Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Streetsblog.net

The Old “We Don’t Need Bike Lanes Because Nobody Bikes Here” Nonsense

"I went out and parked under a shade tree, it was on a Saturday, a beautiful day and I counted in one hour 374 cars and zero bikes," Fresno City Councilman Steve Brandau told a local ABC affiliate.

false

That claim -- some version of which should be familiar to bike advocates everywhere -- was used to kill a road diet in Fresno, California, that was planned for three years, enjoyed wide public support, and would have cost local taxpayers nothing. James Sinclair at Stop and Move is outraged that a thoroughly vetted project that would have offered many public benefits was derailed.

He says the "nobody bikes here so we don't need bike lanes" attitude is willful political ignorance at its worst:

That's right, one council member chose to ignore expert traffic engineers, expert planners, and years of community outreach and work because he sat outside in his car and counted cars. And so he torpedoed a project outside his jurisdiction, one which he apparently did not understand.

Let's also forget for a second that sitting in your car for an unspecified amount of time is not a traffic study. Let's imagine for a second, that not one cyclist actually did go by. 374 cars on a 4 lane road? Clearly, the REAL traffic engineers were right when they said a road diet would cause no congestion -- that's nothing!

There's also the fact that cyclists don't use the road BECAUSE it lacks bike lanes. Nobody drives on the proposed Veteran's Avenue either, and yet the city will spend tens of millions to build it.

Sinclair says the only good thing that could come out of this ordeal is for Brandau to be voted out of office. Shortly after his "stand" against bike lanes, Sinclair reports, a handful of people expressed interest in challenging him.

Elsewhere on the Network today: The Dallas Morning News' Transportation Blog reports that there is still talk of tearing down a downtown highway. Bike Portland explores possible explanations for the precipitous drop in cycling among girls after the age of 14. And the Beat Bike Blog explains why he's so happy not to have a yard.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Talking Headways Podcast: Buildings are Here to Help People

Jeremy Wells on his book, Managing the Magic of Old Places: Crafting Public Policies for People-Centered Historic Preservation.

March 12, 2026

Bus Companies Say There’s a Better Way to Take a ‘Great American Road Trip’ This Summer

"Our eventual goal is to make inter-city bus travel every American's first consideration when they think about how to get from one city to the next."

March 12, 2026

Opinion: Make This Summer’s World Cup A Car-Free Paradise

NYC has a major opportunity to support people who don't drive during the World Cup. Could other host cities do it, too?

March 12, 2026

Thursday’s Headlines Can’t Keep Up

While other developed nations are building more transit lines as their populations increase, the U.S. is not.

March 12, 2026

Wednesday’s Headlines Are Leading the Blind

Unfortunately, many city streets and subway stations are still not ADA compliant.

March 11, 2026

Trump’s Funding Freeze Has Derailed Transit, Undermining Growth and Economic Opportunity For All Americans

American cities used to have some of the longest per-capita rail networks in the world. Not anymore.

March 11, 2026
See all posts