In Atlanta, Transit Service Lags Behind a Booming Population

atlanta-graph-ridership

“My commute has doubled in about four years,” Danielle Elkins, the vice president of Advance Atlanta, told me. “It can take an hour or an hour and a half to my office, when it used to take 20 to 25 minutes.”

Her experience is hardly unique. Since 2000, the Atlanta region has grown by more than 1.5 million people, or over 25 percent, but transit service is not keeping up. Both rail and bus ridership on MARTA, the major regional transit provider, have fallen dramatically in recent years.

gtr-main-logo-400In this post, which kicks off our “Getting Transit Right” series, we’ll examine the quality of transit service in Atlanta — what shaped the current transit network, and how well service patterns serve the needs of residents.

Atlanta transit does have some significant features going for it, including frequent rail service and an integrated transit card. But as we’ll see, there’s a big mismatch between the region’s employment centers and its bus and train networks, and access to convenient all-day service is limited.

A troubled history of transit investment and sprawl

In 1971, residents of Atlanta and DeKalb and Fulton counties voted to support the creation of MARTA. Funded by a 1-cent sales tax, the new agency would operate buses and lead the construction of a rail network with support from the federal government.

Foreshadowing future problems, the referendum was dogged by scare tactics from racist suburbanites, and it failed in Clayton, Cobb, and Gwinnett counties, which were excluded from the system from that point on.

While the transit system slowly expanded until 2000, and suburban Clayton, Cobb, and Gwinnett counties added bus service, a truly integrated regional transit system never materialized. Today, a system designed for the scale of the populated parts of the Atlanta region in 1970 has been overtaken by suburban growth. As the following maps illustrate, the region’s developed area has sprawled out dramatically across the counties surrounding Atlanta, onto previously undeveloped land (shown in gray).

atlanta-map-population-density-1970

atlanta-map-population-density-2015

The now-48-mile heavy rail system attracts more than 200,000 daily boardings, ridership that compares well relative to other southern cities. But only 8 percent of the population in the Atlanta region’s core counties lives within a mile of a rail station, down from 22 percent in 1970.

Atlanta transit service today

atlanta-map-transit-services

MARTA’s bus and rail operations serve Atlanta proper and most of the densely populated areas of DeKalb and Fulton Counties, with some service extending into Clayton County since 2014. Cobb and Gwinnett Counties have their own bus service, and commuter buses operated by GRTA extend along the region’s highway network, reaching far into the suburbs to places like Canton, 40 miles northeast from downtown.

The region’s major services all share one fare card, the Breeze, and riders who use it can transfer for free between most services. That’s a major convenience for people traveling throughout the region.

So is the frequency of service offered by MARTA trains. In the central segments of the system, trains are scheduled to arrive at least every 10 minutes all day, though service is less frequent on the branches.

atlanta-map-jobs-density-2014

The region’s largest employment clusters are arrayed along MARTA’s north-south lines. However, several dense job centers are not served by the rail system: Cumberland in Cobb County; Emory and the Centers for Disease Control in DeKalb County; Norwood in Gwinnett County; and Alpharetta in northern Fulton County (numbered on the map above). Bus service to those locations is also limited, and their distance from downtown complicates efforts to serve them by effective transit.

As the following map illustrates, very few of the region’s inhabitants — generally just those living around rail lines or in the center of Atlanta — have access to more than 50,000 jobs within a 30-minute transit trip:

atlanta-map-jobs-access-2014

Notably, people living in southeast Atlanta and central DeKalb are faced with long transit trips to most jobs in the region. But these are also the areas with the largest concentrations of people who regularly use transit (shown in blue and purple in the following map), as well as the highest share of African-American residents and people living in poverty. These areas have not seen significant transit expansions since the airport station at the far south end of the north-south rail line opened in 1988.

atlanta-map-transit-share-2015

Indeed, in the Atlanta urban area, while only 10.5 percent of people who drive alone to work have commutes over an hour each way, 44.8 percent of transit commuters do.

In general, transit is slow and infrequent for most people. Examples abound of buses that are few and far between. The route 36 bus that connects Midtown with Emory (two major job centers) arrives only every 45 minutes at best. Cobb County’s bus service doesn’t operate on Sundays. Express bus services from Cumming, northeast of downtown, depart three times per morning — in total.

Taking a closer look at service in Atlanta and the central suburbs, access to transit that arrives at least every 15 minutes during rush hour (the orange and red areas) is oriented mainly toward getting downtown:

atlanta-map-level-of-service-8-9

After the morning peak, frequent service becomes considerably more scarce, meaning transit isn’t well-suited for the full variety of trips that people want to make:

atlanta-map-level-of-service-12-13

Transit agencies in the Atlanta region receive no significant state funding for operations and until recently were hamstrung by the inability to raise additional funds. Because of a constitutional amendment, state gas tax revenues must be spent on roads and bridges only, and the state legislature has chosen to distribute virtually nothing through its general fund to transit (though it has spent some money on capital improvements recently).

After reaching a peak in 2009, MARTA transit service was reduced substantially. Those service cuts have been somewhat but not fully restored in the past few years. New demand-response services in the suburbs offered by ride-sharing companies like vRide also fill gaps, but they serve very few people per vehicle compared to buses or trains.

