The Incompatibility of Resilience and Sprawl

Leaders in the Dallas-Fort Worth area recently came together to discuss the idea of resilience — whether the region can withstand big shifts like climate change and oil price shocks, and bounce back from unanticipated setbacks.

Is this what a resilient city looks like? Image: ##http://www.city-data.com/forum/atlanta/777942-why-does-atlanta-get-bum-rap-7.html##City Data##

That got Patrick Kennedy at Walkable Dallas Fort Worth thinking about how sprawl — one of the Big D’s defining characteristics — can influence a region’s ability to adapt with the changing times:

Just fly in or out of DFW. As you’re taking off or landing, look down. Get to know the incredible and overwhelming sameness of it all. The lack of neighborhoods replaced by the presence of generic sameness of houses made of sticks and spit jammed onto cul-de-sacs of social isolation. Drive the highways and arterials. Pretend you don’t know where you are and ask, “Where am I?” You probably could be anywhere.

Local leaders made the point that the regional economy is diverse — a key element of resilience. Kennedy points out of that in other critical ways, the region sorely lacks diversity and choice:

But what about interconnections, the physical infrastructure that allows for the invisible social and economic bonds to exist? That of the top 20 metropolitan areas in the country, only Detroit has a higher percentage of driving commuters. There is no positive way to spin that. It’s a homogeneity of transportation. If you lack choice, you lack adaptability, a key component to resilience.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Greater Greater Washington chronicles the ongoing saga of “who’s parking in the L Street bike lane.” Pennsylvania Bikes and Walks looks at how the state can rise in the League of American Bicyclists’ annual Bike-Friendly States ranking. And The City Fix examines how countries around the world are financing sustainable transportation projects.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Obama: The Days of “Building Sprawl Forever” Are Over

|
Obama in Ft. Myers This is encouraging. On the stump in Fort Myers, Florida to campaign for the stimulus bill, President Obama took a detour from his well-worn "roads and bridges" infrastructure spiel to deliver some brief remarks on transit and land use. Obama’s answer came in response to a city council member who said […]

How Sprawl Hits Atlanta Residents Right in the Wallet

|
There’s no shortage of good reasons to drive less, but maybe the most compelling personal incentive is that it can save you a ton of money. Unfortunately, in a lot of places, making major changes to your travel habits is not that simple. Darin at ATL Urbanist says that in his city, most people are essentially trapped […]

Job Sprawl Leader Atlanta Shows Signs of Reversal

|
When it comes to job sprawl, few regions have been as gung-ho as Atlanta. During the 2000s, Atlanta area employers sprawled at twice the national average. At the end of that decade, only Detroit and Chicago had a greater share of jobs further away from downtown. Just one in 10 jobs in the Atlanta region […]

Is “Sprawl Repair” Worth It?

|
Transforming the territory of strip malls and big boxes into walkable places is a hot topic, exemplified by the popular book “Retrofitting Suburbia.” But is it worth the time, money, and effort? Robert Steuteville of Better! Cities & Towns writes that architect Kevin Klinkenberg and development expert Lee Sobel raised the question at this year’s Congress for the […]

Paul Krugman Links Sprawl to Persistent Social Inequality

|
Is sprawl holding back social mobility in America? Paul Krugman didn’t mince words yesterday in a follow-up to a post he wrote soon after the Detroit bankruptcy was announced. In that initial blog post, he compared Detroit to Pittsburgh and concluded that it wasn’t just the loss of manufacturing jobs that hurt Detroit — it was […]