Violent Crime Up in the Suburbs, Down in Big Cities

A result of better city policing? Or a symptom of suburban decline?

The owner of this Atlanta convenience store was killed -- outside his home in suburban Clayton County, 15 miles south of the city. Violent crime has spiked in the Atlanta suburbs, while plummeting in the city, reflecting a broader national trend. Image: ##http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424127887323300404578206873179427496.html## Wall Street Journal##

The Wall Street Journal reports that over the last 10 years violent crime has spiked in the suburbs while tapering off in cities. Using data from the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics and the Brookings Institution, WSJ reporters found that suburban homicide rates increased 16.9 percent between 2001 and 2010, while large cities saw a 16.7 percent decline over the same period.

“Today, suburban murders, from domestic violence to robberies gone bad to massacres like the Newtown, Conn., school shootings, make up about a quarter of all homicides in the U.S., up from 20.7% in 2001,” WSJ reporters Cameron McWhirter and Gary Fields write.

The reasons for the trend are still subject to speculation. The Journal cites better medical response and “aggressive policing” in places like New York and Los Angeles. McWhirter and Fields also point to stagnating resources for suburban police departments:

Criminologists and public officials cite weaker and more resource-strapped law enforcement in some suburbs for the increase, among other factors. That, in turn, attracts criminals who focus on suburbs, because they are looking for easier places than relatively well-policed cities to commit crimes.

“They just shifted their operations,” said Craig Steckler, the departing police chief of Fremont, Calif., and president of the International Association of Chiefs of Police.

Some of the biggest increases in crime were in the suburbs of Houston, Atlanta and Pittsburgh, WSJ reported. In Atlanta, a particularly pronounced case, violent crime rose 23 percent in the suburbs while dropping 49 percent in the city between 2000 and 2008.

  • Anonymous

    No one knows why crime has dropped so sharply in cities–taking WSJ at face value on this or anything else is ridiculous. The likely surmise for greater crime in the suburbs would include increasing amounts of poverty in suburbs, with demographic changes, greater drug use, etc., and one would imagine that many things have lagged like policing, crime prevention, etc.How police operate and what they do (e.g., more investment in crime prevention, motivating or retiring lazy cops who figured the suburbs were an easy gig) is probably more important than just “more resources”. the idea that criminals are simply going to the suburbs is laughable. They’re probably more likely to live there than before.

  • Anonymous

    Always beware of the low-base fallacy. A neighborhood that had 2 car thefts one year, 3 the other experienced an “explosive 50% car crime increase”.

  • Anonymous

    Kevin Drum has a good article on the drop in violent crime in cities: http://www.motherjones.com/environment/2013/01/lead-crime-link-gasoline

    Yep, lead…

  • Kong

    Demographics are destiny.  Urban areas are gentrifying and suburban poverty is rising.  Crime stats are just reflecting that trend.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

The Suburbs Aren’t Dying — They’re Growing Differently

By Tony Dutzik |
Cross-posted from the Frontier Group. Sommer Mathis said much of what needed to be said about the recent round of “the suburbs are back, baby!” stories on housing trends, including this analysis from Jed Kolko, housing economist at Trulia.com, and the related commentary from Matt Yglesias at Vox. Mathis argues that the concept of a battle for supremacy between cities and […]

Will This Be the Decade of Big City Growth?

By William H. Frey |
William H. Frey is an internationally regarded demographer and senior fellow with the Brookings Institution. This article was originally posted by the Brookings Institution. Figure 1: Large City Growth* For the first third of this decade, big city population growth continues to outpace the rates of 2000 through 2010 while suburban growth continues to lag behind, according to new […]

The Globalization of Suburbia

By Brad Aaron |
The above photo could be a scene from Any Suburb, USA. Except … what’s the deal with the helmet-free cyclist in street clothes? “Welcome to Orange County,” writes Andrew Stokols at TheCityFix. “No, not Orange County, California. This is Orange County, Beijing.” Stokols says walled-off suburbs modeled on U.S. “gated communities” are gaining popularity among the affluent […]

Brookings: Inadequate Transit and Sprawl Cut Off Workers From Jobs

By Tanya Snyder |
If there’s a problem connecting workers with workplaces, it stands to reason that there’s a problem connecting workplaces with workers. A new report from the Brookings Institution has teased out the subtleties of this side of the transit/jobs equation. Last year, Brookings found that, on average, 70 percent of jobs in a metropolitan region are […]