Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In

Was the Auto Industry Bailout Legal? It’s Debatable, Oversight Panel Says

The Treasury Department sent $81 billion in taxpayer-subsidized aid to General Motors and Chrysler -- which is unlikely to be recouped in full -- using legal authority that "is the subject of considerable debate," according to a report released today [PDF] by the congressionally appointed bailout oversight panel.

3c7e114d_8a91_4fe2_904e_48142d17f617.jpgRon Bloom, the president's top manufaturing adviser. (Photo: AP via HuffPo)

The bailout legislation approved in October allowed Treasury to take over "troubled assets from any financial institution," but provided a very broad definition of the term.

That "ambiguity about congressional intent," the oversight panel stated, helped ensure that "Treasury has faced no effective challenge to its decision to use [bailout] funds for this purpose [of rescuing automakers]."

Media coverage of the report has focused on the panel's finding that GM and Chrysler would have to post an unprecedented financial turnaround in order to fully repay obligations to the government.

But the oversight panel isn't alone in concluding that taxpayers have a slim chance of recovering all their investments in the auto industry -- Ron Bloom, President Obama's chief manufacturing adviser, agrees.

From a footnote in the oversight panel's report:

During a meeting with Panel staff on August 11, 2009, Mr. Bloom explained that it was possible but unlikely that taxpayers would recover all of the money they had invested in Chrysler and General Motors. Mr. Bloom has acknowledged that “likely scenarios involve a reasonable probability of repayment of substantially all of the government funding for new GM and new Chrysler, and much lower recoveries for the initial loans.”

Those initial loans, the panel explained, are the $23.4 billion lent by Treasury to the pre-bankruptcy incarnations of the two struggling car companies.

So now that U.S. taxpayers have an inescapable stake in GM and Chrysler, what conditions should they expect the government to impose on the automakers?

The oversight panel, led by Harvard Law School professor Elizabeth Warren, urges Treasury to refine its multitude of potentially conflicting objectives for the auto bailout into a specific set of goals -- and provide that long-overdue legal justification for the $81 billion rescue.

Rep. Jeb Hensarling (R-TX), the only panel member to dissent from okaying today's report, released his own hard-hitting recommendations. One of them touches on issues of great concern to environmentally motivated bailout critics:

The management of Chrysler and GM should provide the American taxpayers with a quarterly business plan that addresses, without limitation, the following challenging issues:

  • Without a growing SUV market, how do Chrysler and GM plan to compete against the Asian and European manufacturers who have all but perfected the design and manufacture of well-built, fuel efficient cars? ...
  • How do Chrysler and GM plan to develop the design and technical expertise necessary to build vehicles with the fit-and-finish and price-point of, for example, a Honda Accord or Civic or a Toyota Camry or Corolla, not to mention a Toyota Prius?

Chrysler's statement to the panel offers an illuminating answer to Hensarling's first question. According to the company's proprietary surveys, "Americans feel that fuel prices will be, on average, $2.89 per gallon in one year and $4.50 in five years."

A poll released by IBM this month found that more than 50 percent of commuters would take a harder look at replacing driving with transit, biking, or walking if gas hit $4.50 per gallon. So Chrysler may well see its day of reckoning ... in five years.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Tuesday’s Headlines Are Running Hard

More political news: Today's top stories delve into Kamala Harris' record on climate change and Republicans' plans for the Trump administration if he returns to power.

July 23, 2024

State DOTs Could Fuel a Resurgence in Intercity Bus Travel

Private equity firms are killing off intercity bus companies. Will public agencies fill in the gaps?

July 23, 2024

GOP’s ‘Project 2025’ is ‘Based on a Lot of ignorance’

What does Transportation for America's Beth Osborne think of the transportation portion of the Heritage Foundation's playbook for a Trump presidency?

July 23, 2024

What a Surprise! Hochul’s Congestion Pricing Pause Helps Rich Suburban Drivers

Gov. Hochul's "little guys" certainly have big wallets. Meanwhile, the rest of us suffer with declining subway service and buses that are slower than walking. Thanks, Kathy.

July 22, 2024

Philadelphia Demands More Than ‘Flex-Post’ Protected Bike Lanes After Motorist Kills Cyclist

Pediatric oncologist Barbara Friedes was struck while biking on a "protected" path. Now, advocates are arguing that flex posts should be replaced with something far better.

July 22, 2024
See all posts