A Tappan Zee Bridge Without Transit Is a Lousy Jobs Program

Here’s the thing about big transportation projects: Even the worst of them, the biggest stinkers, at the very least produce a few temporary construction jobs.

A few temporary construction jobs aren't reason enough for New York to spend billions building a sprawl-inducing bridge. Photo: ##http://longislanddailyphoto.blogspot.com/2010/08/tappan-zee-up-close.html##Long Island Daily Photo##

Take a flawed project like the replacement of New York’s Tappan Zee Bridge, which Governor Andrew Cuomo wants to build without the transit component envisioned by the decade-long public planning process. A politician with extremely low standards for how public money is spent is likely to argue that the construction jobs alone are justification enough to plow ahead.

New York Assemblywoman Ellen Jaffee wrote in a recent op-ed that the state should rush forward this multi-billion-dollar gift to car commuters because “our community cannot afford to wait for new jobs.”

But even as a jobs program, it’s pretty lousy, writes Network blogger Cap’n Transit:

Not all employment programs are created equal. There are many ways to create jobs, including monetary policy, unemployment insurance and infrastructure spending. You could create jobs by rebuilding the Tappan Zee Bridge, but it’s a wasteful and environmentally destructive way of satisfying that basic economic need.

On a basic level, you could pay people to dig holes and fill them up for years, and stimulate the economy that way, but some forms of stimulus are better and others are worse. For years, Smart Growth America has been highlighting data showing that government spending on mass transit projects creates more and better jobs per dollar than road projects.

If you want to create jobs in the Lower Hudson Valley, why not spend it rebuilding the old rail infrastructure? I bet that five billion dollars would be enough to rebuild the tracks on every train line that ever existed in Orange, Bergen and Rockland Counties, double-track them, lower the floor on the West Shore Line, and restore passenger service on all of them. Any leftover money could be spent rebuilding the Putnam Line and NYW&B in Westchester, or digging the Cross-Harbor Rail Freight Tunnel. Tons of good jobs there. No need to rebuild a bridge that has filled the area with sprawl and will only generate more sprawl.

Elsewhere on the Network today: Bike Portland asks if US Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood can honestly claim to be a proponent of livability while supporting the $3 billion monument to single-occupancy vehicles that is the Columbia River Crossing. Bike Friendly Oak Cliff explains that just two percent of Dallas’s streets budget could build 100 miles of bike lanes. And Los Angeles County Bicycle Coalition reports that cycling is up 32 percent over three years.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

President Obama’s Hollow Push for Infrastructure Investment

|
This afternoon, President Obama stood by New York’s Tappan Zee Bridge and made a speech pressing Congress to do something about infrastructure investment. It’s part of his Infrastructure Week push for Congress to pass a fully funded transportation reauthorization bill. Many other groups are spending this week sounding the same horn. “If they don’t act […]

Federal Fast-Track Process Strips Transit Component From Tappan Zee

|
We reported yesterday that the Obama administration had selected 14 infrastructure projects, including five transportation projects, to put on the fast track for construction. We mentioned that there were early warnings from transit advocates that at least one of these projects might not go exactly as planned. Noah Kazis at Streetsblog NYC looked deeper into […]

What Went Wrong With Boston’s Green Line Extension?

|
Last week, the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority abruptly cut ties with four contractors working on the 4.7-mile Green Line extension to Somerville and Medford, outside Boston. The announcement came shortly after reports that the cost of the light rail project had ballooned to about $3 billion, an increase of a billion dollars. State officials said the decision doesn’t mean […]

San Francisco Mayor to NYC: “Eat Your Heart Out.”

|
A rendering of the Transbay Transit Center with a 5.4 acre park on its roof. At a groundbreaking ceremony for the long-awaited Transbay Transit Center in San Francisco yesterday, Mayor Gavin Newsom asserted the project will be "so much more extraordinary than Grand Central Station." Pointing to the renderings on a projection screen behind him, […]

Transportation Projects Chosen For Federal Fast-Tracking Lean Multi-Modal

|
Last month Streetsblog asked whether President Obama would select transportation projects that reduce congestion, improve air quality, and create jobs when he picked several infrastructure investments, among those recommended by agency officials, to fast-track. The selection of these projects, intended to help spur short-term job creation, could avoid the mistakes of the 2009 stimulus program, […]