Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
Federal Stimulus

Transit Jobs Nearly Twice as Cheap to Create as Roads — By Congress’ Math

During the first stimulus debate, House Democrats and the White House famously sparred over how quickly infrastructure money could be spent -- with the data later proving that transit was just as "shovel-ready" as roads, if not more so.

Shovel_ready.jpg(Photo: DMI Blog)

Now that transportation policymakers have turned to stemming the rising unemployment rate, three transit advocacy groups examined the age-old question of how many jobs are created per $1 billion of spending on transit versus roads.

But this study, conducted by the Center for Neighborhood Technology (CNT), Smart Growth America (SGA), and the U.S. Public Interest Research Groups, used numbers taken directly from the stimulus job-creation reports that every state sends to the House transportation committee.

According to the most recent report to Congress [PDF], 16,419 direct job-months were created by every $1 billion in transit aid. Roads lagged behind with 8,781 job-months created per $1 billion in stimulus aid.

SGA state policy director Will Schroeer said the study -- using jobs math endorsed by lawmakers as recently as last week -- sends a message to Congress that transit spending in the House jobs bill should be increased.

"If your goal, as it seems to be, is first to create jobs,
then your own data is saying we should be spending more on transit," Schroeer said in an interview.

It's important to note two factors that make today's study different from previous looks at infrastructure job creation.

The three groups looked only at direct jobs, not employment indirectly spurred by new transit and road work (sometimes referred to as the "multiplier effect"). The transit industry's estimate of as many as 36,000 jobs created by $1 billion of transit spending factors in that indirect hiring.

Also, the "job-months" designation refers to one month of work by one person, rather than one full-time, sustained job. That devilish detail has sparked controversy over the legitimacy of the White House's job-counting methods for the stimulus law, not just its transportation provisions.

Asked about the lingering uncertainty over job counting, Schroeer said the three groups conducting the study were not intending to test the viability of states' reports to Congress, merely to apply Democratic leaders' own jobs math to their stimulus spending patterns.

And on that score, transit would seem to come out ahead yet again.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Wednesday’s Headlines Are for the Children

From mothers with babies in strollers to preteens on bikes, much of the U.S. is hostile to families just trying to get around without a car.

July 2, 2025

Ambulance Data Reveals That Boston Drivers Are 4 Times More Likely to Run Over Pedestrians From Black Neighborhoods

"Overall, residents of predominantly Black and Latino neighborhoods are about four times more likely than residents of predominantly white neighborhoods to be struck as a pedestrian."

July 1, 2025

Tuesday’s Sprawling Headlines

Sprawl seems to be having a moment, but it remains a very shortsighted and environmentally disastrous way to solve the housing crisis.

July 1, 2025

Does Constant Driving Really Make Our Country Richer?

A new study reveals that constant driving is making America less productive and prosperous — and getting people on other modes could help right the ship.

July 1, 2025

This Threatened Toronto Bike Lane Gets More Rush Hour Traffic Than the Car Lane

Toronto leadership claim "no one bikes" on their cities' paths — but the data shows otherwise.

July 1, 2025
See all posts