtown and in many residential neighborhoods — a common-sense reform that will make housing more affordable and curb powerful incentives to own and drive a car.

Parking minimums lead to dead pedestrian environments loaded with cub cuts. Photo: ##http://planphilly.com/eyesonthestreet/2012/11/12/five-reasons-why-philly-shouldnt-set-parking-minimums/##Plan Philly##

But some members of the City Council object to the new code and want to preserve the wasteful, traffic-inducing status quo. They’ve introduced an amendment that would bring back parking minimums.

Artificially inflating the amount of land reserved for parking would be bad for the city in a litany of ways, writes Ashley Hahn at Network blog Plan Philly:

Design-wise we’ve seen the silent streetscapes born out of parking requirements: entire blocks fronted by first floor garages – a move that neighborhoods like Queen Village (an RM-1 district) have actively tried to curb. A steady diet of lifeless, dead-eyed buildings leads to a boring pedestrian environment – no variety, no stoop culture, no snooping, no window shopping – just bland repetition along one big curb cut. A boring streetscape, coupled with decreasing density, creates places where people don’t want to walk (and sometimes feel less safe) or areas where uses are too spread out to make walking trips worthwhile. Hardly the kind of robust, dense, varied urban environment that these districts aim to accommodate. Plus, walkability and density have real value: as a recent study [pdf] by the Congress for New Urbanism confirmed, Philly’s walkable neighborhoods have held their property values better than auto-centric suburbs.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Carfree Baltimore offers some hard numbers showing that the city’s car use is tapering off, while bicycling grows. Spacing Toronto “honors” the electeds who supported the removal of the the Jarvis Street bike lane. And NRDC’s Switchboard blog explains the new collaborative infrastructure program West Coast cities are participating in.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Cincinnati Will Reform Its Parking Mandates

|
Bad parking policy can greatly harm a city. Too much parking makes walking impractical and uncomfortable. It also erodes the tax base, as the map of downtown Detroit we posted last week made painfully clear. Meanwhile, cities that manage the parking supply wisely have bolstered their downtowns, as we’ve seen in the cases of Pittsburgh and […]
Mexico City will use the powerful lever of parking policy to tackle its congestion problem. Photo:  CarlosVanVegas/Flickr

Mexico City May Abolish Its Parking Minimums

|
Mexico City Mayor Miguel Mancera is pursuing a sweeping overhaul of the city's parking policy that's expected to do away with minimum parking requirements and generate revenue for transit and affordable housing. If enacted, the reforms could set an important precedent for cities in North and South America.

New Philly Mayor: Politicos Can No Longer Park on the City Hall Sidewalk

|
The Jim Kenney administration is off to a promising start in Philadelphia. One of the mayor’s first acts in office was to end the thoroughly obnoxious practice of letting government honchos park on the sidewalk “apron” around City Hall — a public space. There was a Tumblr dedicated to chronicling this highly visible abuse of government privilege. And ending the […]

Donald Shoup, an Appreciation

|
On Tuesday, the news came that after 41 years of teaching at UCLA, Donald Shoup, distinguished professor of urban planning, will retire. For all of us who have had our paths in life profoundly influenced by his research, writing, and teaching on parking and transportation, it’s a good time to reflect. I never got to […]