Detroit Media Mogul: Beware Transport Subsidies (Except for Cars)

From Scott Walker to the New York Post, opponents of transit and bicycling have displayed a masterful ability to selectively apply their disdain for “government interference.”

Keith Crain of Crain's Communications is just fine with this kind of government spending. Photo: ##http://www.transportmichigan.org/2011/05/crain-of-crains-rails-against-rail.html## Transport Michigan##

When it comes to transportation policy, they equate spending on rail lines or bike lanes to socialism, while overlooking any and all subsidies for roads and cars. That’s just the “free market” at work, they say.

The latest purveyor of this double-standard is none other than the publisher of a national news conglomerate. Keith Crain, chairman of the Crain’s media empire, doesn’t like the fact that Michigan Governor Rick Snyder has accepted federal money for a rail connection with Chicago.

As Joel Batterman at Network blog Transport Michigan points out, Crain has a pretty short memory:

“Beware,” Crain warns, “when anyone shows up and says, ‘I am from the government and I’m here to help you.'” Interesting. Turns out a certain Detroit publisher begged the federal government to step in and bail out another transportation industry (hint: four wheels, internal combustion engine) just three years ago. “Across the world,” Crain wrote back then, “governments are reaching out to help their auto companies survive.” He lamented the “theatrics” that Big Three CEOs had to endure in Washington hearings after their neglect of more fuel-efficient vehicles nearly wiped out the industry.

Come to think of it, didn’t the government have a hand in building our roads, too? Why no column titled “We don’t need highway aid from Washington,” just for consistency’s sake? In Crain’s mind, are the Interstates also an example of Big Government largesse?

The “libertarian,” “public choice” argument for exclusive government support of automobiles is getting just a little old these days. It’s rather embarrassing, here in Michigan, watching poor Keith trying to make it work in defiance of historical memory. How can anyone still think this way, when they’ve just had the government step in to save their whole business universe?

Elsewhere on the Network today: The Wash Cycle asks if it’s time to retire the “Share the Road” sign. Gateway Streets reports that despite the St. Louis region’s growing number of roadway miles, commuting isn’t getting any easier for area residents. And Rebuilding Place in the Urban Space comments on D.C.’s attempt to raise residential parking fees for households that own multiple vehicles.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Today’s Headlines

|
New York Times Asks: Is It OK to Kill Cyclists? It’s Not Just Transit — Most Other Transpo Funding Measures Passed in Tuesday’s Elections (ARTBA) Obama Pushes for Infrastructure Improvement (NYT) Transpo Funding Bills Run Up Against End of Session in PA, WA (Mercury, Seattle Times) Michigan, Oklahoma Slow Down Transpo Spending Amid Funding Crunch (Daily […]

Today’s Headlines

|
Now Is the Time to Fight, Transportation Advocates (Transport Politic) Rep. De Fazio Champions Safe Routes to School Just Before Party Line Vote to Defund (Shareable) GOP Transit Bill Gets Railed From All Sides (Washington Times, Hill) Just How Big Are Subsidies to Fossil-Fuel Companies? (Grist) Climate Change Will Make You Love Big Government (Grist) […]

Another Shutdown Avoided

|
It’s getting to be a little like the Boy Who Cried Wolf over on Capitol Hill. I mean, it’s hard to get all revved up about an impending government shutdown when Congress always insists on taking negotiations to the edge and they always figure out something right before the deadline. The 2011 fiscal year ends […]

Smaller Cities Propel Amtrak Ridership to a New High

|
It’s been another year of ridership growth for Amtrak, despite the difficulties caused by Hurricane Sandy in the Northeast. In fiscal year 2013, the nation’s intercity rail service saw its 10th ridership increase in 11 years, carrying a record 31.6 million passengers [PDF]. The Northeast Corridor still accounts for a huge share of Amtrak’s total […]