Don’t Forget the Third Party Candidates!

In recent posts, we’ve explored the impact President Obama has had on transportation and land-use policy, and we’ve tried to square Candidate Mitt Romney’s oil-soaked rhetoric with Governor Mitt Romney’s smart growth record.

We don’t want anyone protesting outside our offices, so our coverage of the presidential election must include the third party candidates.

Green Party candidate Jill Stein

Green Party nominee Jill Stein takes her transportation agenda from the party platform — which is everything a sustainability promoter would love. Cheap or free mass transit, funded by “major public investment.” An end to automobile and fossil fuel subsidies. A moratorium on highway widening, using the money saved for mass transit and facilities for pedestrians and bicyclists. Free community bike fleets. High-speed rail. No free parking in non-residential areas well served by mass transit, preferential parking rates for HOVs. Higher gas taxes, with some compensation for low income drivers. Freight transport by rail.

The Green transportation platform is by far the most complete of the four minor parties on the ballot in the race for president.

Libertarian Party candidate Gary Johnson

Libertarian Gary Johnson, the former governor of New Mexico, doesn’t have anything to say about transportation at all. And his energy platform is simple: “The government should simply stay out of the business of trying to promote or ‘manage’ energy development. The marketplace will meet our energy needs.” That means no subsidies for fossil fuels. One would imagine he’s not a big proponent of subsidies for transit, either — though other libertarians, notably Ron Paul, have taken a more complex view.

Constitution Party candidate Virgil Goode

Former U.S. Rep. Virgil Goode, a former Democrat and Republican who is now running with the Constitution Party, is similarly silent on transportation and infrastructure. His energy platform centers around independence from foreign fossil fuels — not from all fossil fuels. It reads more like a national security policy than an energy policy. Drilling in Alaska and off shore? Let’s do it. The Constitution Party would abolish the Department of Energy.

For what it’s worth, during the re-election campaign that he eventually lost, one of the most damaging events for Goode was when supporters showed up to a July Fourth rally in a Hummer. It blew up when Jon Stewart lampooned the event on the Daily Show, saying Goode was too cozy with big oil and too disconnected from his constituents.

Justice Party candidate Rocky Anderson

On the ballot in 15 states is Rocky Anderson, whose leadership of Salt Lake City has led many to dub him one of the greenest mayors in America. He committed the city to the emissions reduction goals set out in the Kyoto Protocol, which the city surpassed seven years ahead of schedule. His sustainability program improved the bicycle and pedestrian infrastructure in the city, and he passionately supported brownfield development.

In an address to the Downtown Business Association in 2000, Anderson opposed a 1.1 milion square foot “sprawl mall” and asked, “Will we fall into the trap of further suburbanization, look-alike chain-store developments (with all profits and support expenditures flowing out of state), greater sprawl, traffic congestion, crowding and air pollution? Or will we plan wisely and for the future, with support for those who would help revitalize our downtown and west side, with friendlier, more livable communities?”

You don’t have to be Nate Silver to know that none of these fine men and women are going the win the presidency today, but polling that only asks about the two top candidates can obscure the role they might play. A recent CNN poll included three of these candidates — excluding Anderson, sadly — and found that Libertarian Gary Johnson commanded 4 percent of the vote and Green Jill Stein got 2 percent. The Constitution Party’s Virgil Goode finished with less than half of one percent — but could still play spoiler in a close race in his home state of Virginia.

  • Davistrain

    How about Peace and Freedom candidate, Roseanne Barr?  If an actor like Ronald Reagan could become President, we couldn’t do any worse with a performer like Roseanne.  (she is on the ballot in California, I don’t know how many other states have her as a choice.)

  • Anonymous

    I just wish the federal government would move to a run-off system so that I can vote for my candidate of choice and not feel like, in the case when that person is not likely to win, I’m jeopardizing the chances of my next favorite candidate. (The classic example would be wanting a Green Party candidate as first choice but, realizing they’ll never win, not wanting to vote for them and jeopardize the chances of a Democrat, the next favorite choice and much more likely candidate to win, from winning).

  • Michael Hicks

    I’ll just point out Wikipedia’s list of third party candidates for 2012, which also shows maps of ballot access.,_2012

  • Anonymous

    With California’s open primary the November election becomes a 2-candidate run-off, so for Senate and House the 3rd party and, for that matter, write-in candidates have already been  blown off the ballot.  In the end, it’s a better system, but in my direct case forces me to select between pro-war Dianne Feinstein and “Pipeline of Prosperity” Elizabeth Emkin, neither of whom I’m willing to vote for.


What the Price of Parking Shows Us About Cities

Cross-posted from City Observatory.  Earlier, we rolled out our parking price index, showing the variation in parking prices among large US cities. Gleaning data from ParkMe, a web-based directory of parking lots and rates, we showed how much it cost to park on a monthly basis in different cities. There’s a surprising degree of variation: […]

Feeding the Beast: The Backdoor Ways Transit Subsidizes Roads

We’ve done our share of commentary on this blog about how transit is underfunded in the first place. So it’s all the more upsetting to see highway projects pick the pocket of transit agencies. But that’s exactly what’s happening, in different forms, in different places throughout the country, writes Alon Levy at Pedestrian Observations. Levy […]

Ron Paul: Stop Subsidizing Highways, Let “Transits” Flourish

Before the Iowa caucuses, we wrote briefly about the candidates’ positions on transportation, but we’d missed this tidbit. (Thanks to an anonymous reader for bringing it to our attention.) In this video from 2009, Ron Paul responds to a supporter’s angst about light rail – he wants to oppose anything that was built with government […]