“The people who have felt the burden of this reduction in service are the people who depend most on it,” said Simon Berrebi, head of the advocacy group MARTA Army. “It’s important that we incorporate their needs.” Indeed, the cuts to MARTA were especially painful because the agency carries 94 percent of transit passengers in the region, though it accounts for 68 percent of regional service.

atlanta-graph-service-provided

Grading Atlanta transit service 

The MARTA system has a strong backbone but it’s showing its age. Atlanta transit services simply haven’t improved as the region has grown substantially in recent years.

atlanta-service-quality

Strengths

  • Frequent rail service can serve as an important rapid transit backbone for the region.
  • Fare cards grant access to most of the region’s transit services with free transfers.

Weaknesses

  • Transit service has not kept up with population growth.
  • Areas with the highest number of transit riders are not well-connected to major job clusters.
  • Frequent bus service is too sparse to be a reliable all-day travel option.

Coming next

In the upcoming articles about Atlanta, I’ll delve into how land use affects transit in the region, then discuss how future transit investments could change the landscape for residents by opening up access to more places.

  • USN VETERAN

    You refer to them as Marta I know them as the true Metropolitian ATLANTA SCREWUPTRANSIT AUTHORITY.
    1. They are NEVER on time. Buses or Trains
    2. They allow open drug dealing on their buses train’s train and bus stations
    3. Their police are to busy on their cell phones to do anything like security
    4. They ABANDON CITIZENS 1.5 miles from home in the dark at 02:00 AM. due to late train’s and when you report it to Maj. Smith and Capt Dorsey they say SO WHAT WE DO NOT CARE ABOUT THAT.
    5. The bus and train stations are ALWAYS FILTHLY
    6. When a masts employee threatens a citizen and reports it to the police they tell you they are NOT GOING TO DO ANYTHING.
    7. Bus operator commits 6 Georgia laws violations during driving a masta bus with citizen on it and it is reported again nothing is done
    8. Allow overcrowding on buses with senior citizens and BABIES on board
    OH MY AGNES WHY DON’ T WE USE masta?

  • Walter Crunch

    This is the same state that forces 14 year olds into the road by law. It’s illegal in all of the state to out a single wheel on a side path. Ever. Statewide. They call those Jim Crow laws. No matter if there are walkers or not, you get contacted by the police. It’s a great tool to harass black people.

    Sorry Atlanta, you own your disaster. Your sprawl is insane, your poverty is unchecked and you have stupid laws.

  • TakeFive

    Not everybody sees “sprawl” as evil. Please provide a source for where the law says minorities can’t live any where they wish?

  • TakeFive

    It’s fair to say that no form of transportation has kept up with population growth. They could and should provide much better transit options but it wasn’t until last year that they finally increased road and bridge funding, admittedly a preferred otion.

  • Bernard Finucane

    Sprawl has nothing to do with freedom, and everything to do with government subsidies.

  • TakeFive

    Sprawl has everything to do with freedom; it’s called the right to choose. BTW, I don’t advocate sprawl; it is what it is.

    Government subsidies are a myth and government reflects the wishes of the voters; it’s not some foreign boogie man.

  • Bernard Finucane

    Subsidies are only a myth when you get them, not other people, I suppose.

  • cqholt

    How much of the density drop in City of Atlanta between 1970 and 2015 has to do with AHA’s HOPE VI revitalization program, that razed all large-scale public housing projects?

  • cqholt

    The City of Atlanta is making transit improvements; recently passing 0.5% sales tax increase to fund transit-only projects and improvements in the city limits. So the blame rests more with the state and suburban counties.

ALSO ON STREETSBLOG

Transit Vote 2016: Atlanta May Finally Expand MARTA and Beef Up Bus Service

|
We continue our overview of what’s at stake in the big transit ballot initiatives this November with a look at Atlanta. Previous installments in this series examined Indianapolis, Seattle, and Detroit. Back in the 1970s, both Atlanta and Washington, D.C., received federal grants to build rail networks. After finishing the first wave of Metro construction, D.C. continued to invest, […]
The Garnett MARTA station in downtown Atlanta, surrounded by parking

A Fixation on Parking Threatens Transit Progress in Atlanta

|
Darin Givens is frustrated with how Atlanta is planning for the future. “We don’t feel like the city is building transit that fits needs, or places that fit transit,” says the founder of local advocacy site Thread ATL. “You see nodes of density nowhere near transit, located nowhere near a MARTA station or a regular MARTA bus. We’re not matching development and transit.”

Transit Vote 2016: Raleigh’s Chance to Grow Smarter

|
We continue our overview of what’s at stake in the big transit ballot initiatives this November with a look at Wake County, North Carolina. Previous installments in this series examined Indianapolis, Seattle, Detroit, and Atlanta. Ask Wake County Commissioner Sig Hutchinson how Raleigh’s transit system is currently functioning, and he doesn’t sugarcoat it. “I just really don’t think we’ve got […]

$8 Billion Expansion of Atlanta Transit Clears First Hurdle

|
Atlanta’s regional transit network, MARTA, isn’t known as a dynamic, growing system. While cities as varied as D.C., Minneapolis, and Houston have rolled out new high-capacity transit routes, MARTA has stagnated. But has MARTA’s moment finally come? The prospects of major transit improvements for the region are looking more hopeful today than they have for a generation. Last week a Georgia […]

6 Transportation Ballot Initiatives to Watch Next Tuesday

|
Next week, voters in Maryland and Wisconsin may tell state officials to keep their greedy paws off transportation funds. Louisianans will consider whether to create an infrastructure bank to help finance projects. Texans will weigh the wisdom of raiding the state’s Rainy Day Fund for — what else? — highways. And Massachusetts activists who have […]