Earlier this month, Transportation Secretary Elaine Chao put a highly-regarded project to modernize Caltrain, the commuter rail line between San Jose and San Francisco, in jeopardy. Acting at the behest of Congressional Republicans opposed to high-speed rail, Chao delayed a $647 million grant for Caltrain electrification, throwing its future in doubt.
It looks like Republicans in other states were watching and learning.
State lawmakers in Minnesota are appealing to Chao to sink Minneapolis's Southwest Light Rail, a 15-mile route between downtown the western suburbs expected to draw about 35,000 weekday passengers.
State Senator David Osmek wants a $900 million federal transit grant to go to roads instead, or barring that, anything else that's not transit for Minneapolis. Photo: Minnesota Senate
A grant from the Federal Transit Administration's New Starts program is supposed to cover $929 million of the $1.85 billion project, which is currently in the engineering phase.
State Senator David Osmek, who represents the western suburbs, has introduced a resolution in the Republican-controlled legislature asking Chao to divert that $929 million to roads and bridges around the state.
By law, however, the FTA grant funding can't be transferred to roads. "They can’t reprogram [Federal Transit Administration] funds," said Stephen Lee Davis of Transportation for America. "There’s no way to do that. They’ll just lose the money. That money will just go to another place."
That wouldn't bother Osmek, who told the Star Tribune he would rather lose the money to another state altogether than see it spent on transit.
It's unclear if Chao can even rescind the money at this point. While a full funding agreement has yet to be signed, the FTA has approved the grant. Yanking the funding away would be highly unusual at the very least, said Davis.
Trump's upcoming budget could give ammunition to local Republicans looking to disrupt urban transit projects, Davis warned. The budget is expected to include sweeping cuts (except to military spending, naturally), and the GOP has been targeting transit funding for years.
Angie is a Cleveland-based writer with a background in planning and newspaper reporting. She has been writing about cities for Streetsblog for six years.
We talk a lot about how parking minimums drive up housing costs, but so do overly wide roads. Why not take away a lane or two and let people build on the land?
A lot of Americans traded long commutes for short errands during the pandemic — but whether that swap resulted in more or less driving is a consequence of policy choices.