Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Bicycling

Upstate NY City Makes it Illegal to Block Bicycle Lanes

The City of Rochester in upstate New York has been working for years to add bicycle lanes to its streets. Now it will be illegal to park in them. Image: City of Rochester

The City of Rochester in upstate New York has for the last few years been adding bicycle lanes in hopes of retaining and attracting young people to the town on the shores of Lake Ontario. But up until a few weeks ago, it was perfectly legal to park a car in one.

Finally, the City Council voted earlier this month to give police the authority to write a ticket for simply blocking a bike line, thanks to a bill submitted by Mayor Lovely Warren, the radio station WXXI-AM reports.

Before the bill was passed, most bike lanes in the Flour City were only protected from being blocked if a car driver was violating an existing "no parking" regulation at the site — so police could only issue tickets when a parker was violating a "No Standing" or "No Stopping" or "No Parking" regulation on the block. Now, police can issue tickets just for blocking the lane — solving a problem city officials and bike advocates said was keeping people from pedaling.

Rochester Mayor Lovely Warren. Photo: City of Rochester
Rochester Mayor Lovely Warren. Photo: City of Rochester
Rochester Mayor Lovely Warren. Photo: City of Rochester

"Without enforcement, bike lanes are not usable, they're not safe, and they're really not helping Rochester meet its goals with getting more people of all ages on bikes," Jesse Peers, the cycling coordinator for the pro-bike group Reconnect Rochester, told the station.

The city completed its bicycle master plan — which aims at attracting residents by making the are more bicycle friendly — in 2011, and it has led to new bicycle-only and shared lanes across the city, with a focus on the Downtown area.

Of course, passing a law banning a practice is one thing, but getting it enforced is another.

Just hours before the vote, a member of Mayor Warren’s team was spotted blocking a bike lane a government-issued SUV.

A reporter for WXXI radio in the Lake Ontario town took a Kodak (okay, a picture, but let’s remember the history of this municipality), of the director of emergency communication idling in a bike lane in front of City Hall just a few ticks on the clock before the panel rubber-stamped legislation making such a move illegal.

City spokesman Justin Roz initially told reporters the car was there to pick up a deputy mayor for lunch, but later claimed the drivers had pulled over to take a phone call, pointing out that was a reasonable use for a bike lane that wouldn't break the new "no stopping" law.

"What I would refer to as 'stopping' is stopping at length," Roj told the station. "It's not contrary to the way, in essence, the spirit of the law is seen."

Forward-thinking medium-sized cities such has Rochester, which has a population of just over 200,000, have for the last few years tried to make themselves more bike-friendly using an "if you build it, they will come approach" to bicycle infrastructure.

Last year, the website PeopleForBikes.com ranked Fort Collins, Colo.; Boulder; and Providence as the top three medium cities for bicyclists, with Ann Arbor and Alexandria rounding out the top five.

Interestingly, the city council in the Virginia suburb recently went against some public opinion and voted to go ahead with a controversial bike lane in that city.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Trump’s ‘EV Mandate’ Does Not Exist. But Car Dependency Does — And We Can End It

The new president has sworn to unravel Biden's EV plans. But would they have been enough to decarbonize the transportation sector without confronting how much Americans drive?

January 22, 2025

Wednesday’s Headlines Get a Gentleman’s ‘C’

Transportation for America gave the Biden administration middling grades. Meanwhile, President Trump is already following through on promises to cancel EVs.

January 22, 2025

Drivers Keep Hitting Pedestrians In Front of An Iconic St. Louis Ice Cream Shop. Advocates Are Fighting Back.

A series of crashes outside a popular St. Louis landmark carries a larger lesson about traffic violence, and the cost of government inaction.

January 22, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines Take Me Home, Country Roads

Getting around without a car in a small town isn't easy, as one Fast Company writer found out. More bike lanes and denser town centers would help.

January 21, 2025

How America Can Reconnect Its Neighborhoods Before the Next Climate Catastrophe

America is replete with sprawling, disconnected neighborhoods that send residents out of their way by design. A new study explores just how bad it is — and what we can do about it.

January 21, 2025
See all posts