Baltimore Invents an Excuse to Avoid Building Its Downtown Bike Network

Residents of Potomac Street upset about the replacement of parking spaces to make way for this bike lane were the first to cite fire clearance as a reason to block the project. Now the city is parroting their argument to delay action on its downtown bike plan. Google Street View
Residents of Potomac Street upset about the replacement of parking spaces to make way for this bike lane were the first to cite fire clearance as a reason to block the project. Now the city is parroting their argument to delay action on its downtown bike plan. Google Street View

Baltimore was supposed to have a 10-mile downtown bike lane network by now: Six lanes of protected bike lanes and four miles of unprotected lanes. The $2.8 million plan was developed after extensive public feedback.

Instead, as of today, Baltimore has completed just 2.5 miles of bike lanes. The project is almost 100 percent over budget, and the bike network city residents were promised is not coming anytime soon.

This week, city officials decided to delay work by nearly another year, supposedly due to concerns about fire safety. The Baltimore Fire Department says its vehicles need 20 feet of street width to meet international fire code, which the city has adopted wholesale without modification to reflect local conditions. That conflicts with the bike lane designs — and it also conflicts with many other typical Baltimore streets that just happen to not be very wide.

This story isn’t just about inflexible bureaucracy run amok. It’s about how car owners disingenuously steered the bureaucracy to block the conversion of on-street motor vehicle storage into bike infrastructure.

The 20-foot clearance issue was first raised by a group of residents who opposed a bike lane because it replaced parking. By presenting their campaign under the veneer of “fire safety” they’ve been able to deny progress on real street safety improvements.

The bike lanes would not only make cycling safer, they’ve been shown to make walking and driving safer too, by reducing the prevalence of lethal speeding. Baltimore streets could use that type of engineering: Traffic fatalities are on the rise, with 53 people losing their lives in 2016, nearly double the rate in 2012. Among the victims were 18 pedestrians, up from eight in 2012 [PDF].

“They’re holding this up as a life safety issue,” said Liz Cornish, executive director of the local advocacy organization Bikemore. “Meanwhile we’re ignoring the more pressing life safety issue — that’s people getting killed when they walk or bike in Baltimore city.”

Baltimore ped deaths
Chart: City of Baltimore

It’s not uncommon for urban street redesigns to provoke objections from local fire departments about narrowing the right-of-way for their large vehicles. But most of the streets in Baltimore already don’t meet the 20-foot standard, said Cornish, and it’s never been an obstacle before.

Baltimore was one of 10 cities selected last year to receive support from People for Bikes to achieve dramatic increases in cycling. Many other cities applied for that grant funding. The fact that the clearance standard is being cited now suggests the city’s real motivation isn’t public safety — it’s mollifying the bike lane opponents upset about a few on-street parking spaces, without admitting it.

“You’ve been fighting fires on these narrow city streets,” said Cornish. “This idea that all of a sudden it’s a problem is ludicrous.”

Baltimore's plans call for 10 miles of downtown bike lanes. Only 2 miles have been constructed. Map: Bikemore
Baltimore’s plans call for 10 miles of downtown bike lanes. Only two miles have been constructed. Map: Bikemore

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Rescuing New Ideas From the Purgatory of Old Bureaucracy

|
Your city may have a complete streets policy. Your mayor may say all the right things about making streets work for walking, biking, and transit. But if the inner workings of government — city budgets, agency protocols — aren’t set up to enable big street design breakthroughs, all you’ll get are scattershot improvements. Writing for Network blog Broken Sidewalk, Chris […]