Smaller Cities Taking on Big Transit Projects

A coalition of local partners was able to dust off this vintage streetcar in Savannah, Georgia and get it running for just $1.5 million. Photo: Reconnecting America

Grand Rapids, Michigan. Fort Collins, Colorado. Savannah, Georgia.

Mid-sized cities like these are stepping up and demanding many of the same transit improvements as their larger cousins. A new report from Reconnecting America [PDF] offers recommendations for these less populated cities to consider, whether they’re pursuing some version of bus rapid transit or a streetcar.

The mid-sized cities the report focuses on have populations between 50,000 and 250,000. What they have in common, in addition to their modest sizes, is a less dense residential pattern, lower levels of congestion, and greater job dispersion. But in many ways, they face the same issues as bigger cities, report authors Sarah Kline and Sasha Forbes write.

They identify three keys to success for mid-sized cities taking on “second-generation” transit projects:

  • key champions and partnerships among relevant stakeholders
  • a solid funding package
  • an understanding of the role transit plays in the context of local land use

Bus service will be “the backbone” of the transit system in these smaller metros. But if those three fundamentals are in place, adding bus rapid transit or a streetcar system can help boost mobility and promote urban development — just the way they have in larger cities. Kline and Forbes report that streetcar systems in Tampa, Florida and Little Rock, Arkansas have generated $150 million and $800 million in development investment, respectively.

Here’s a great example from Grand Rapids, which is in the middle of constructing an extensive bus rapid transit system:

The project includes dedicated lanes for 65 percent of its 9.6 mile route, and will connect major destinations in downtown Grand Rapids such as Michigan State University, Grand Rapids Community College, and DeVos Place Convention Center and Performance Hall.

In the central business district, 30,000 jobs will be within a quarter-mile of the BRT.

Recognizing that transit works best when the surrounding land uses provide the system with a critical mass of riders and destinations, the city has created a TOD zone in its zoning code for the areas around BRT stops, with higher height limits and the ability to waive parking requirements entirely.

Credit is also due to Savannah, which built its tourist-oriented “Dottie” streetcar line for a thrifty $1.5 million. Reconnecting America also has praise for Flagstaff, Arizona’s NAIPTA, where transit supporters bounced back from a ballot box defeat to better align their proposal with public wishes and win support for a service expansion.

4 thoughts on Smaller Cities Taking on Big Transit Projects

  1. Seattle had a “vintage streetcar” operation with tramcars from Melbourne, Australia (similar to the one in the photo).  Unfortunately, the local official who was the main advocate for the waterfront streetcar passed away, and when a big art museum wanted the space occupied by the carbarn for a “sculpture garden”, there was nobody who would step up and make sure a new carbarn was built before the old one was torn down.  The trams are presently in storage and hope for a revival of vintage streetcars is dim.

  2. @b9079a2928b221307247ecba46d1ed0f:disqus : Yeah, so sad. Last time I was up there, I noticed that some of the streetcar track had been paved over in one of the intersections… which will make it even more difficult/expensive to bring back. The good news is that Seattle built a new streetcar line and is in the process of extending their streetcar network… but it’s a shame they’re letting all the existing historic streetcar infrastructure go to waste.

  3. $1.5 million for a 1 mile streetcar.

    Or in other words, for about 4% the cost of the proposed LA downtown streetcar. Not bad at all.

  4. $1.5 million for a 1 mile streetcar.

    Or in other words, for about 4% the cost of the proposed LA downtown streetcar. Not bad at all.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


How Long Will Dallas Take to Make a Better Bus Network?

A lot of cities and transit agencies have been inspired by Houston’s recent effort to overhaul its bus network with a grid of high-frequency routes. One of those cities is its neighbor to the north, Dallas. According to Brandon Formby at the Dallas Morning News’ Transportation Blog, DART is planning to redesign its bus network, with many of the same goals: transforming from […]

Wisconsin’s Highway Spending Mania Makes Less Sense Every Day

Wisconsin isn’t known as a state that makes smart use of transportation dollars, whether it’s Scott Walker rejecting federal funds for high-speed rail service, denying funds for what would have been Milwaukee’s first suburban commuter rail service, or cutting millions in state aid for transit. Now a new report from the Wisconsin Public Interest Research […]