Skip to Content
Streetsblog USA home
Streetsblog USA home
Log In
DOT

THE BRAKE: Should Cities Train Their Own Transportation Advocates?

Anyone who's ever tried to get a new crosswalk in their neighborhood knows how hard it can be just to figure out who to call — never mind how to get whoever's on the other end of the line to listen. And any transportation professional knows how challenging it can be to get that call from a resident, and realize that they don't have the faintest idea of how decisions actually get made on our streets.

But what if cities offered a crash course that got both groups speaking the same language — and in the process, transformed ordinary citizens into effective and well-informed transportation advocates?

Today on The Brake, we welcome Keith Bartholomew of University of Utah and Nathan McNeil of Portland State University, who are hoping to bring the concept of the "Citizen Transportation Academy" to communities across the U.S. We talked about a more than 25-year-old course has helped shape the transportation conversation in Portland, Ore., how Salt Lake City is adapting the idea for its unique landscape, and what it says about U.S. transportation culture that residents even need a 10-week class to have a real voice — and what to do about it.

Give it a listen, and be sure to check out the beta version of McNeil's curriculum handbook if you're curious about starting a class in your town.

Here's a short excerpt from our conversation. It has been lightly edited for clarity and length. 

Kea Wilson: For folks who haven't been there, or aren't giant dorks like me, what are the unique challenges of adapting this curriculum which was made for a place that has a reputation as an active transportation hub — Portland — for Salt Lake City? What is your landscape like and what sorts of questions are people asking about it?

Keith Bartholomew: Well, you have to start with the ground truth that the Salt Lake City region has a population that's roughly equivalent to Portland. But it's spread out across about four times the amount of land. And so it's highly dispersed, which, by necessity makes it much more automobile oriented. So that's an obvious difference.

But really, that difference didn't show up so much in the curriculum or in the class, or the way it rolled out — no pun intended. Because the the class itself is just a structure; it's just saying, "here are the things that are happening in your region with respect to transportation planning, and transportation decision making, and here's how it flows, and here are the people who are involved in making it flow. And here are the criteria that they're responding to when they are making those decisions. And here are the places in that process where regular community members — citizens in the neighborhoods  — can get involved and have a say.

And that structure, the specifics of the answers to all those questions, and how you fill in those details — that's going to vary from region to region. However, there is actually more that's similar from region to region than different. Part of that is creature of federal law; every metropolitan area in the country has to have a metropolitan planning organization that creates a long range plan. And we now have about 380-some-odd MPOs across the country, and they're creating plans that respond to criteria that come from the federal government, and local governments are interacting with these MPOs. So yeah, there are differences from California to Utah to Oregon to Illinois. However, when you when you peel back the first layer of the onion, you start to see really common themes showing up again, and again.

Stay in touch

Sign up for our free newsletter

More from Streetsblog USA

Wednesday’s Headlines Have a System

The safe systems approach to street design, popular in Europe, could cut U.S. traffic deaths in half.

May 21, 2025

Does Transportation Advocacy Have a Place In the Wake of a Deadly Tornado?

Much of St. Louis is struggling in the wake of a deadly tornado. Amid such disasters, urbanism needs a pause and a rethink.

May 21, 2025

Tuesday’s Headlines Show Elections Have Consequences

"Woke" transit agencies need not apply for federal grants now that father of nine Sean Duffy is in charge.

May 20, 2025

Should We Treat the Local Bus As a Basic Right?

There's a way of framing public transit that makes the bus a useful mobility tool for everyone: as a moving extension of the sidewalk network.

May 20, 2025

Op-Ed: Public Transportation is Key to Social Mobility

"As wealth inequality grows and social mobility becomes more difficult, people without access to mobility will be left behind."

May 19, 2025

Car Harms Monday: Machines Took Over Cities and Left Humans in the Dust

There isn't enough physical space for every single household to store its fleet of personal vehicles in front of the home, nor is there space for everyone to drive at the same time. So let's fix that.

May 19, 2025
See all posts